Visit the Team Iceshanty Proshop
I have yet to see a articulable difference from one minnow species to the other as far as Northern having a preference. I usually have Shiners, creek chubs and suckers and the Pike get whatever I happen to grab next. The only advantage I have ever seen between suckers and shiners is that suckers are far tougher and hardier minnows. Shiners are wimpy and die very easily.