Waterdogs (tiger salamanders) are a favorite of pike but they are a major pain to rig. I've just used a large treble hook in the back, maybe get two of the hooks to pierce the skin. Then I tie a stinger hook to the tail.
The problem is that waterdogs are so jello-like that the hooks come out easily and I end up almost killing them instantly.
For 2010 I'm thinking about using a #10 bait hook through the lower lip and run a stinger treble hook to the tail. It seems like they would stay alive a lot longer if I did it this way.
Any other ideas or alternate riggings? Also, is it possible to cast them in open water without killing them?
Thanks!