I'm an avid ice fisherman and i would have to say that if your looking for Pike i would try Lake Mohawk...I caught a 60'' in the summer and have already landed 2-35'' inchers through the ice. Its a private lake so it might be hard without knowing someone. I fish Atwood a lot and i know if ur in the right place at the right time its a very succesful lake...we did really good early ice...40-50 fish a day.