The cottages were awesome. Heat, hot water, spacious and comfortable....I think we will be back unless we decided to find an airbnb near redwood and the lakes. The fishing was so-so as we caught a lot of fish (10" of clear ice on LOTI) - but man did the weather take a turn for the horrible. Several days in a row when you realize that whole 'shelter' think is one of the elements for survival. We never made it out on Eel as the boat launch wasn't plowed, it was stupid cold and the wind was blowing....certainly not howling but at -16 ambient a bird passing gas will cut through you.
Being there the bay is inaccessible unless you were to scamper down with a bucket and the auger (mabye). Probably a 20 foot descent through brush, small trees and rocks. Regardless the cottages were great and I think I will be trying them again - though not next weekend as they are all sold out.