IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

Maine => Ice Fishing Maine => Topic started by: StolenB8 on Mar 13, 2021, 09:03 AM

Title: Smoke em if you’ve got em!
Post by: StolenB8 on Mar 13, 2021, 09:03 AM
Alright clamfarmer got me thinking... dangerous I know! Let see some pics of smokers full of fish! Maybe throw in recipes if it’s not a family secret!  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Smoke em if you’ve got em!
Post by: Jack978 on Mar 13, 2021, 10:07 AM
I use a wet smoker for doing all my smoking which produces a different product than dry smoking which takes a lot longer.  Its not so much preservation as cooking.   Since mine uses propane it keeps a constant temperature without having to screw around with it much.

Prepare the fish by brining them overnight. You can do this by adding a generous amount of salt to a one gallon freezer bag adding enough water to cover the fish and letting them set in the refrigerator overnight.   In a pinch just take wet fish and rub salt all over them if your are in a hurry. 

Prepare the smoker by bringing it up to about 200 degrees and adding tarragon to the water pan. Usually its best to add the wood (pre soaked in water for at least 20 minutes) you are going to use at the beginning before you put the fish on.  Its a judgement call how much to add but several pinches of tarragon are usually enough.  Put the fish on (spray the racks with oil so they don't stick) and bring back up to 200 degrees and walk away for 3 hours or so.  Avoid the urge to check before then.  If its cold and windy out perhaps 4 hours but with enough water in the pan you don't have to go to the minute as it won't burn or dry out. Make sure the water pan is full since otherwise the temp will climb and blacken the fish and possibly dry it out.

At the 3 hour mark open the door and pull them out.  Remember to complain endlessly to the wife about the back breaking labor involved and how difficult it was.   The skin will peel off easily and the outside will be a very rich golden color. The fish will be moist and flake easily. 

Everything from there is a matter of taste and trial and error.  Dry smoking is a totally different process but this is a quick way to make dinner and usually the fish will last for a week at least in the refrigerator.   I use oak or applewood but  as long as you stay away from hickory or pine in particular its what tastes best to you.

I'm sure someone will have a better way to do it but life is complicated enough without adding additional layers.  I've mostly used this with trout and salmon but pretty much works the same for any kind of fish. 
Title: Re: Smoke em if you’ve got em!
Post by: Anomaly on Mar 13, 2021, 10:21 AM
I use a wet smoker for doing all my smoking which produces a different product than dry smoking which takes a lot longer.  Its not so much preservation as cooking.   Since mine uses propane it keeps a constant temperature without having to screw around with it much.
  Cool! Thanks! I’ll save this recipe for use when I get my unit up!
A long time ago, I had whitefish that was smoked whole. They were all a golden color and very moist inside. The pin bones were firmly attached to the vertebrate similar to a perfectly pan cooked brook trout. They were one of the most amazing foods I’ve ever eaten! It was almost like eating flaky smoked butter! I wonder if the smoking method used was similar to yours. I imagine is also had something to do with the fish being whole such that none of the moisture and oils bleed out in the smoker. I believe the fish was smoked in Canada. I’ll be doing a little  research.
Title: Re: Smoke em if you’ve got em!
Post by: grub662 on Mar 13, 2021, 11:49 AM
Alder is excellent for smoking fish and it is everywhere.
Title: Re: Smoke em if you’ve got em!
Post by: Jack978 on Mar 13, 2021, 02:19 PM
Regardless of technique fruit woods seem to be the go to along with alder for smoking fish.  The brine or marinate is a matter of personal taste and experimenting is always in order.  My father grew up in eastern Europe along a tributary of a major river that was loaded with sturgeon back in the day and smoking them was about the only preservation method available.    They favored a cold smoking method and that's where I got the salt idea from but regardless of how you do it the product is very good. Whole fish tend to work best and the less you mess with them the easier it is.  No need to advertise its easy but with an inexpensive smoker from Lowes or Home Depot you can become the envy of the neighborhood.
Title: Re: Smoke em if you’ve got em!
Post by: Jack978 on Mar 13, 2021, 02:22 PM
  Cool! Thanks! I’ll save this recipe for use when I get my unit up!
A long time ago, I had whitefish that was smoked whole. They were all a golden color and very moist inside. The pin bones were firmly attached to the vertebrate similar to a perfectly pan cooked brook trout. They were one of the most amazing foods I’ve ever eaten! It was almost like eating flaky smoked butter! I wonder if the smoking method used was similar to yours. I imagine is also had something to do with the fish being whole such that none of the moisture and oils bleed out in the smoker. I believe the fish was smoked in Canada. I’ll be doing a little  research.


What you are describing is exactly how they turn out the way I do it.  Some like it hot off the smoker but actually if you let it sit a while more flavor comes through for some reason.