Honestly, I bet nobody gets them all. It wouldn't be very sporting if that were the case. I have heard many old timers say to wait for the second run the fish makes, but honestly, I don't. I take it as soon as I see the spool turning. I would rather take a shot early and miss, than have the majority of my fish gut hooked. I guess it's preference, but I would err on the side of fish preservation and limit kills (unless you're going to eat it, of course). Good luck!