I have Gander's version and have been pleased. I have the uninsulated bibs and jacket. The bibs go very high on my chest (I'm just a hair under 6'). The jacket is cut long so there's always total coverage, even if you were to get the pants intead of bibs. Plenty of room for layering. They lasted 3 years of pretty frequent use before I needed to treat them with the gore-tex refresher spray. Now they're as good as new. I've been happy with all the normal features -- storm flaps over the zippers, boot zippers, the buckles on the shoulder straps, plenty of pockets, etc. No failures of any kind.
They've kept me completley dry in some heavy precip. They're fine for kneeling on the ice too.
I give them 9.5 swedish pimples out of 10