Visit the Team Iceshanty Proshop
I myself like whatever is the lightest and easiest to pull, load in the truck, store, and also keeps me outta the wind and fits all my crap and some beers etc... I dont need a lot of extra room and a comfortable seat. Thats why I use a shappell rover 1.0. Does it feel cramped sometimes? Yes. Do I still catch fish and stay warm? Yes. Do I look at other guys that are lugging around their heavy ass big and roomy shanties and think how glad thats not me? Yes. The current shappell models like the rovers are called fx100's I think. So I vote shappell fx100.
I've got the scout xl thermal and absolutely love it. Pulls great and the full thermal is the way to go. Little buddy heater keeps it nice and toasty.