If a fella had to subscribe to just one catalog.....what would it be? I don't get to just run to the store to shop....that's a 3 hr trip.
American Science and Surplus. Seriously, there is not a more entertaining catalog read on the planet. Or, almost as good, an old Herter's "bible" when George L. was still writing. Not a bigger collection of outdoor bravado, self-importance and B.S. anywhere. But you're not interested in entertainment value...
Honestly? What RyanW said. I get weekly catalogs (sometimes more often than that) from BPS/Cabelas because I've been a long-time customer. They rarely get opened and head right for the recycle bag. Reed's comes about three times a year, same deal. Even their big "Master" or seasonal special catalogs... Recycle immediately.
Occasionally I look at the specialty ones (Boating/Marine, Saltwater, Shooting) just to get some ideas on what's new and/or available. I do like and keep the Lure Parts Online big catalog around just for reference and quality reading in the "library".
I've got a folder just for "Shop n Ship" bookmarks that holds preferred vendors and tracking pages for all the primary shippers on both phone and PC. Done.
My preferred vendors? FishUSA, LPO, Amazon, BPS/Cabelas get probably 99% of my business. The more I use FishUSA, the more I use FishUSA. They don't have
everything but they have a lot and their pricing is very competitive.