What's your price range?
Warm. Warm and wide with a proper fit. Price is secondary.
I want something that I can walk in and wear while sitting in a portable shanty all day with my feet on the ice. If I can find a slip-on boot for climbing into my treestand as well, that's a bonus. I don't like to save money up front and not get what I really need. For me, I've found that buying things based on best price only more often than not usually means buying things two or three times and being miserable until I get it right. Conversely, I've also found that buying things just because they're the most expensive doesn 't necessarily work, either, and can be quite a waste. I like to focus on buying things once based on quality so that I can use them for years.
I see a lot of love here for Baffin boots, but I won't pull the trigger unless I can get a pair that's wide enough yet don't slop around when I walk. I know that my toes need a little room to stay warm.