I have only every owned a Coleman lantern, though it is a liquid fuel lantern. Between hunting, fishing, and camping it's been reliable through any number of climates and conditions. It lights up on the first or second try everytime when using a lighter...matches are more difficult time for obvious reasons. In fact, this lantern has been so reliable I have only had to change the mantle once (in about 7 yrs) and I've really beat the lantern hard at times.
My father owns a Coleman lantern which uses propane. It works great as well, though we have broken the pane of glass numerous times until he purchased the hard plastic protectors. He uses the lantern in his portable (one man) shanty and it's quite balmy...just be careful not to bump the material of the shanty against the lantern if it's plastic, again for obvious reasons.
I've never used any brand other then Coleman, but that's because I believe you pay a little more for quality and it lasts much longer.