Wore my new Cabelas Predator Extreme Pac boots for the first time last Sat. Like you, my feet normally freeze, but they stayed warm all day this time. They are a bit heavy and stiff, but I adjusted to the weight pretty quickly and hope they will break in a bit. I also had my XXXL Stabilicers strapped on them. So far I'm a happy camper.
I don't have any experience with the other style that you mentioned.
-Jeff