So thanks to Deal Ninja I picked up a pair of the Baffin Shackleton. I wear size 9 in everything and went with 10 in these. I have been wearing the Cabela’s Saskatchewan boots for past 5 yrs. I decided to take the liners apart in both to compare and it was very easy to see which boot was better made. Baffin hands down. The liner is thicker and Baffin also has a waffle type liner under the main liner that will add comfort. Now, the only thing I can’t review on is the warmth of the Baffin. I tend to get cold feet and would get a bit cold in the Cabela’s ones after awhile. I generally would just always put a hot pack in my boots but that wasn’t always the best idea. Long story short I can’t wait to try these Baffin out in sub 20 degrees and lower! For 68 bucks on sale thanks to deal ninja I’m a tad excited if you can’t tell. And considering my muck artic split at the ankle seem I will be watching for the Baffin comparable all rubber boots for warmer days. Any other feedback?