I've had a sportcat for about 2 years now. Works ok in my single man fish trap if it is not real cold. I'm thinking about trading up, but haven't decide on what. As far as a smell, you might get a little odor when you first light her up, but not enough of a stink to be unbearable or run you out of the shack. I would suggest running a small cannister of propane through her to break it in and then see what you think. Good luck!