Please welcome Eyoyo Underwater Fishing Cameras.https://amzn.to/3siEgXn
First light and last light is best for me as well, however first light seems to take the cake.Also, I get probably equal amount of rainbows on a deadstick rod as I do jigging. I never use spoons and always use jigs of some kind. Maybe I have equal success because each person can fish with 6 rods where I am . I usually fish 15-30 FOW but sometimes will set a pole in less then 10 feet. Caught 3 rainbows yesterday (slow day). 2 were on my "jigging pole" in 21 FOW. One I had to reel up to about 5 feet from the ice and he came back and whacked it. Another came up from the bottom and whacked it while it was sitting there. I of course wasn't ready. Picked up my pole and jigged it a few times, he hit it again and i missed him...then i had to mess with him a little bit before he hit it a third time and I was able to get him.My other was on my deepest deadstick rod on the bottom, in about 30 FOW. 2 fish were twins at 20" and the other was 18".Here's a picture of the 2 biggest.(Image removed from quote.)
I like to run a dead stick with either a piece of shrimp or a salted frozen minnow on either a small jig a small hook and splitshot, and the other rod pumping a jigging spoon all day long. I tend to focus on 10' or less of water and find gravel bottom to be what I target the most. That or weedlines. This one came on the deadstick with shrimp just as the sun was setting. (Image removed from quote.)
My 2 cents. Mix up the bait. I have had success on icicles, trout worms(or crawlers),waxies and hellgramites. . I have had great success deadsticking with northland forage minnow tipped with a waxie or icicle. Ice flies work too. Shallow water at first light under the ice has been most productive. 3 foot mono leader with circle or treble hooks. I use the smallest split shot I can find about 12 -18inch's above the bait.