IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community
Montana => Ice Fishing Montana => Topic started by: slickice on Jan 25, 2024, 11:07 PM
-
Been out 10 times this season for perch & pike and have done really well with the pike by using a hotdog on a tip-up. I've iced numerous large pike this season and am ready to pickle a few gallon bags of pike loins. This is the 3rd season I've used hotdogs for bait and I'm totally convinced that they out perform most bait other than large live minnows which is illegal in Western MT. Here's my routine: Prior to fishing, I microwave the dogs in a zip lock for 20-30 seconds, let cool, then repeat. The microwaved dog may develop minor splits as it softens, secretes fatty juice and flavor onto the outside of the skin. I bury two hooks into the side of the dog and let the third hang out the side. The pike really go for dogs done this way. This isn't a joke or BS, it really works. Other "ice-heads" that use hotdogs for pike feel free to offer constructive tips and suggestions. I'm curious to see how many on this forum have tried hotdogs on tip-ups.
-
Been out 10 times this season for perch & pike and have done really well with the pike by using a hotdog on a tip-up. I've iced numerous large pike this season and am ready to pickle a few gallon bags of pike loins. This is the 3rd season I've used hotdogs for bait and I'm totally convinced that they out perform most bait other than large live minnows which is illegal in Western MT. Here's my routine: Prior to fishing, I microwave the dogs in a zip lock for 20-30 seconds, let cool, then repeat. The microwaved dog may develop minor splits as it softens, secretes fatty juice and flavor onto the outside of the skin. I bury two hooks into the side of the dog and let the third hang out the side. The pike really go for dogs done this way. This isn't a joke or BS, it really works. Other "ice-heads" that use hotdogs for pike feel free to offer constructive tips and suggestions. I'm curious to see how many on this forum have tried hotdogs on tip-ups.
Well, there goes my upper hand... ;)
Tight lines,
Pyro
-
kosher dogs work the best
-
kosher dogs work the best
-
Oscar Mayer's been my go to dog. Not sure if pike know the kosher quality thing but I'll give it a try.
-
I just use what the ol lady finds for cheap. This season, she's been gettin Bar S for 59 cents a pack. The slay no less than any other brand I've used.
Pyro
-
Well this answers a question I've had. We caught a pike last Tuesday and I found half a hotdog in its gut. I couldn't figure out where the hell he got it from but now I know. ;D
-
I heard if you soak your hotdog in powdered Kool-Aid, the female Pike like it better pro tip
-
I heard if you soak your hotdog in powdered Kool-Aid, the female Pike like it better pro tip
This is the exact way we slay catfish.
Pyro
-
The Kool-Aid thing is new to me and rather strange. Never heard of that but did know about catfish eating hotdogs.
-
Blue raspberry works best and I add garlic salt
-
Hot dogs under any circumstances do not, i repeat do not ever work for pike. Forget all about that nonsense and dont trust anyone who says otherwise. Its all a lie to get you to catch less fish, while the trickster catches all the pike to himself.
-
I personally have not used hotdogs but I know people that do. They do work. I was with a buddy last year on a lake in northwest mt. He kicked me but using hotdogs. I am just set in my ways. I honestly thought about using them but couldn’t bring my self to do it
-
I run tip-ups for pike when I'm spearing & when they're hitting & bait runs low, the can of Vienna sausage I keep in my gear has worked well over the last 20 years
-
Hot dogs under any circumstances do not, i repeat do not ever work for pike. Forget all about that nonsense and dont trust anyone who says otherwise. Its all a lie to get you to catch less fish, while the trickster catches all the pike to himself.
Obviously he's never used hot dogs for pike because they do indeed work and work very well. There's no nefarious agenda to trick people into wasting time with posting the use of hotdogs as bait.
-
Obviously he's never used hot dogs for pike because they do indeed work and work very well. There's no nefarious agenda to trick people into wasting time with posting the use of hotdogs as bait.
i think you may have missed the sarcasm.
-
i think you may have missed the sarcasm.
Is the newbie attempting to be humorous or sarcastic? Either one seems abrasive. At 75, I say what I mean...and mean what I say. "Hotdogs work very well for pike."
-
(https://i.postimg.cc/DmWKS9nV/3gaizz.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/DmWKS9nV)
-
(https://i.postimg.cc/bsZmzs8P/IMG-20240206-161952.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/bsZmzs8P) Yup. Hotdogs at work. Went for 3 hours chasing perch today. Had 1 flag on an Oscar dog. Pike measured 29"...about 5-6 pounds.
-
(https://i.postimg.cc/bsZmzs8P/IMG-20240206-161952.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/bsZmzs8P) Yup. Hotdogs at work. Went for 3 hours chasing perch today. Had 1 flag on an Oscar dog. Pike measured 29"...about 5-6 pounds.
Good deal, slickice!
We picked up a few today on the BarS weiners soaked in that FireBrine.
(https://i.postimg.cc/k28Hj25Z/20240206-122650.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/k28Hj25Z)
(https://i.postimg.cc/8FS0xTJC/20240206-130041.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/8FS0xTJC)
(https://i.postimg.cc/k6MhXwy3/20240206-132744.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/k6MhXwy3)
Pyro
-
Nice looking catch. Making a batch of pickled pike right now. Added this guy to the batch.
-
If you don't mind me asking Pyro, what is the Firebrine. I've had luck with hotdogs but would like to improve my catch. thanks
-
If you don't mind me asking Pyro, what is the Firebrine. I've had luck with hotdogs but would like to improve my catch. thanks
Here is their list of offered products. They can be purchased at pert near every place that sells tackle.
https://pautzke.com/shop/product-pautzke-fire-brine/
Pyro
-
I've used the firebrine on shrimp and had decent success with perch as well, they seemed to hit it faster than the poles with unbrined shrimp or maggots nearby.
-
Here is their list of offered products. They can be purchased at pert near every place that sells tackle.
https://pautzke.com/shop/product-pautzke-fire-brine/
Pyro
Thanks much Pyro
-
How do you rig the hot dog? Single hook or treble hook.
-
Medium sized treble with the shank against the dog and two of the hooks buried. The third hook faces away from the dog and is exposed. Gamakatsu hooks work well for me.
-
Hello everyone! Newbie to the forum. Found this conversation about using hotdogs for pike bait very interesting. Heard it before from a friend and thought it was a joke. I've always just used smelt and herring but will definitely give it a shot this weekend. I'll post some pics if successful.
-
Hey Abe (Lincoln406). Saw your pics on the photo section. Nice Pike. You said you'd try. Did you happen to use any hotdogs that day?
-
Took some and tried for about an hour, got bites on smelt right away and gave up on the dogs. Maybe I'll try it again some day.
-
Took some and tried for about an hour, got bites on smelt right away and gave up on the dogs. Maybe I'll try it again some day.
This ain't the 1st time I heard if a similar story on Bull.
I find that the hotdogs only work better in some waters, but not all.
Nice pike, by the way.
Pyro
-
Hotdogs are my go-to pike tip up bait. I do not live near a bait shop, so I am left with deadbait or hotdogs. I use both and find the hotdogs out produce. My largest pike (41 inches) was on a dog. This weekend I fished with a buddy, we had hotdogs, dead chubs, and live shiners out. We got two pike on the ice and both on the hotdog. We had two flags on the shiners but both drops. I use a single circle hook in the middle of the dog and have great hook-up rates.
-
This ain't the 1st time I heard if a similar story on Bull.
I find that the hotdogs only work better in some waters, but not all.
Nice pike, by the way.
Pyro
Thanks Pyro. Maybe I'll give it more of a chance next time. Hard to not switch when a different bait is working and 2 lines the limit.
-
Thanks Pyro. Maybe I'll give it more of a chance next time. Hard to not switch when a different bait is working and 2 lines the limit.
It really is! There have been many times I've told myself to switch the bait out for the other, but figured I'd give it more time. I always leave the ice within I had switched earlier. ::)
If smelt is workin, it's really hard to switch to hotdogs.
Pyro
-
Anyone ever tried vienna sausages? I've heard about people using jimmy dean links, but for the more economically minded, perhaps the poor-man's sausage would be worth a shot?
-
hot dogs big pike. vienna sausage pick handles.