IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

New York => Ice Fishing New York => Topic started by: oneidawalleye on Feb 17, 2009, 06:05 PM

Title: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: oneidawalleye on Feb 17, 2009, 06:05 PM
The sales rep Craig from Michael's Wholesale Bait out of Massachusetts is telling all of his dealers in New York to dump their supply of Hunts Minnows since their certification is suspect. Heard that from many bait shops owners in the Sacandaga and Saratoga region. Would like to know if this is the REAL DEAL.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Mr.Esox on Feb 17, 2009, 07:22 PM
That's just great and we pay more for certified bait and have to toss after 7 days. I bought some of that bait I want a refund. I hope there isn't more of this going on because we the fisherman are getting ripped off with these bait prices. What a raquet.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: oneidawalleye on Feb 17, 2009, 07:26 PM
Blame it on Michaels Wholesale Bait for selling it to the bait shops, NOT THE BAIT SHOP OWNERS FAULT
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: coldbum on Feb 18, 2009, 08:15 AM
Is there any more information on this? Is there another supply of hunts available?

Are any shops in the Fulton/Hamilton County area's affected?

Details please :)
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: JJ on Feb 18, 2009, 04:37 PM
This is true, heard it directly from Craig. The hunts are certified, but the paperwork has them listed by the wrong species, they are trying to resolve this, but can't ship out any of the bait in question for the time being.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: yellabella on Feb 18, 2009, 05:08 PM
does this mean that fish 307 is not going to have any on friday?
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: duckman on Feb 18, 2009, 08:04 PM
Do not worry fish 307 has got a lot of minnows.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: troutguy1377 on Feb 19, 2009, 07:38 AM
Does any one know when they will be available again ???
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: BigEd on Feb 19, 2009, 02:43 PM
Bought the last 3 doz. Hunts from my fav baitshop the other night.  He said they probably weren't going to be getting anymore this season.  I didn't know why until I read this!  What exactly is a Hunt calssified as?  If you look at the NYS Baitfish regs they are not listed.   ???   
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: coldbum on Feb 19, 2009, 03:11 PM
They are also called spottail shiners or notropis hudsonius.

Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: coldbum on Feb 22, 2009, 08:31 AM
I talked with a friend close to DEC sources the other day about the hunts issue.

The issue seems to be that they (DEC) did not know what species hunts really are.

Apparently what we all thought were spottail shiners (notropis hudsonius)  were actually silver shiners (notropis photogenis).

Silver shiners are not on the approved bait list. This is stupid mistake that has cost all of our bait shops a lot of money!

Jim killed a whole fresh tank of them this week.

DEC is supposed to add the silver to the list for next year, we shall see...
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: WALLEYES INC. on Feb 22, 2009, 09:04 AM
Here is a link if anybody wants it!
http://www.cnr.vt.edu/efish/families/silvershiner.html
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Nick94 on Feb 22, 2009, 09:31 AM
http://www.cnr.vt.edu/efish/families/silvershiner.html
 (http://www.cnr.vt.edu/efish/families/silvershiner.html)
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: holehawg on Feb 22, 2009, 12:51 PM
i do believe this minnow nonsense is getting out of hand...has it been proven that this causes the disease ????????? or are they shooting in the dark with this...i never have really learned the truth on this...
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: SpEeD on Feb 22, 2009, 02:30 PM
If those silver shiners were tested and disease free what the heck is the DEC's problem with them then :cookoo:
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: coldbum on Feb 22, 2009, 03:10 PM
From what I know yes indeed they were all "Certified."

This is only a problem on paper.  I think DEC should have crossed all the t's and dotted all the i's before they rubber stamped the certification paperwork. This could have been avoided.

All those bait fish that were killed, were perfectly healthy.

I understand the importance of the  new VHS laws. I value our resources as much as the next guy and would go to any length to protect them.

This was just dumb.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: waytkus on Feb 22, 2009, 05:56 PM
My buddy owns a bait shop in Hudson Falls and said he wasn't even ordering icicles or "emeralds" this week because there is always hunts in with the icicles, and he would feel bad if a customer got a ticket because of this crap . Apparently hunts wern't listed as a baitfish that can be certified.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: coldbum on Feb 25, 2009, 04:03 PM
Hrm, I am eager to hear what went on..
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Camp Bassfish on Feb 25, 2009, 05:22 PM
Must not have paid off the EnviroMafia  AKA DEC or DEP etc....

Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: jay c on Feb 25, 2009, 06:48 PM
Hrm, I am eager to hear what went on..
I was told there were mixed species in tanks.
I have posted this minute ago--------
They are one of two suppliers for Northen New York.
Nothing to laugh about.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Hop-Sing on Feb 27, 2009, 05:05 PM
The bait in question (nickname "hunts") were Eastern Silvery Minnow (Hybognathus regius). You can look them up by clicking on: http://fish.dnr.cornell.edu/nyfish/fish.html (http://fish.dnr.cornell.edu/nyfish/fish.html)

The minnows in question in this thread (Eastern Silvery Minnow Hybognathus regius ) are NOT on the New York "Green List" which consists of: Golden shiner, Northern redbelly dace, Emerald shiner, Blacknose dace, Common shiner, Longnose dace, Spottail shiner, White sucker, Banded killifish, Northern hogsucker, Fathead minnow, Creek chub, Bluntnose minnow, Fallfish, and Logperch.

The permit issued by the DEC to import the load of "hunts" in question into NY (across state lines) was issued incorrectly. Thus the "hunts" in question were then legal classified (by default) as Uncertified Baitfish in New York and bait stores would have to obey this NY DEC regulation:

"Uncertified baitfish" are all those that have not been tested and found to be free of specified diseases. Uncertified baitfish purchased from a bait dealer can only be used on the same body of water from which it was caught and cannot be transported overland by a motorized vehicle (i.e. car). The seller is required to provide a receipt that names the water body in which the uncertified bait fish can be used and a warning to the purchaser that the baitfish may not be transported by car or other motorized vehicle.

Because NY retailers did not buy them under the correct permit-to-import, they could not provide a receipt that names the water body in which the uncertified bait fish can be used, and could not issue a warning to the purchaser that the baitfish may not be transported by car or other motorized vehicle. Thus, they had to be dumped.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Captain1978 on Feb 27, 2009, 05:42 PM
Yep I was at a baitshop and saw the paperwork...It's true, the paperwork is screwy
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: greg42 on Feb 27, 2009, 05:49 PM
Hop-Sing appears to do more than cook on the Ponderosa.....Nice touch
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Hop-Sing on Feb 27, 2009, 11:42 PM
Two points to ponder:

a) As of yesterday the Feds and DEC were still up in the air whether the minnows in question were Silver Shiners (notropis photogenis) or Eastern Silvery Minnow (Hybognathus regius).

b) Easterns and spot-tails are harvested in the same manner and and can be found schooled-up from the same habitat, particularly in the Connecticut River back-waters. On casual examination, it is not uncommon for them to be mistaken for each other.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: DA-Bait on Feb 28, 2009, 05:02 AM
I run a very small retail bait shop in Massachusetts-very small.  Have had Michael's as a supplier since we opened in March 2006, I have to say Michael's has always been very fair to us.  No matter how small our weekly order is he delivers, and at a very low delivery charge.
The raid on his shop was right out of the movies-the State and Feds spent 11 hours going over the place.  I'm not sure I really want my tax dollars being wasted that way.  I would have thought that a simple inspection would have sufficed, then a shut down until things got squared away.  My take on this is that somewhere in the past Michael really torqued off someone in the political establishment and whoever that was is still po'd.  It did not help that one of the employees (a son) was pinched in 2004 for a shady deal, after that I would have imagined that he would have told everyone in the organization to keep their nose clean. 
I think channel 40 and 22 out of Springfield MA has a vid of the raid and can be seen on the web sites.

Later,
DA-Bait Shop
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: tafts ta on Feb 28, 2009, 07:06 AM
I own a Tackle shop just over the NY border in Mass. I also used to be a sales rep for the Uncle Josh Bait Company in Wisconsin, do product demos at Bass Pro Shops accross the country, and be Conservation Director for the Massachusetts BASS federation.
I know what a pain in the butt all the new regs are about certified bait. I go through it with my customers everyday. But what I Can tell you is this. VHS is the real deal. I have seen lakes down south and in the midwest with 100% fishkill from it. I always hear people say "well my bait isnt dead so it must not have it". What people do not realize is that VHS does not show itself until the fish reaches breeding maturity and the sex organs are developed. VHS is also only one of a handful of diseases that are currently affecting lakes in the northeast. New York is on the forefront of what will soon be a nationwide requirement for bait certification within a few years.
I have spoken directly to Major Pajak from the Mass Environmental Police about the circumstances at Michaels. Just FYI to everyone, This is not the first Major Violation at Michaels, in fact it is the third in 10 years. That is why they EP's came down so hard so quick. Without being able to directly comment on an ongoing investigation he also informed me that the Hunts Minnow was not the only thing that they were looking for.
I have been informed by Major Pajak that it will be a minimum of 2 to 4 weeks before all is cleared up IF it gets cleared up. If you are a tackle shop, or know the owner of a tackle shop, you may want to try to locate another supplier of bait at least in the short term. Lets face it, as tackle shop owners we rely on ice fishing as a money maker for us, we only have a few weeks left in the season and if you are loyal to michaels or not, you need to cut hay while the sun is shining.
I do not want to post more info than is necessary about michaels because I like the people there and they have always been nice even if they are not the best at customer service. Anyone who reads this feel free to contact me with any questions and I can put you directly in touch with Major Pajak if you would like. I have his home and cell numbers so that I can reach him with concerns.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Hop-Sing on Feb 28, 2009, 08:04 AM
If those silver shiners were tested and disease free, what the heck is the DEC's problem with them then :cookoo:
I am under the impression that some of the species of minnows to which we commonly attach the nickname 'silver shiners' are not on the NY "Green List."

So, inspected/certified or not, they can only be retailed as "uncertified bait" in NY.

Retailers in NY can sell uncertified bait IF and ONLY IF the retailer tells the buyer the specific waterbody they can be fished, restricted to the exact waterbody from which the bait was trapped.

But, if the retailer does not KNOW the exact waterbody from which the so-called silver shiners originated, the retailer cannot sell them. Period. Thus, they would have to be dumped.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: trapper2000 on Feb 28, 2009, 03:19 PM
I own a Tackle shop just over the NY border in Mass. I also used to be a sales rep for the Uncle Josh Bait Company in Wisconsin, do product demos at Bass Pro Shops accross the country, and be Conservation Director for the Massachusetts BASS federation.
I know what a pain in the butt all the new regs are about certified bait. I go through it with my customers everyday. But what I Can tell you is this. VHS is the real deal. I have seen lakes down south and in the midwest with 100% fishkill from it. I always hear people say "well my bait isnt dead so it must not have it". What people do not realize is that VHS does not show itself until the fish reaches breeding maturity and the sex organs are developed. VHS is also only one of a handful of diseases that are currently affecting lakes in the northeast. New York is on the forefront of what will soon be a nationwide requirement for bait certification within a few years.
I have spoken directly to Major Pajak from the Mass Environmental Police about the circumstances at Michaels. Just FYI to everyone, This is not the first Major Violation at Michaels, in fact it is the third in 10 years. That is why they EP's came down so hard so quick. Without being able to directly comment on an ongoing investigation he also informed me that the Hunts Minnow was not the only thing that they were looking for.
I have been informed by Major Pajak that it will be a minimum of 2 to 4 weeks before all is cleared up IF it gets cleared up. If you are a tackle shop, or know the owner of a tackle shop, you may want to try to locate another supplier of bait at least in the short term. Lets face it, as tackle shop owners we rely on ice fishing as a money maker for us, we only have a few weeks left in the season and if you are loyal to michaels or not, you need to cut hay while the sun is shining.
I do not want to post more info than is necessary about michaels because I like the people there and they have always been nice even if they are not the best at customer service. Anyone who reads this feel free to contact me with any questions and I can put you directly in touch with Major Pajak if you would like. I have his home and cell numbers so that I can reach him with concerns.


first vhs has only been confirmed in the great lakes basin and surrending waters !!!! what lakes are you taking about that had complete die offs? and i don't know where you get the idea that fish maturity has anything to do with the virus!
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Hop-Sing on Feb 28, 2009, 04:50 PM
first vhs has only been confirmed in the great lakes basin and surrending waters !!!!
After it was first discovered in Lake Ontario in 2005, VHS spread rapidly to other Great Lakes waters. It is now found in the St. Lawrence River, Lake Erie, the Niagara River, Lake St. Clair, the Detroit River, Lake Huron, and Lake Michigan. VHS has already caused widespread fish mortalities in Lakes St. Clair, Erie and Ontario.

Michigan DNR determined it had spread into Lake Huron, as far north as Cheboygan and Rogers City.

It has spread to several inland waters w/o without any direct connection to the Great Lakes including Lake Butte des Morts and Lake Winnebago in Wisconsin, Budd Lake in Michigan, and several lakes and rivers in the NY Finger Lakes.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: trapper2000 on Feb 28, 2009, 05:04 PM
yes but thats not southern waters it has also been found in the fingerlakes  original believed to have  came from lake erie from  the bait industry (emerald shinners) now it's not that clear  i'm just interested he said southern lakes with complete kill off ,i live on lake ontario  and i assure you it wasn't a complete  kill also many waters have (fish) have tested positive with no die offs
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: DA-Bait on Mar 01, 2009, 04:22 AM
I own a Tackle shop just over the NY border in Mass. I also used to be a sales rep for the Uncle Josh Bait Company in Wisconsin, do product demos at Bass Pro Shops accross the country, and be Conservation Director for the Massachusetts BASS federation.
I know what a pain in the butt all the new regs are about certified bait. I go through it with my customers everyday. But what I Can tell you is this. VHS is the real deal. I have seen lakes down south and in the midwest with 100% fishkill from it. I always hear people say "well my bait isnt dead so it must not have it". What people do not realize is that VHS does not show itself until the fish reaches breeding maturity and the sex organs are developed. VHS is also only one of a handful of diseases that are currently affecting lakes in the northeast. New York is on the forefront of what will soon be a nationwide requirement for bait certification within a few years.
I have spoken directly to Major Pajak from the Mass Environmental Police about the circumstances at Michaels. Just FYI to everyone, This is not the first Major Violation at Michaels, in fact it is the third in 10 years. That is why they EP's came down so hard so quick. Without being able to directly comment on an ongoing investigation he also informed me that the Hunts Minnow was not the only thing that they were looking for.
I have been informed by Major Pajak that it will be a minimum of 2 to 4 weeks before all is cleared up IF it gets cleared up. If you are a tackle shop, or know the owner of a tackle shop, you may want to try to locate another supplier of bait at least in the short term. Lets face it, as tackle shop owners we rely on ice fishing as a money maker for us, we only have a few weeks left in the season and if you are loyal to michaels or not, you need to cut hay while the sun is shining.
I do not want to post more info than is necessary about michaels because I like the people there and they have always been nice even if they are not the best at customer service. Anyone who reads this feel free to contact me with any questions and I can put you directly in touch with Major Pajak if you would like. I have his home and cell numbers so that I can reach him with concerns.

Thank you for the info here we are not getting much info from local news and Michaels isn't telling us much either.  As soon as I heard about the raid I was on the horn to another wholesaler and had secured my needs that day.  Thanks again!
DA-Bait Shop
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Bailbuster on Mar 01, 2009, 05:05 AM
This post was started 2/17.Michael's was raided on by local wardens and feds 2/25 .It looks like he has more trouble than hunts at this time. What has he done now?BB
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: tafts ta on Mar 01, 2009, 06:10 AM
yes but thats not southern waters it has also been found in the fingerlakes  original believed to have  came from lake erie from  the bait industry (emerald shinners) now it's not that clear  i'm just interested he said southern lakes with complete kill off ,i live on lake ontario  and i assure you it wasn't a complete  kill also many waters have (fish) have tested positive with no die offs

Many waters can sustain the virus without 100%kill, some can not. If any of you are BASS fisherman, or follow bass fishing at all you may remember major publicity being made only a few years ago about the Massive fish kill at Lake Fork in Texas. Also from the Viral Hemmoragic Septicemia VHS virus, all breeding sized fish in a major part of the lake were killed over a two year strain. First it was thought to be caused by Largemouth Bass Mosaic Virus LMBMV, but later after other species started to show signs of mortality, it was linked to VHS and was the first reported case of VHS in the south.

So to say it is only a great lakes issue is naive. One of the major reasons why all these laws were implimented was because up until a few years ago, most golden shiners, shad, chubs, etc that were used for bait were harvested out of the great lakes, and then resold throughout new england, the midwest, and surrounding areas.

The idea that since the lake I fish on now doesn't have a problem so I am going to continue as usual should be a thing of the past. These issues ARE problems, we as anglers did not create them, but we should do and be doing what we can to stop and hopefully prevent them.
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: tafts ta on Mar 01, 2009, 06:36 AM
This page is a little dated, but still highly useful.

This forum has gotten way off track too, sorry, i guess that is my bad

http://dnr.wi.gov/fish/vhs/vhs_qaaboutvhs.html#1
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: trapper2000 on Mar 01, 2009, 06:58 AM
Many waters can sustain the virus without 100%kill, some can not. If any of you are BASS fisherman, or follow bass fishing at all you may remember major publicity being made only a few years ago about the Massive fish kill at Lake Fork in Texas. Also from the Viral Hemmoragic Septicemia VHS virus, all breeding sized fish in a major part of the lake were killed over a two year strain. First it was thought to be caused by Largemouth Bass Mosaic Virus LMBMV, but later after other species started to show signs of mortality, it was linked to VHS and was the first reported case of VHS in the south.

So to say it is only a great lakes issue is naive. One of the major reasons why all these laws were implimented was because up until a few years ago, most golden shiners, shad, chubs, etc that were used for bait were harvested out of the great lakes, and then resold throughout new england, the midwest, and surrounding areas.

The idea that since the lake I fish on now doesn't have a problem so I am going to continue as usual should be a thing of the past. These issues ARE problems, we as anglers did not create them, but we should do and be doing what we can to stop and hopefully prevent them.


i don't believe that was a vhs kill off sorry as far as great lakes VHS it has been only confirmed in and around the great lakes areas this is from lake fork


AUSTIN, Texas--The deaths this summer of up to 4,000 largemouth bass on one of the nation's premier trophy bass fisheries, Lake Fork, were most likely caused by a virus similar to one implicated in fish kills in four southeastern states, according to an investigative report released this week by Texas Parks and Wildlife (TPW).

The findings point to several stress-related factors that may have influenced the onset of an iridovirus strain similar to the Largemouth Bass Virus (LMBV) that affected adult bass almost exclusively on several popular fisheries in the Southeast. But the report draws few conclusions other than to suggest the Lake Fork fish kill may be an isolated event that is coming to an end.

THIS WAS NOT VHS!!!!!!

                                                                                                                                                     trap
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: JJ on Mar 01, 2009, 09:17 AM
Here's a link to a "Timeline of Reported VHS Events":

http://www.focusonfishhealth.org/vhs-timeline.php (http://www.focusonfishhealth.org/vhs-timeline.php)

Lot's of other good VHS info on this site also:

http://www.focusonfishhealth.org/index.php (http://www.focusonfishhealth.org/index.php)
Title: Re: Hunt's minnows from Michael's wholesale bait are illegal in New York
Post by: Hop-Sing on Mar 01, 2009, 10:39 PM
Thank you for the info here we are not getting much info from local news and Michaels isn't telling us much either.  As soon as I heard about the raid I was on the horn to another wholesaler and had secured my needs that day.  Thanks again!
DA-Bait Shop
Paul (from Michael's) told me we would have our regular bait delivery on Wednesday ............ ::)