It’s OK to post anything that would be an advantage to ice fishing in PA. Mentioning draw downs, news, map info, lake access info, lake info, anything like that is OK. If people are posting open water fishing reports then they should go to
www.myfishfinder.com. That site was designed exactly like Iceshanty for just that very purpose, to post open water fishing. If everyone did that then the traffic on that site would be up as well. The other option for them is to use the off topic section of iceshanty. When someone sees a post about a lake looking for something that can help them on the ice only to find out that someone is posting an open water spring time crappie report, how is that useful to ice fishing? This is a recent phenomenon too, not the intent of the site.