Once you get how to adjust the spring tension for various wind conditions, I think you will like the Windlass a lot. Hole placement can vary also. On a windy day I will place the metal "fin" (that catches the wind) on the side away from the wind. This will impart the jigging action, without allowing gusts to raise the arm upright. On really calm days I have placed the fin to face the wind, so even the slightest breeze will jig the bait.
I use the Windlass to impart motion for smaller minnows, looking for Perch, Gills and etc. Have caught Pickerel on these as well. Have not been in Pike or Walleye water. I have heavier duty Polar Tip Ups that I use for Pickerel and the larger fishies.
Be prepared for some early frustration on the first few set ups. But in my limited experience, set up will become easy after the first couple of trips.
-Reelcharacter