IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

Iowa => Ice Fishing Iowa => Topic started by: duckaholic76 on Feb 15, 2016, 02:12 PM

Title: Limit question
Post by: duckaholic76 on Feb 15, 2016, 02:12 PM
I'm taking my stepson up to Okoboji this weekend and I can't remember if he can catch his own limit of fish or if it goes against mine. He is only 9 years old
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: dcmod25 on Feb 15, 2016, 02:56 PM
15 and under can have there own limit in iowa without a license. good luck
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Mr.Seaguar on Feb 15, 2016, 03:15 PM
Follow up question, has anyone ever asked the DNR about redear sunfish?  The regs do not clarify that.  It lists pumpkinseed though.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: duckaholic76 on Feb 15, 2016, 04:19 PM
Thank you I thought that was the case but I couldn't remember for sure
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Kevin23 on Feb 15, 2016, 07:19 PM
Kids get their own limit of all fish except trout. Trout count against your limit unless you get them a trout stamp.

There is no limit of redear, green, or orange spotted sunfish. Just bluegill and pumpkinseed. This is new wording, it used to say "sunfish and their hybrids"
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: dekalbnick on Feb 15, 2016, 07:37 PM
Not to Hyjack this thread, but what about fishing in two or 3 states in the same day.  Can a person have a limit of the same species in each one??
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Kevin23 on Feb 15, 2016, 08:07 PM
Yes. Just cant have over a states limit in posession at a lake.  For instance if i have an IL license i can go to a lake in IL and keep a limit then come back to Iowa and toss the fish in the freezer and go catch an IA limit. I cannot take the IL limit with me to an IA lake and then keep more fish, the DNR would have no way of knowing where they were caught. I hope that makes sense?

You can NOT keep a daily limit from two bodies of water in the same state on the same day. I cant go to lost grove and keep 25 gills then go to the river and get 25 more.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: ICEHOUND22 on Feb 16, 2016, 04:27 PM
Does the rule of a kid keeping his own limit also apply to out of state line license  holders? I have a friend from out of state wanting to bring his kids to boji to fish and I didn't see anything in the regs that specifically stated so? Thanks for any help.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Kevin23 on Feb 16, 2016, 04:47 PM
same laws apply to non res fishing in iowa.

You can call the DNR and ask them with any questions regarding regulations. you can also call your local conservation officer as well, the phone numbers are in the back of the regulations booklet.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: SDPerchPounder on Feb 17, 2016, 12:36 PM
3 limits from 3 states in one day? Might not hurt to throw a few back if you every find yourself in that scenario..
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Ice_Fly_Guy on Feb 18, 2016, 07:29 AM
3 limits from 3 states in one day? Might not hurt to throw a few back if you every find yourself in that scenario..

No kidding.  I would never want to clean that many fish at once.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: dekalbnick on Feb 18, 2016, 10:45 AM
I didn't say that was my plan but have fished MN and IA in the same day.  And if its walleyes it wouldn't be that many fish to clean.  Also, don't worry I let a lot of fish go every year.  I keep plenty too, but I always release a lot.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: 26perch on Feb 18, 2016, 12:48 PM
you haven't fished very much for yellow bass
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: dekalbnick on Feb 18, 2016, 09:57 PM
you haven't fished very much for yellow bass
e

.???  I haven't fished much for yellow bass?  2000+ yellows in the last three years isn't fishing yellow bass much?  I've fished them a lot. Open water and hard water. Also won the YBB at clear lake last year and we placed 7th this year and 5th two years ago. Trust me I know a thing or two about yellow bass.......
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: dcmod25 on Feb 19, 2016, 08:08 AM
pretty sure he was talking about blake saying he wouldnt want clean that many fish
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Mr.Seaguar on Feb 19, 2016, 09:01 AM
pretty sure he was talking about blake saying he wouldnt want clean that many fish

Maybe, but it was funnier this way
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Ice_Fly_Guy on Feb 19, 2016, 09:32 AM
Who said anything about yellow bass?  ??? 
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: 26perch on Feb 19, 2016, 12:08 PM
sorry dekalbnick if you thought I was talking about you  just meant that if you haven't fished yellow bass  it's nothing to clean 50-75 at a time
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Ice_Fly_Guy on Feb 21, 2016, 10:14 AM
Just because I don't keep 100 fish doesn't mean I haven't caught them. I used to catch 100's on some days at Black Hawk before they killed it off. The last thing I wanna do after fishing all day is clean a bucket full. That's just me.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: dekalbnick on Feb 21, 2016, 12:45 PM
sorry dekalbnick if you thought I was talking about you  just meant that if you haven't fished yellow bass  it's nothing to clean 50-75 at a time

Ok, no problem
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Mr.Seaguar on Feb 21, 2016, 05:48 PM
Just because I don't keep 100 fish doesn't mean I haven't caught them. I used to catch 100's on some days at Black Hawk before they killed it off. The last thing I wanna do after fishing all day is clean a bucket full. That's just me.

That's why I pay the bait shop and encourage others to do the same. 
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: 26perch on Feb 21, 2016, 08:03 PM
wish we had somebody to do it winter put ice on them till am summer the DNR or the Clear Lake Fishing Club has a fish cleaning station    Always leave a donation
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Mr.Seaguar on Feb 21, 2016, 09:01 PM
You could do it. A few high school kids, some electric knives and Skin zits and you are golden. Once you find a facility, that is.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: 26perch on Feb 22, 2016, 06:06 AM
live 40 mi from lake & where do you find hs kids that want to work today
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 17, 2016, 09:08 PM
3 limits from 3 states in one day? Might not hurt to throw a few back if you every find yourself in that scenario..

I've done it with walleye...was a long early & late day. SD, MN, & Iowa. Was sheer luck and doubt it will ever happen again.  Between going with different friends, the bite being on, and timing just working out for it to happen it was like winning the power ball lol. Ended up giving/donating most the fish to a fundraiser fish fry. Which was kinda most the reason it happened. Everybody was kinda fishing to help get fish for the fundraiser so they didn't have to buy so much.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Bates on Aug 21, 2016, 11:54 AM
So agronomist you drive to 3 different states in one day and catch a limit of walleyes at each state only to give away?  Well way too go, I wish I had that much time and money to waste. Why even go? Just to brag on the www in the middle of summer on a ice fishing forum.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: GB 83 on Aug 21, 2016, 06:13 PM
You know if someone wants to buy 3-5 fishing licenses and pay that out of state fee. Then do all that traveling to catch fish and give it away. 🤔Hmmmm He has that right. Giving fish away to elderly people, food drive, fundraiser or just giving me to people who love to eat fish but are afraid of water (cause they can swim) or the people who are afraid of the ice (cause they don't to fall through) Many way of catching fish and giving em away..... is sometime the right thing to do and it makes you feel good that you can.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 21, 2016, 09:02 PM
So agronomist you drive to 3 different states in one day and catch a limit of walleyes at each state only to give away?  Well way too go, I wish I had that much time and money to waste. Why even go? Just to brag on the www in the middle of summer on a ice fishing forum.

Yeah I did. I can be in 3 different states within an hour.. It's called a hobbie. Why else would I go. I doubt I can ever justify the cost of my boat, wheel house shack, 4 wheeler, portable, or $1,000's of dollars of gear.  ???  I didn't try or plan to hit 3 states. Just happened by chance, and happened because we were all fishing for a cause. Donated fish for the fish fry bought a lot of gifts for children during the holidays....can't say that was a bad deal.  I usually donate quite a few fish to fundraisers. I enjoy fishing, and I harvest fish Within my legal rights. I usually try to harvest "eater" 14in fish, and let the larger ones go. So why do you fish?
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 21, 2016, 09:09 PM
You know if someone wants to buy 3-5 fishing licenses and pay that out of state fee. Then do all that traveling to catch fish and give it away. 🤔Hmmmm He has that right. Giving fish away to elderly people, food drive, fundraiser or just giving me to people who love to eat fish but are afraid of water (cause they can swim) or the people who are afraid of the ice (cause they don't to fall through) Many way of catching fish and giving em away..... is sometime the right thing to do and it makes you feel good that you can.

I get a SD, MN, and IA fishing license every year. I don't think it is really uncommon for people in this area to do so.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Buckshots on Aug 21, 2016, 09:20 PM
I usually get a MN and SD license on top of my Iowa license every year too. I know a lot of folks that do up here in the NW corner of Iowa.

Agro, congrats on the tri-state limit. Haters gonna hate... Rhythms with Bates...

I eat fish maybe once or twice a month. I spend a lot of money on fishing and I let a lot of fish go. I'd rather let them go than give them away. I do give some away, but I'd rather not clean fish than clean them and let them sit in the deep freeze for over a year. I just enjoy fishing is all.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 21, 2016, 09:45 PM
I usually get a MN and SD license on top of my Iowa license every year too. I know a lot of folks that do up here in the NW corner of Iowa.

Agro, congrats on the tri-state limit. Haters gonna hate... Rhythms with Bates...

I eat fish maybe once or twice a month. I spend a lot of money on fishing and I let a lot of fish go. I'd rather let them go than give them away. I do give some away, but I'd rather not clean fish than clean them and let them sit in the deep freeze for over a year. I just enjoy fishing is all.

I kinda just keep and harvest them, then usually have a fish fry for family and a few friends. Once Dec. hits any fish I have in my freezer goes to the fish fry fundraisers to help get presents for kids for Christmas. I guess I've more then likely ate fish I've caught going to the fish fry......and paid a 2nd time to eat them....lol.....at least I didn't have to cook them.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: GB 83 on Aug 22, 2016, 09:58 AM
Agronomist, living in this area. I have My KS... OK, IA, SD, ND, MI.... And will get MN too this yr. How does that old saying go...you pay to play.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 22, 2016, 01:14 PM
Agronomist, living in this area. I have My KS... OK, IA, SD, ND, MI.... And will get MN too this yr. How does that old saying go...you pay to play.

Pretty much.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Bates on Aug 22, 2016, 07:04 PM
I don't care how many non-resident licenses someone gets I have more than I need also. I can't stand people who have to come on a forum to pat themselves on the back about something they have done. If you really wanted to help your charity why didn't you line up some ponds that need thinned out instead of a few small walleye. Your "eater" size walleye is not 14", it's what you can catch at the time, ie: your under 14" walleyes this spring you had to show off. Maybe I need to list everything I own and all the out of state fishing license I have,  nope. 
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Buckshots on Aug 22, 2016, 08:22 PM
So if someone catches a limit of perch or walleyes and post it online or catches a monster perch and posts it, well you just can't stand that??  Agro didn't start this thread to pay himself on the back, heck, he didn't even start this thread!

I'm pretty proud of myself when I go out and have an awesome day of fishing. Thats why we all do it. And when others do good or have a great day, I enjoy hearing/reading about it. I think we all do.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 22, 2016, 09:23 PM
I don't care how many non-resident licenses someone gets I have more than I need also. I can't stand people who have to come on a forum to pat themselves on the back about something they have done. If you really wanted to help your charity why didn't you line up some ponds that need thinned out instead of a few small walleye. Your "eater" size walleye is not 14", it's what you can catch at the time, ie: your under 14" walleyes this spring you had to show off. Maybe I need to list everything I own and all the out of state fishing license I have,  nope.

Oh your that guy off the other site. Dude get a life. Why are you on any of these forums? All you do is talk crap and belittle people on the forums. Get a life. It's pricks like you that cause people not to share and enjoy these forums. LMAO, your still trying to claim the walleye I caught weren't 14in.......that's just funny....like it even matters......Look I know you're one of those guys that can't catch fish and it just digs at you when others do.....please get over your childish acts and try to enjoy the sport. Here I got another pic of a limit I got this weekend......oh oh oh it's magic 😀


(http://i132.photobucket.com/albums/q1/agronomist_at_IA/A49BDC33-B845-46F1-90B8-40D7FD79E9C3_zpsbkuvdlpo.jpg)
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 22, 2016, 09:27 PM
So if someone catches a limit of perch or walleyes and post it online or catches a monster perch and posts it, well you just can't stand that??  Agro didn't start this thread to pay himself on the back, heck, he didn't even start this thread!

I'm pretty proud of myself when I go out and have an awesome day of fishing. Thats why we all do it. And when others do good or have a great day, I enjoy hearing/reading about it. I think we all do.

Don't waste your time trying to talk common sense to this troll.  She's a bitter old internet troll, and wants to fight with people. Now that I know who it is I'm just going to use the block function on the site for her.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: squ1rr31_ on Aug 22, 2016, 11:15 PM
Ok folks, back on topic. I notice you have a leech lake knife there Agron.
Title: Re: Limit question
Post by: Agronomist_at_IA on Aug 23, 2016, 12:40 AM
Ok folks, back on topic. I notice you have a leech lake knife there Agron.

Yeah I do. The one in the pic is actually my buddies. I'll give credit the leech lake knifes are great. My wife got it for me back in 2007 for a birthday gift.  I found I don't really use mine much though. Tend to use the Mr.Twister or Storm electric.