I have had an HT polar escape magnum for about 5 or 6 years now and I like it....it's not fancy but I bought it on sale and the price was right(can't remember how much). I was much bigger when I bought it and needed the extra room( 6'4 and 285 lbs) it provided over a 1man shelter--now my wife or son and grandson go with me so I'm glad I bought it. only problem I had was with the 3-legged chairs that came with it----but, at that weight,most cheap lawn chairs were a problem with me. I had a mouse make a home in it about the 2nd year I had it so now I have a 1in. peek hole in the door flap
Now I hang it from the rafters in my shed for the off-season.
Just my 2cts.--no doubt there are better and worse but,for what I spent and the service recieved, I've been well satisfied. Good luck in your decision.
Tombo