Best small lake in Madison County NY

[Teddy1990]

Anyone have any opinion on the what they think the best producing lake for them in Madison County NY is?

[Oldtimer]

Like any other lakes, they have their days.  Morraine is good for big gills, may have to sort out a few.  Done the best on perch in Bradley Brook., never caught much in LeLands,  Lebanon and  Eatonbrook are spotty but get good late season. Best place day in and day out is Erieville Res. , Caz gets to busy for me.  Just my opinion.

[Zeker259]

They are all the Best when you are there catching them.

 

[moosefeet]

Moraine is ok, Lelands? never had much luck, Lebanon is ok, Caz is ok. Is Bradley Brook private tho? Hey Old timer, when you say Erieville Res are you also referring to Tuscarora?

[Chilled]

My favorite lake in the area is caz if you're looking for panfish. I can almost always go out and catch tons of gills and crappie.

[geo315]

Like any other lakes, they have their days.  Morraine is good for big gills, may have to sort out a few.  Done the best on perch in Bradley Brook., never caught much in LeLands,  Lebanon and  Eatonbrook are spotty but get good late season. Best place day in and day out is Erieville Res. , Caz gets to busy for me.  Just my opinion.

Isn't Bradley Brook Res.  private?

[Rugburn]

 Yes Geo along with Hatch.

[geo315]

Yes Geo along with Hatch.

Thanks. 

[Oldtimer]

Moraine is ok, Lelands? never had much luck, Lebanon is ok, Caz is ok. Is Bradley Brook private tho? Hey Old timer, when you say Erieville Res are you also referring to Tuscarora?

Yes, Tuscarora. 

[bigdub22]

Hatch has access along rt 26 I believe....owner of rod and bobber bait shop on Jones road said you can park on the road and go on. Small guard rail there.

[moosefeet]

Yes, Tuscarora.

Where's the best access for Tuscarora? I took my son to a Derby there about 10 yrs ago and we got on by what was ''Rosies'' then.

[flukeman]

You can still get on there, by the dam, and on the south end.

[gil_lunkage]

I think when he said eerieville he meant pickerelville...

[moosefeet]

You're right about the pickerel, there's some bruisers in there! I haven't fished it in a long time, maybe I'll have to drag Rugburn and R.R. Frank over there some weekend. Anybody do much with the Eyes there?

[Rangerclay]

Hey don't forget DeRuyter Lake.  I do well there when I get the chance to go. Sometimes you even get a nice walleye.

[Teddy1990]

You can still get on Tuscarora at what used to be Rosies. It's called the Blue Canoe now. Decent food there too after a long day fishing. Thinking about hitting Tuscarora in the morning.