Otter pro cabin vs clam Yukon x (cabelas one)

[eyes11]

Otter pro 1200 cabin=$849
Clam Yukon x (cabelas label on outside)=$749
But clam comes with cover,  LEDS, and battery tray.

Is the otter worth the extra jack?  I know the sled is a little better and the fabric is thicker.  Anyone have the new clam that can speak of quality

[XN]

I can't speak for the new clams but went from a Yukon TC to a otter pro cabin and would never go back! The fabric is so much better than the clam stuff IMO.

[cwavs1982]

I have the Yukon Thermal and love it.  Fits what I want to do.  I don't see the need for extra spending on the Otter, and I looked at the Otter Pro when I got my Yukon.  Thermal is the way to go no matter which you choose.  Its well built, light enough for me to pull.  I don't have an ATV, so its man power out to the holes.  This is a Ford/Chevy kind of thing.  If they keep adding weight to the insulation, we won't have any room to fish inside. 

[perch_stalker]

I was looking this year at the Clam vs Otter, and after much deliberation, and research, I decided to go with the Otter XT Pro Lodge. I couldn't be happier. The quality of the fabric. sled and the square tubing support bars are FAR SUPERIOR to the Clam. But if you're looking to save money, the Clam would probably work. But if money isn't a huge option, and you want the best quality, It's Otter without question! I made a custom center counsel for my shack that holds a battery, and I have switches wired in and run lights for the shack that way. You can find led light strips on ebay or amazon for real cheap. Best of luck in which ever shack you choose!

[crappie55409]

its pretty much a scientific fact that otter is better but without going into the details, cause we all know them, one thing to consider as well is resale value.  Ive known people that have sold their otter setups years later for more than they have into them.  cant say the same about Clam

[Mittenman]

I was just in the Cabelas store near me in MI they have the Otter Pro Lodge on sale right now for $809.99 now thru the 23rd. The online store still list it at the regular price of around $950. If you have a retail store near you it would be worth it to give them a call.

[Rags777]

Also own an otter and quality is top notch, in my opinion

[BBQMAN]

I have two Otters one Lodge and just bought a Hideout. The quality is unmatched. They cost more but you get more. I have had a clam and a Frabil both good products but no where the quality of Otter. Just my two cent.

[Leather]

I dont know why people are talking about the LODGE???  The man said CABIN!!  I understand the OP.  These two are very similar. FYI I do not own a flip over and never have and Planning to pull the trigger on one this year and I have been throwing these to shelters around myself.
  Throwing the Lodge in there doesnt help the guy out one bit. 
 the Yukon X and the Pro Cabin.  My friend just bough a Yukon X this week and just set it up.  I went over last night to check it out.  Its very nice and I like that they beefed up the support poles to 1.25".  The seats are very nice and the grey interior of the sled helps with lighting. 
SO... I go home and start doing research.
#1 Both shelters are almost the same weight empty.
#2 Clam 20 sq feet - Otter 22 sq feet
#3 Both shelters are the same height
#4 Both Shelters have swivel seats
#5 Both have doors in the back and front

Now here is the big difference.
#1  Clam only had 600 denier fabric  ---- Otter has 1200 denier fabric!
#2 Clam is $700--Otter is $850
#3 Clam has grey interior sled---Otter does not

So, the Otter has better insulating value ( double the amount ) and from what i hear a stronger sled. Go with the clam and only save $150 and a grey interior sled.

I think I would spend a $150 more for 1200 denier over 600. I would spend more money and be warmer than to have a grey sled and be a bit colder.
I think I am going to pull the trigger on the Otter.  But till then, I am going to wait for a sale only because i am in no hurry.

[Monticatgeek]

to get 1200 Denier fabric in a Clam you need to go with a X200 thermal and if you want a industry all time high thickness of 1800 denier then you would need to go with the X200 pro thermal. the only other close option in the Clam line up would be the new for this year Stealth Voyager X and the new redesigned Jason Mitchell Thermal X. these are both 900 Denier fabric.

[TheCrappieFisherman]

I read somewhere that a 600 denier fabric vs a 1200 denier fabric doesn't have a difference when it comes to retaining heat.  Denier just refers to fiber thickness in the threads used, not a measurement of warmth.  So if this is correct, a higher denier only means the canvas is more durable, not warmer.   

I know for sure Otter uses the same amount of insulation in their xt series (600 denier) as their pro series (1200 denier). 

[Monticatgeek]

I read somewhere that a 600 denier fabric vs a 1200 denier fabric doesn't have a difference when it comes to retaining heat.  Denier just refers to fiber thickness in the threads used, not a measurement of warmth.  So if this is correct, a higher denier only means the canvas is more durable, not warmer.   

I know for sure Otter uses the same amount of insulation in their xt series (600 denier) as their pro series (1200 denier).

you are right it is not about warmth mostly  but were the higher denier counts the most is in the durability and the ability to stop wind from penetrating the material which indirectly makes it some what warmer.

[crappie55409]

i may be mistaken but i think otter went to a grey interior sled this year.

[Mittenman]

i may be mistaken but i think otter went to a grey interior sled this year.

Yes they did. The Pro models all have grey tubs now.

[gonehunting]

Otter Pro XT Lodge regular price $750 plus in store only at L&M Fleet Supply in MN.  Won't find cheaper other than maybe the St. Paul Ice Show at Reeds.

[eyes11]

I am leaning towards the otter and before i walked into cabelas was the only shack i was even looking at but that clam caught my eye due to the length and being able to fit it into the back of a short bed.  I like the hammocks under the chairs on the clam and that fact that it comes with a light bar and cover.  I just know i would get a better sled and a better shell with otter.

[cwavs1982]

Eyes11 - that was the same situation I was in when I got my Yukon Thermal.  Needed to fit in my truck with the bed cover on.  I figured I could use the savings on other items that I wanted.  Good luck with your choice.  Either way - It will get cold, and someone will be fishing somewhere.....

[El Matador]

Just some clarification on the fabric...1200d fabric is NOT twice as thick as 600d.  Denier is a measurement of how much the thread weighs, not the fabric itself.   This can be deceptive because other fabrics are measured by the weight of the actual fabric (such as 12.0 oz canvas, which weighs 12.0 oz per square yard).  If you increase the diameter of the thread by roughly 1.4x you will double its weight.  While the larger thread is in fact twice as heavy it's also wider, meaning fewer threads per inch.  So, in reality, 1200d is about 40% thicker than 600d.

[filetandrelease]

Denier is a unit of measurement that is used to determine the fiber thickness of individual threads or filaments used in the creation of textiles and fabrics. Fabrics with a high denier count tend to be thick, sturdy, and durable. Fabrics with a low denier count tend to be sheer, soft, and silky.

[XN]

FYI the pro model tubs were gray last year on the otters.

The only advantage I think the clam has over the otter is it seemed easier to pull

[bulldawger]

Will the Otter Pro Cabin fit in a 5 1/2 foot bed ?

[cwavs1982]

Will the Otter Pro Cabin fit in a 5 1/2 foot bed ?

Here are the dimensions from the Otter site: It's gonna be tight, might be able to:

COLLAPSED DIMENSIONS   
66″ L x 36″ D x 20″ H
SETUP DIMENSIONS   
66″ L x 84″ D x 70.5″ H

[Salmonquest]

I don't think it will fit. I have to leave my tailgate down.

The otter cabin is a beast to pull. Any slush and you aren't getting it out without a machine.

Smitty helps but it's still a heck of a pull.

Love the quality but to be honest I wish I would have spent a lot less on a cheaper sled. Yes the quality would be less but I could have built a "permanent" shanty that was somewhat protable and had a cheap light portable for running and gunning. And paid less. I don't feel it was worth it.

[tracksnorth]

Otter hands down

[bulldawger]

I don't think it will fit. I have to leave my tailgate down.

The otter cabin is a beast to pull. Any slush and you aren't getting it out without a machine.

Smitty helps but it's still a heck of a pull.

Love the quality but to be honest I wish I would have spent a lot less on a cheaper sled. Yes the quality would be less but I could have built a "permanent" shanty that was somewhat protable and had a cheap light portable for running and gunning. And paid less. I don't feel it was worth it.

yeah i'm leaning to the yukon thanks