I used to fish opossum before they drained it to fix the dam a few years ago, that was pretty productive, Little Buffalo isn't a bad choice either, you also have Letterkenny which is stocked with trout, and Laurel Lake is out your way too which has trout as well, but like with any lake it may take you a trip or 2 to get on some fish but most guys are helpful on the ice and might give you a spot or 2 to try, good luck!