I like having my dog with me, my last Lab (14yr old), didnt think a fish was caught if it still moved! he would dive in the river and help fly fishermen land their fish and nothing I could do would stop him. So he couldnt go fishing. Dogs are like kids they are only "cute " to their owners. I got a new Lab he's 1 yr old now and hasnt been ice fishing yet, but when he goes he will be tethered , my buddy's lab took off after a plastic milk crate that the wind took right outta sight! he came back with it but we were anxious for a few minutes. I do feel sorry for some dogs I see shivering on the ice, some people shouldnt have a dog.