I believe there is a shortage of golden shiners this year, and with the new bait laws its pretty slim pickens at most bait shops. Your best bet would be hog island market in west swanton, probally 10-15 drive from holiday harbor. Also, Ive never been there, but I believe bill's bait shop in grand isle has minnows, you will be driving past it on rte. 2, its located behind the islands super market.