I have fished all of them. Crooked was a lot of very small pike. Didn't find a perch. Pretty stained water.
Lawrence was the easiest to fish and find them just using a depth chart. All the pike were small. Some of the perch were okay. You could keep some 8-10 inchers is one was so inclined.
Island has the most promise and the biggest lake of the three. Caught one decent pike, some okay perch, and seen some whites but didn't catch any.