Go smaller not worth it if your dragging by hand. I have the x2 and I got caught up on how great it is with the room, comfort, and ceiling height. Through experience I have learned lighter is better. When the ice gets thick enough, I pull it with my machine, and a friend is with me, it is great to have. The majority of the time I prefer to stay light. The other thing to think about is the x2 + other gear= total weight to have to pick up and put in a truck bed or trailer. A truck bed is high to lift all that weight especially if your fishing alone. Most likely you will be like me and also buy something to drag out by hand, for me in early and late season with thinner ice. I have found that the drag out to fish isnt so bad, the drag back is brutal.