Jonesy is right about Crane Marsh being over fished. It was good the first year they let you fish it but after some guy's took 5gal bucket after 5gal bucket out it went down hill fast! I have only kept 2 fish from there and they both had firm white flesh. I can't say if they tasted bad I cooked them up with fish from James and George. But no one eating them said "YUCK"! LOL