After trying many different styles and the materials, the one that has worked the best for me is Windstopper Polar Fleece. Light weight with the great ability of retaining heat even wet (like wool, without the down sides), washable, VERY durable and best of all windproof! I have one pair from Orvis that are 16 hard used years old (sadly they are starting to get a little thinner). I have had the ones with neoprene palms and found them not as warm. If you want warm, make sure it is a wind blocking/stopping fabric, it make a huge difference...