I've wondered how jack trap styles will do with less ice. When the ice is 3' thick, the hole acts as a guide, and it doesn't matter. When the ice is 6" thick, I can see some tangles happening. The HT Arctic bay seems to be good quality. Bait under 6" should be no problem, any bigger, and you may need some modifications. If you just want you tip up visible, you can attach a dowel to a regular tip up easy.