i prefer a smaller sized 4''-6'' natural sucker sized and colored decoy. golden sucker is the second choice. perch color and size is my third choice. red head-white body sucker is choice #4. no matter what decoy i use, the pectoral fins need to be painted white for flash/contrast, top and bottom.
.
i have the chance to spear burbot and whitefish while after pike. the bigger decoys tend to scare the ''other fish''.
.
i've never felt ''undergunned'' using a smaller decoy.
.