IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

IceShanty Main => General Ice Fishing Chit Chat => Topic started by: captain54 on Mar 07, 2007, 07:56 PM

Title: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: captain54 on Mar 07, 2007, 07:56 PM
I always buy the bait because I live the closest, I give it or share it with friends.I'm not a cheap person.But my point is I'm fed up with tight a## bait shops,24 waxy's 1.30 plus tax, always 1 or 2 dead ones,never got 24 in cup all winter,spikes"mag" some cup look great other all saw dust,1.30 plus tax, crappie minnows 1.25 a dozen and THEY MEAN A DOZEN "12".I asked for 12 dozen fat heads last week and it took the owners girl 20min. to count to 144.  I buy more bait at this dive than most people,there are two other bait shops that are 15 miles round trip away that give you a fair deal with minnows and there grubs are bigger and alive.Any other anglers run into CHEAP A## BAIT THIEVES.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: scansy on Mar 07, 2007, 08:12 PM
There's a local shop about a half mile from a popular lake who is like that.  Counts out every minnow and if one extra sneaks in, nets it back out.  And, he's right on the road to this lake - it gets fished hard.  And on the weekends he opens at 8:00 !!!  Hell, half the guys are out for two or three hours already.

But near my family camp is a place we buy bait.  A dozen minnows is a big scoop full.  We buy three dozen, but get 60 or 70.  And the bait is always lively.  So there are good shops too.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: John_BZ on Mar 07, 2007, 08:27 PM
the bait shop i go to is sort of like that. depending on who is in there i may get only 1 dozen per the dozen i buy. somtimes if i buy one dozen i get 60 minnows. i never complain because i have been taken care of more than ive been f'ed. all depends who is there.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: empty hook on Mar 07, 2007, 09:02 PM
I always buy the bait because I live the closest, I give it or share it with friends.I'm not a cheap person.But my point is I'm fed up with tight a## bait shops,24 waxy's 1.30 plus tax, always 1 or 2 dead ones,never got 24 in cup all winter,spikes"mag" some cup look great other all saw dust,1.30 plus tax, crappie minnows 1.25 a dozen and THEY MEAN A DOZEN "12".I asked for 12 dozen fat heads last week and it took the owners girl 20min. to count to 144.  I buy more bait at this dive than most people,there are two other bait shops that are 15 miles round trip away that give you a fair deal with minnows and there grubs are bigger and alive.Any other anglers run into CHEAP A## BAIT THIEVES.
I have no compliance the bait shop I go to is the best one I have ever been in.  The owners are supper friendly and don't charge to much for bait that is lively.[Tackle Box] I even get my bait there when I fish other lakes,just get it a day sooner.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: blaster22077 on Mar 07, 2007, 09:06 PM
JIM'S BAIT SHOP
Howard PA
he has cheap minnows and other stuff and it is a 7 day week 24 hr self serve.
It is the only one that i know of :)
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crayfishbob on Mar 07, 2007, 09:27 PM
I own a baitshop. Usually when someone asks for a dozen minnows, I dump like 18 to 20 in. The trouble is that when buying minnows at $5.00 to $7.00 a lb and giving deals, you might as well not even bother with the whole business. I counted and figured out what I get per lb. If I was counting each minnow, I get between $24 and $27 per lb. Not too shabby. So be generous and give like two dozen. Now the price is $12.00 and shrinking fast. Some inevitbly die, and there's always one or two disasters every season, plus overbuying for those rained out holiday seasons. Look at this year: we got ice in late Janurary in upstate NY. Try to justify renting a building at $500.00 a month when there was no ice ! Then get dumped with 7 to 10 feet of snow two weeks after ice formed.

As far as the long wait and count, it must have been a new employee. Try to consider all aspects of whats going on before losing your temper.

Instead of complaining about bait counts, I would be praising the baitshop owner for patiently waiting for you to come through the door. ( believe me it gets lonesome ! )
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: hunters08 on Mar 07, 2007, 10:19 PM
I always buy the bait because I live the closest, I give it or share it with friends.I'm not a cheap person.But my point is I'm fed up with tight a## bait shops,24 waxy's 1.30 plus tax, always 1 or 2 dead ones,never got 24 in cup all winter,spikes"mag" some cup look great other all saw dust,1.30 plus tax, crappie minnows 1.25 a dozen and THEY MEAN A DOZEN "12".I asked for 12 dozen fat heads last week and it took the owners girl 20min. to count to 144.  I buy more bait at this dive than most people,there are two other bait shops that are 15 miles round trip away that give you a fair deal with minnows and there grubs are bigger and alive.Any other anglers run into CHEAP A## BAIT THIEVES.
order it (spikes and waxworms)from the online bait stores has always been fresh for me 1000 spikes for 10 bucks free shipping,and net your own minnows and use them in the lake your fishing(VHS).Most bait shops net there own minnows crayfishbob does.I dont know what he charges but i know others charge like they paid 5-7 dollars a pound and they were right beside me netting them to sell to you!! And if it takes 20 minutes to get bait,new employee or not i'm walking my a## out and driving the extra 15 miles from that day on.just my .02 :tipup:
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: captain54 on Mar 07, 2007, 10:23 PM
CrayfishBob,I'm not asking for 24 minnows when I buy a Dozen but it would be nice to get 3 or 4 extra per dozen.( and I've never bought a dozen in my life,more 5 dozen or more)Do you sell dead waxy's and spikes to your customers? Are you a tight a## bait dealer too? As from as me thanking him for being there,your something else! Put the shoe on the other foot Bob.Would you like drop $20 or more a week for bait and get treated sooooo well.I never complained to the bait shop owner ever once, plus he OPENS at 9 o'clock and is closed on sunday. Probable the same hours you keep.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Tim Hanford on Mar 08, 2007, 05:07 AM
I used to manage a tackle shop in SC PA and the owners had very high prices on live bait.  This is what we charged and customers rarely complained.  Customers didn't complain because we were the only shop for nearly 15 miles. I personally felt we were way overpriced on live bait but we sold more and more of it each year so what do I know.

Fatheads - $1.99/12
Rosey Reds - $2.49/12
Small Shiners - $2.99/12
Medium Shiners - $3.99/12
Large Shiners  $4.99/12
Pike Shiners - $10/12
Wax Worms/Meal Worms/Spikes - $2.49/25 or $11.99 per 250
Nightcrawlers - $2.99/12 or $4.49 per 24
Red Worms - $3.99/25
Nitro (Green) Crawlers - $3.99/12

Now you do have to take into account dead loss in the summer months, electricity to run the AC to keep water cool in summer (water temp over 70 and they die real quick) and electricity to run air pumps, time to clean the tanks every week spring through fall.  But we still made a large profit on live bait after all expenses were figured in.

One owner gave you 12 minnows per dozen and counted carefully.  The other owner would give one or two extra per dozen.  I personally took good care of our regular customers with their minnow counts per dozen.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: buttlesdog on Mar 08, 2007, 06:58 AM
I gotta take the bait shop owners side. I think selling dead bait or less than a person paid for is BS... BUT!!! You try making a living selling grubs and minnows for $1.39. What do you think his profit on it is? 30 cents maybe? Local bait and tackle shops face pressure today that they never faced in the past. For one thing, there's walmart, for another there is this thing, the internet. Do you buy all your tackle at the tackle shop? Or do you buy your tackle elsewhere and rely on the local guy for bait only? Be honest.. you know you buy your big ticket items elsewhere like everyone else does, usually on the internet or some big bargain place like Walmart, Kmart or The Sports Authority. Point is, local guys are drying up and going out of business, or barely hanging on and probably running into debt as they do so. Cough up the buck and change, talk to the guy, let them know your concerns, dont be surprised if they tell you their problems, and be prepared to listen to how they have a lot bigger problems then your 3 dead grubs...

All that said, I support my local shops. Try and hit them all and buy the big ticket items from them too. I find i fyou tell them you need a deal to fit your budget, they will work with you. And sure, sometimes you get burned, thats the nature of the business when people sell small live animals. Same thing happens in pet stores. Its just the way it is with little animals kept in small places for long periods of time. But the other side is worse. If you had no local bait shop, had to order everything from the internet, ... AND!! Good luck getting any advice on local fishing at Walmart of Ebay...
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: dollartrifecta on Mar 08, 2007, 07:02 AM
try 15 bux a dozen for pike shiners......not gonna mnetion any names...but that redic
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Rat-Man on Mar 08, 2007, 07:22 AM
Coming soon--- NO BAIT SHOPS AT ALL.---
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: HUNTER16 on Mar 08, 2007, 07:34 AM
The closest bait shop by me has a real gem working there.  He's an old man whose shop is attached to a beer drive-thru.  Only time I was there my son (9 yoa) was with me.  I asked for 3 doz bass minnows and he counted each one BY HAND.  He used the dip net to get them out of his tank.  Picked them out of the net w/his hand and dropped them in my bucket one at a time like he was counting pennies.  After watching this painful event, I asked him how much his waxes were.  He replied, "Money is no object."  I said, "Whose money, mine or yours.  I saw you rubbing the scales off my minnows.  Never mind on the waxes, I'll just take the minnows."  By the time I got to the lake  (15 min away) there were 3 floaters.  Before you ask, I had just replaced the styrofoam liner in my bucket and the water was from his tank.  When we left the guys shop, my son said "Dad can't we get our bait somewhere else?"
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: buttlesdog on Mar 08, 2007, 07:53 AM
Ok, rereading my post, maybe I was a bit too absolute in my reply. There are certainly bad businesses. But the point is, if someone charges x for y amount of bait. Then you should get y. Not y+2 or yx2. And the local bait shop is in fact becoming an endangered species. All the internet deals are great for fisherman, but maybe not so great for fishing as a whole.... time will tell. Didnt mean to attack captn 54, or any others who deal with bad businesses, just trying to say that the whole industry is hard pressed right now to make a buck.

Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crayfishbob on Mar 08, 2007, 08:11 AM
Yes, I catch my own bait. I am also in the red because of VHS testing. With three weeks left of possible ice, I hope to just break even. I would not dream of not being open on sundays, and counting minnows.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: JJ on Mar 08, 2007, 09:37 AM
CrayfishBob,I'm not asking for 24 minnows when I buy a Dozen but it would be nice to get 3 or 4 extra per dozen.( and I've never bought a dozen in my life,more 5 dozen or more)Do you sell dead waxy's and spikes to your customers? Are you a tight a## bait dealer too? As from as me thanking him for being there,your something else! Put the shoe on the other foot Bob.Would you like drop $20 or more a week for bait and get treated sooooo well.I never complained to the bait shop owner ever once, plus he OPENS at 9 o'clock and is closed on sunday. Probable the same hours you keep.
Ok, I tried to bite my tongue, but here's my 2 cents. Have you ever said anything to the one person that could do something about it, the bait shop owner. You were very quick to jump down crayfishbob's throat, he was only trying to give some insight from a seller's perspective; You know, the shoe on the other foot. You lost all credibility at that point and started sounding like the rest of the complainers on here.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: SPARKYICE on Mar 08, 2007, 10:14 AM
I gotta take the bait shop owners side. I think selling dead bait or less than a person paid for is BS... BUT!!! You try making a living selling grubs and minnows for $1.39. What do you think his profit on it is? 30 cents maybe? Local bait and tackle shops face pressure today that they never faced in the past. For one thing, there's walmart, for another there is this thing, the internet. Do you buy all your tackle at the tackle shop? Or do you buy your tackle elsewhere and rely on the local guy for bait only? Be honest.. you know you buy your big ticket items elsewhere like everyone else does, usually on the internet or some big bargain place like Walmart, Kmart or The Sports Authority. Point is, local guys are drying up and going out of business, or barely hanging on and probably running into debt as they do so. Cough up the buck and change, talk to the guy, let them know your concerns, dont be surprised if they tell you their problems, and be prepared to listen to how they have a lot bigger problems then your 3 dead grubs...

All that said, I support my local shops. Try and hit them all and buy the big ticket items from them too. I find i fyou tell them you need a deal to fit your budget, they will work with you. And sure, sometimes you get burned, thats the nature of the business when people sell small live animals. Same thing happens in pet stores. Its just the way it is with little animals kept in small places for long periods of time. But the other side is worse. If you had no local bait shop, had to order everything from the internet, ... AND!! Good luck getting any advice on local fishing at Walmart of Ebay...

bless you buttlesdog !!
i couldn't have said it better myself !!
i get my bait at a place where guys have said for years they get ripped off.
i always get a bucket full of minnows- but i always buy a couple jigs, or sinkers, or bobbers, i'll pick up a rapala or a sutton spoon on occasion, and i've bought several rods and reels there over the years, and my merc. outboard. i buy my bullets there,too.
and i talk to the guy about what his neighbor, walmart, is doing to small businesses like his all across the country.
his prices on lures are very close to walmart, and he has what the local fish are hitting, not what some weinie in corporate purchasing thinks looks cool.

ALWAYS support local businesses of ALL types !!!



Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Pail Rider on Mar 08, 2007, 10:24 AM
ALWAYS support local businesses of ALL types !!!

You betcha, I'd rather pay a little more to help the little guy out than to give it to a large chain store.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: jigmasterjr on Mar 08, 2007, 02:16 PM
either way no one is forcing you to shop at their store, if their the only one around and you have to go their for bait so what quit b***hin or fish with artificials, i dont complain when i stop at the grocery store and get ripped off buying everything they sell, or for that matter  any store  and buy stuff made in china and taiwan for pennies on the dollar that im paying for it, its called good old american greed and it destroyed america, so why not give your money to the local guy not the corporate tycoon even if he's making a small percentage off it 'guys gotta live ya know'
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: grizzwald660 on Mar 08, 2007, 04:38 PM
very good post. maybe some people will see the other side. i've been to both types of bait shops. our guy here is fair. but he still needs to make a living as do you. remember this it sounds easy to have a business and make money. and the people i bought from that counted their bait were always there even if it was 6:00am. and from the looks of there vehicles they weren't getting rich. had to be something they enjoyed doing. my hats off to the little guy out there fighting coporate america. wow honey i've got a new job for us sitting at the kitchen table from 6 am to 9pm waiting for a few customers everyday. "were in the money were in the money"
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: esox slayer on Mar 08, 2007, 04:50 PM
CrayfishBob,I'm not asking for 24 minnows when I buy a Dozen but it would be nice to get 3 or 4 extra per dozen.( and I've never bought a dozen in my life,more 5 dozen or more)Do you sell dead waxy's and spikes to your customers? Are you a tight a## bait dealer too? As from as me thanking him for being there,your something else! Put the shoe on the other foot Bob.Would you like drop $20 or more a week for bait and get treated sooooo well.I never complained to the bait shop owner ever once, plus he OPENS at 9 o'clock and is closed on sunday. Probable the same hours you keep.

So what you're saying is that you'd like the dealer to give you 1 and 1/3rd dozen for every dozen you ask for??

I buy my bait at a couple local bait shops up here.  It would be "nice"..no make that "great" if they gave me the equivalent of "buy 3 dozen, get one dozen free" when I went in, but it doesn't happen.  They always make sure I get at least 1 or 2 extra minnows in my "dozen", but once in awhile that doesn't happen either, no big deal to me.  If I wanted 1 1/3rd dozen minnows each time to the bait shop, I'd tell them thats what I wanted.  I'm content with my usual bakers dozen minnows but sure as blazes don't get on a rant if it doesn't happen.

My guess is that you've never tried operating your own business before and had to deal with such trivial things as accounts payable, inventory loss, competition, utility bills, being a slave 24/7 to the store, etc.....just MY rant for the day....Esox
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Reel Wet Ride on Mar 08, 2007, 04:57 PM
You know, I don't think I've met one rich small baitshop owner. Not one. I, like almost everyone else, go there for all of one reason, bs a little, ask where, how deep, what on, and buy bait. No lures, no nets, nothing that he/she might actually make decent money on. So you know what I do, I buy what they sell me, if a doz. minnows is 12, and I wanted 14, I ask for another dozen and happily hand over my money.

I'm a small business owner, and I deal with numbers a lot bigger than 3 or 4 bucks, and I'm not even breaking even after 2+ years. Do I cry, no. Do I whine, no. Am I about to complain because I go to a bait shop 4 times a year and spend a grand total of 20.00 and the guy/girl behind the register isn't "hooking me up", not even close.  So do as others have suggested, switch places and make a living or think about if they weren't there at all.....Well then, you'd have nothing to complain about would you?!
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: buttlesdog on Mar 08, 2007, 06:04 PM
bless you buttlesdog !!
i couldn't have said it better myself !!
i get my bait at a place where guys have said for years they get ripped off.
i always get a bucket full of minnows- but i always buy a couple jigs, or sinkers, or bobbers, i'll pick up a rapala or a sutton spoon on occasion, and i've bought several rods and reels there over the years, and my merc. outboard. i buy my bullets there,too.
and i talk to the guy about what his neighbor, walmart, is doing to small businesses like his all across the country.
his prices on lures are very close to walmart, and he has what the local fish are hitting, not what some weinie in corporate purchasing thinks looks cool.

ALWAYS support local businesses of ALL types !!!



Sparky - Indeed, we share the same views, and I would argue... we "get it". Some of these guys are clowns... crying over $1.39. Im new to ice fishing, I got 6 rods, a strikemaster hand auger, an ice scoop, and some glo-jigs and grubs for around $230 when I went to stock up this year. The guy was happy to make the sale. I was thrilled its so damn cheap! I live near saltwater here right outside NYC. I spend that on gas some weekends just to putz around looking for fish. I wonder if some of these guys are sporting $300 power augers, $350 vex 8's, and still have to ask where the fish are while they moan and groan about the price of rice in china...

If we dont support these guys, they will find something else to do... I frequent 2 places, one for salt water, one for fresh. Both are owned and operated by Vietnam Vets. Guys who walked in jungles waiting to get their ass shot off to serve their country. Both have told me they dont know if they can do it much longer. That guys come in with the setups they buy at walmart, and want line put on for 3 bucks, then want to know where to find the fish. The saltwater guy sends them on wild goose chases, the freshwater guy tells them the same place he tells everyone else which is the same place all the walmart shoppers fish anyway, you know, that fished out lake the real guys laugh when they pass and see the walmart guys drowning minnows.

Support your local baitdealers folks,  it beats paying whatever you have to pay to get your grubs shipped from god knows where, and wont people cry double loud when half their bait shows up dead and there isnt a person to take it up with, just a reply to email address...
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: projoe on Mar 08, 2007, 06:22 PM
u think a dozen one the money is bad i have had shops wen i ask for 3 dozen they give me 2 and a half one time i countd how many he put in and we he went to give me my bucket back i told him he needs to give me 6 more and i had to count them out putting them back in his tank and showd him. i think he was doing this alot becaeu he gave me the bait for free and wen ever i go in to the shop now he gives me a dozen more then wat i ask for
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: zamboni on Mar 08, 2007, 06:40 PM
I am not even going to try getting in the middle of this, but remember one thing about bait shop owners-I think 9/10ths of all bait shop owners run the place and work there by themselves, one day closed a week sounds good to me. These guys sell bait all day and don't even get a chance to go out and fish themselves? They should be able to go out and have a day off. I used to help run 2 businesses, I wasn't the owner, but I worked 6 days a week, 11 hour days, it sucks. In order for them to get their days off, they'd have to pay someone $10 an hour to run their shop, would they sell $10 worth of stuff an hour to turn a profit, very doubtful.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: esox slayer on Mar 08, 2007, 06:46 PM
The whole idea of getting "3 or 4" free with each dozen is ludicrous.

I don't get 16 eggs when I buy a dozen,

I don't get 15 2x4's when I order 12,

why should I, or anybody else for that matter, expect any different from a bait shop as opposed to any other "by the dozen" purchases??  Esox
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: InSearchOfPerch on Mar 08, 2007, 06:52 PM
The bait shops around here in the dakotas for the most part buy wholesale minnows by the gallon not the pound...and It is ALOT less than 7 bucks a lb.  You dont buy retail from them by the dozen...its by the scoop...2 bucks a scoop..one of those little yellow plastic scoops.  You get about 30 crappie minnows or about 20 large minnows for the 2 bucks.  I agree about the euro's and waxies...order online...save alot.  I got 2000 Euro's for 16 bucks.  compared to 2 bucks per 30, not bad.  If I go into a shop and they start counting minnows instead of selling by the little yellow scoop...im out.  Counting is for shiners and chubs.  There are plenty of baitshops around and If I knew my competition sold by the dozen, I would change to sell by the scoop...the coupla bucks you lose per day will be made up by the 100's of dollars in tackle and munchies, rods, reels, etc. you are taking away from the clown down the road counting minnows.  I think this is a regional experience of buying from shops that sell by the dozen and by the scoop.  Around here no one sells by the dozen and no one would go there if they did.  In essence its not alot different..when you compare 12 minnows for $1.25 to a scoop for $2.  A scoop might include 30 percent more minnows or so but the price reflects the difference....the big difference is no one is killing 5 minutes counting minnows and a scoop is a scoop...meaning a scoop minus 3 minows is still pretty much a scoop....a dozen minus 3 minnows is a rip off.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: mattmull10 on Mar 08, 2007, 07:23 PM
Lol i wasnt going to post on this but i'm a jerk so here it goes.  When you goto the butcher and ask for 3 lbs NY strip do you get 3.5lbs or 3lbs?  When you go and buy sandwhich meat and ask for 1lb turkey, .5lbs of roast beef and a pound of provolone do you get any extra in their?????

Before i moved i went to the same local bait shop in NY and you know what once in a while a dozen was 16 or 5 dozen was 70 but would I ever think less of the shop because she actually gave me the 5 dozen i asked for?????

This has got to win an award for dumbest thread of the year. 
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: ice dawg on Mar 08, 2007, 07:23 PM
Where I buy bait in South Dakota they are $1.25 for a scoop and if you get a card from the bait shop they are $1.00 per scoop and they punch the card for each scoop purchased. When the card has all ten spaces punched you get a free scoop. I did have minnows and red wigglers counted out by hand when I lived in Colorado though.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: ice dawg on Mar 08, 2007, 07:29 PM
Lol i wasnt going to post on this but i'm a jerk so here it goes.  When you goto the butcher and ask for 3 lbs NY strip do you get 3.5lbs or 3lbs?  When you go and buy sandwhich meat and ask for 1lb turkey, .5lbs of roast beef and a pound of provolone do you get any extra in their?????

Before i moved i went to the same local bait shop in NY and you know what once in a while a dozen was 16 or 5 dozen was 70 but would I ever think less of the shop because she actually gave me the 5 dozen i asked for?????

This has got to win an award for dumbest thread of the year. 

Yup, Now the butcher is in the bait business. lol I remember when my dad would buy weiners out of the meat case at the butcher shop and when you bought a pound they always weighed out a pound and threw another weiner in the package. I think this comes from the old "bakers dozen" where you would get 13 donuts or rolls instead of twelve. The guy at the baitshop that I go to sells wax worms two dozen to a container and he always has  28 worms in them.  ;)
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: captain54 on Mar 08, 2007, 09:57 PM
Esox Slayer, I don't expect extra bait ,but it would be a nice gesture to get a few extra minnows when you buy 12 doz. at a time.Why do you think I buy large amounts of bait,because I KNOW I'm not going to get any extra.As for running a business I have since 1975 ,and I no how to treat my customers fairly and honestly. And I am anti Wal-Mart but just like everyone you and I do buy something there.And just like everyone else everybody looks for a deal. All you guys say you gladly pay a higher price, are really not ,$279.00 for a vex or $350.00.Gee let me think.....I'll take the one for 350.00 to help the little guy...I bet you would... To Bob with the bait shop,Whats your mark up on lures? I know It's big ,and they just sit there and never go bad,great shelf life.I'd like to buy a product for 5 to 7 bucks( minnow) and sell it for 27 bucks as you said you make on them.I know it tough to make a living being self employed but my post was really about being treated a little better by the bait shop owner.Sorry to all that I offended,but I'm almost positive that most of you guys have been ticked off at least once or twice at your bait man.I hope we can move on the better topics and let this one rest.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crayfishbob on Mar 08, 2007, 10:20 PM
The common retail markup goes as follows : Devide the price you buy something by .6. you should get a ballpark figure. For example, $1.00 equates to $1.66 Big ticket items get chopped a bit, but for small items this works well.

The prices I quoted on minnows reflect going price on fatheads last fall at aprox 225 to 275 minnows per lb.
Big shiners are different.

Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: scansy on Mar 09, 2007, 06:37 AM
One question for the guys who have run/owned a bait shop - and I'm asking out of curiosity, not to make a point of any kind.

Do most bait shops "make money" off of their bait, or is it just a necessary thing to have or else most guys aren't coming in to the store.  Is it "bait" :D to get guys in and while they are there they buy a couple of lures, drinks, a net, rod, whatever?

The reason I ask is that there are two local convenience stores that are big here in PA (outside of the national chains) - WaWa and Sheetz.  Both of them started selling gas in recent years and are generally cheaper than the average gas station by a few cents a gallon.  I read somewhere that they only try to break even on gas or maybe make a little bit of money - have enough income to pay for the gas, maintaining the pumps, etc.  But that the gas has people come in and then they buy coffee, donuts, drinks, hoagies, etc. - and that's where they make money.

Is bait the same as gas?
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: esox slayer on Mar 09, 2007, 06:43 AM
One question for the guys who have run/owned a bait shop - and I'm asking out of curiosity, not to make a point of any kind.

Do most bait shops "make money" off of their bait, or is it just a necessary thing to have or else most guys aren't coming in to the store.  Is it "bait" :D to get guys in and while they are there they buy a couple of lures, drinks, a net, rod, whatever?

The reason I ask is that there are two local convenience stores that are big here in PA (outside of the national chains) - WaWa and Sheetz.  Both of them started selling gas in recent years and are generally cheaper than the average gas station by a few cents a gallon.  I read somewhere that they only try to break even on gas or maybe make a little bit of money - have enough income to pay for the gas, maintaining the pumps, etc.  But that the gas has people come in and then they buy coffee, donuts, drinks, hoagies, etc. - and that's where they make money.

Is bait the same as gas?

A lot of stuff in retail is, or was referred to as a "loss leader".  Some items for example were sold at or maybe even slightly below cost, something the competition didn't sell so cheaply, in order to draw people to "your" store...

Point of Purchase (POP) stuff that grabs your eye at the counter when you hit checkout/ the cashier is designed  specifically to draw your attention to the item in question.....Esox
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: scansy on Mar 09, 2007, 07:18 AM
Point of Purchase (POP) stuff that grabs your eye at the counter when you hit checkout/ the cashier is designed  specifically to draw your attention to the item in question.....Esox

Oh, you mean the stuff the kids beg for when you are leaving.  "Pleeeeeeease can I get gum.  Pleeeeeeeaaaaaassssee.  I promise, it won't end up in my sister's hair this time."

 ::)
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Tim Hanford on Mar 09, 2007, 09:27 AM
From my experience running a tackle shop for 3 years, live baits sales are a big money maker.  At least they were for us with our prices. 

Fishing rods, soft pastic lures and live bait were our big money makers.  Hard baits like Bandit crankbaits for example we didn't make squat on them, about a quarter, but carried them because they were popular.  Now high end lures like Lucky Craft and Megabass had BIG markups on them.

Rods are a big money maker with a huge markup but the profit on reels is very, very little.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: keva on Mar 09, 2007, 10:23 AM
I only read the first page of post, but I am with crayfishbob. A dozen minnows means 12 and you have no reason to get angry at someone for giving you what you asked for. They are trying to run a business. They shouldn't be giving you dead bait, I agree completely there. It is nice when they give you a few extras, but they don't have to. The 20 minutes is too long, but I doubt she took 20 minutes. I would becareful of what you are doing to these baitshops, it sounds as if NY is giving them a hard time and they don't need the anglers giving them a hard time too.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: RLWagner on Mar 09, 2007, 10:28 AM
If 12 allways meant 12, the it would not be such a big deal. But for most of our lives, a dozen meant a GOOD scoop! Two or three dozen meant an army of minnows. Now in the last year or so there is a transition going on that is hard to get use to. Weather itis based on minnows, donuts or anything else, there was a norm, and it is now evolving into something hard to deal with. The prices are soaring, and the count is declining.
I personally think the discontentwith 12 for a dozen is not that we cannot afford it, but we have been use to a dozen actually meaning more, for a reasonable price, one that allowed the bait shop to make a living, and fisherman to afford bait weekly.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: downRIVER on Mar 09, 2007, 10:59 AM
Supply and Demand.

All this talk about back in the day, 18 miles uphill both ways.

GET OVER IT!
IT IS TIME TO COMPETE and SURVIVE!

Don't expect extras, be happy when you get them.
Be happy your local bait shop is still a bait shop.


Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: pembroke on Mar 09, 2007, 11:56 AM
So you want 15 or 18 or 24 to be a dozen. If so you will have to help me out with some of my expenses.
1. because of A new law in NY I get my fatheads from the south west US at double the price of the ones I used to get locally.
2. emerald shiners I used to get from the Niagara River now come from Wisconsin at almost 3 times the cost.
3. We had 2 feet of snow in October and had no electric for four days. I lost all my minnows overnight as I could not even get to the shop. That storm shut most fishing down that month as people had to clean up after the storm.
4. No ice in Dec.
5. No ice until end of Jan.
6. taxes went up
7. insurance went up
8. The house I rent in front of the shop was vacant for 2 months
9. had a broken water pipe in the shop
10. Had a leak in the bait tank.
11. repaired refrigerator in the shop
12. Shop needs a roof
the above is just a partial list, then your have shoplifters, guys who think it's a good idea to take a leak in your driveway or think you should be open 24/7 or how about the guy who kicks the s**t out of your bait machine.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: RLWagner on Mar 09, 2007, 12:08 PM
Not expecting anymore than 12, just trying to explain that the recent change in practice, albeit neded, may have confused some into angryness. If they understood your angle, as they may now, it should help. Thanks for sharing your angle.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crayfishbob on Mar 09, 2007, 06:04 PM
Having a baitshop is not a business, its a service to the fishing community.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: hunters08 on Mar 09, 2007, 06:10 PM
So you want 15 or 18 or 24 to be a dozen. If so you will have to help me out with some of my expenses.
1. because of A new law in NY I get my fatheads from the south west US at double the price of the ones I used to get locally.
2. emerald shiners I used to get from the Niagara River now come from Wisconsin at almost 3 times the cost.
3. We had 2 feet of snow in October and had no electric for four days. I lost all my minnows overnight as I could not even get to the shop. That storm shut most fishing down that month as people had to clean up after the storm.
4. No ice in Dec.
5. No ice until end of Jan.
6. taxes went up
7. insurance went up
8. The house I rent in front of the shop was vacant for 2 months
9. had a broken water pipe in the shop
10. Had a leak in the bait tank.
11. repaired refrigerator in the shop
12. Shop needs a roof
the above is just a partial list, then your have shoplifters, guys who think it's a good idea to take a leak in your driveway or think you should be open 24/7 or how about the guy who kicks the s**t out of your bait machine.
sounds like you better close your shop
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crafty1 on Mar 09, 2007, 06:32 PM
hey hunters08 what is the site you order from for the spikes and wax worms...and how long is it for delivery.just curious,and thinking of doing it too(good idea)
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: shrub on Mar 09, 2007, 06:37 PM
there is 3 or 4 bait shopsin my area, all but 1 are anywhere near all the local bodies of water, so this is the bait shop i give my business to. he does not sell a lot of tackle and stuff like that, he has bait nets, buckets terminal tackle and a few tip ups and jig rods. but the bait is his major business, me and my buddies spend allot of money their during the winter. and we always get extra bait, a dozen of the smaller bait tends to  equal 2 dozen. a dozen of the more expensive bigger baits tends to equal a dozen and a half. is this whey i go there? no i go there because it is close to where i fish,the bait is reasonably prised, there is always someone there, and the owner are really nice. but getting more bait than you pay for is nice to ;)
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: walleyeslayer on Mar 09, 2007, 06:44 PM
can you order wigglers online? lol  i had a guy this morning give me a real deal, 2 dozen dead rotting wigglers for the low price of 3 dollars.  got to the lake, and i was able to get 4 wigglers on the hook....only 2 were alive, and all the rest melted in my fingers before i could get them on the hook, man was i pissed, i call the store, some dude answers and tells me to bring back the dead ones, and hed swap with me, i guess that was a half assed effort to make it right.  thank god im the walleyeslayer, and i overcame by sheer willpower, and caught the fish.  it woulda been better to just offer me a free dozen friggin wigglers (alive) which is all i wanted in the first place, instead of pawning off his garbage to me, 2 dozen rotting wigglers...i feel like i was hustled..i prolly bought 100 dollars in bait alone from the guy this short winter, not including numerous lures trying to support his business, damned if you do, damned if you dont
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crafty1 on Mar 09, 2007, 06:50 PM
that cracked me up walleyeslayer,thats why i wanted to see if you could buy the spikes and waxes on line..and the main thing i was wondering was how long until they were delivered to the house
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: hunters08 on Mar 09, 2007, 06:56 PM
hey hunters08 what is the site you order from for the spikes and wax worms...and how long is it for delivery.just curious,and thinking of doing it too(good idea)
www.jadabaits.net Free shipping   1-800-861-4415 Faster if you call in your order usually around 5 days
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crafty1 on Mar 09, 2007, 07:01 PM
thats perfect im going next weekend.thanks for the info hunters08
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: pikeking on Mar 09, 2007, 09:49 PM
Order them online 1000 for 5.99 put them in a paper bag in your basement or fridge if she will let you. Fish smarter not harder.  Cabela's has them or find a garden shop online.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crafty1 on Mar 09, 2007, 10:06 PM
yea thats what i want to do,hunters08 is going to get the web site for it,and believe me she'll let me put little worms in the fridge,every year i have bags of squid and spearing stinking up the freezer sometimes when im go fluke,flounder,and striped bass fishing down the road from me,so little worms are a walk in the park for her...lol
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: hunters08 on Mar 09, 2007, 10:36 PM
the corrected site is www,jadabait.net same phone number
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: crafty1 on Mar 09, 2007, 10:56 PM
thanks good luck to everyone, and hope everyone has a great & safe time of catching the big ones...
                                  p.s. just let me post the biggest one after next weekend lol
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: buttlesdog on Mar 10, 2007, 05:41 AM
yea thats what i want to do,hunters08 is going to get the web site for it,and believe me she'll let me put little worms in the fridge,every year i have bags of squid and spearing stinking up the freezer sometimes when im go fluke,flounder,and striped bass fishing down the road from me,so little worms are a walk in the park for her...lol

Yo Crafty, I live on the other side of the LI sound in Mamaroneck... nothing, and I mean nothing, smells worse than a nice rotting bunker!! If you come up this way to ice fish, through Westchester, we have some very good bait dealers in this neck, PM me and we can discuss...
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: keva on Mar 10, 2007, 06:04 PM
Think of is as you will, but it is a business. They may be helping you a lot, but they are still looking for a profit. There is nothing wrong with running a business.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: BASSandICE65 on Mar 10, 2007, 08:33 PM
For mealworms buy them at a pet store I get 500 hundred for 7.95! They use them for lizards. As for shiners throw out some minnow traps until you find them well worth the effort to catch your own bait. The bait stores in my area suck they know nothing about the local fishing just want to sell you bait!!! :%$#!:

Keith
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: CHICKENFOOT on Mar 12, 2007, 02:58 PM
THERE IS ONE ON 23 IN NJ IS THE CHEAPEST!! COUNTS THE BAIT WITH A DIP NET AND YOU ASK FOR A PARTICULAR SIZE IT IS LIKE PULLING TEETH. GOT TO RES TO FISH AND THREE HAD DIED TOLD HIM,TOLD ME HE IS NOT RESPONSIBLE MORE INTERRESTED IN DOING THE CROSSWORD PUZZLE THAN HELPING A FISHERMAN
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Big Burk on Mar 14, 2007, 09:23 PM
the gas stations where i fish always have dead maggots, meal worms, leaches or worms when you buy them but the tackle shop in the same town right next to the one gas station goes through his bait every few days and if you have dead ones he will replace them if you bring them back within half an hour. i hate buying bait at the gas stations but till the tackle shop opens up in april looks like im stuck buying crappy bait. tell me in 30 maggots, only 13 were alive? >:( they were good when they were put in the fridge was all i was told when i complained about the bait. me hates that place :-\ >:(
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: cold_feet on Mar 15, 2007, 08:16 AM
All I got to say is get over it. I mean come on you go to buy bait and if they sell Minnows by the dozen then you get a dozen, not 24 not 18 not 13. Why is it everyone thinks they should get something free. As far as buying grubs and such well do as I do Open the container in the store and look at them before you purchase. If half are dead well Say so right there and then. If the owner has a problem about it well then Leave them right where ya found them and do yourself a favor and order 5,000 from a bait supplier and split the costs. One other option is Open a shop yourself. These people who do this for a living are living on pennies the Ma and Pa shops are about done for because of the big businesses who have enough money to purchase products and sit on them a year before someone  purchases them. Not the ma and pa shops who have to dig into their bank accounts and purchase  everything and sit on the there inventory until someone decides they need to buy a bag of split shots for a buck. No one is telling you you must buy from these people so why complain if you are too cheap to drive that extra 15 miles to the next baitshop well thats your problem not the owners. For me If I get lousy service or someone sells me dead bait Ill never go back period! Yet if I can talk to the owners or people who work there and feel I am important to there business well I guess I will go back many times. As a owner being rude to customers is no excuse. But expecting a gas station attendant who sells bait to know where the fish are biting well Doh what would you expect. I look at it this way, These shops are comming into a slack time of year where all the bait and tackle they bought is either going to die or lie on the shelf for at least a month or two just because of the weather. That relates to a loss. In a month or two they have to restock there bait supplies which is another hit on there pocketbook until that bait is sold. Until the time where they start selling regularly they must keep the shop open which cost money for elect to run the lights, coolers, Aerators, and gas for there vehicles to get to work. To basically sell nothing. Not much profits if you ask me. So before you complain about a guy not giving you those extra minnows look a little more deeply into his situation, it surely isn't a pretty one if you ask me and again if you don't like it Take a ride 15 miles down the road to the guy who gives them away free.
Just My .02
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: IceholeFisherman on Mar 19, 2007, 01:13 PM
For mealworms buy them at a pet store I get 500 hundred for 7.95! They use them for lizards. As for shiners throw out some minnow traps until you find them well worth the effort to catch your own bait. The bait stores in my area suck they know nothing about the local fishing just want to sell you bait!!! :%$#!:

Keith

My bait dealer is the only one in town. The owner was hospitalized and his wife said they didn't think they would be in business much longer. Bummer. Didn't have any live bait in stock. I took a chance and went to the local pet store. They had waxies and mealworms as well as other things. The waxies were 50 cents cheaper per 50 then the bait store was. Now I'm not one to cry over 50cents, and would gladly pay it for the conversation value. The pet store people don't get the info the bait dealers get. Pet stores are another small business alternative to Wal Mart but your not going to get lures there.

I can get live bait without even having to leave the house. My wife has a "critter" problem and is at the pet store at least once a week. So I just have her pick them up for me. I am thinking of getting her professional help but that is another subject. Any one have a reference to a good therapist? LOL
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Mentiply on Mar 19, 2007, 08:02 PM
Reading this topic I only have one question. There are two bait shops in town both equally easy to access. Which shop would you buy your bait from.

Shop A charges $2.00 for a dozen shiners and counts them out.

Shop B charges $2.50 for a dozen shiners but always throws one or two more in.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: buttlesdog on Mar 20, 2007, 08:36 AM
I would go to the one that knows the fishing conditions and appreciates my business most.
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Mainehazmt on Mar 20, 2007, 09:54 AM
you guys I guess shouldnt complain  your bait prices are cheap   we pay about 6 + a doz for minnows up here   Well mine were all free this year (kinda) trapped my own  yes they count out each one   but they live!  trap your own they can be kept all year if ya pay attention   I still have 400 or so alot still from 8 mo ago  hate to waste em now but cant put em back and cant give them away   the way the laws are now adays    maybe they will help my garden or  plant a few with my each of my corn seeds  like the pilgrams did (as was reported in school many years ago)   
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: pyle on Mar 20, 2007, 10:07 AM
We pay $8.99 a doz for pike chubs and for the BIG ones there a buck to $1.50 a piece......so 6 isnt bad
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: SpEeD on Mar 20, 2007, 02:28 PM
We pay $8.99 a doz for pike chubs and for the BIG ones there a buck to $1.50 a piece......so 6 isnt bad

Then to think we are suppose to throw them away after 7 days if the rules don't change :'(  Lets hope the DEC comes to there sense around here with the receipt rule by next ice season ???
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: pyle on Mar 20, 2007, 02:35 PM
Just need to make my own recipts...lol
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: SpEeD on Mar 20, 2007, 02:44 PM
Just need to make my own receipts...lol

Yep - That is one of the plans for now ;) Just sucks that law abiding sportsmen have to resort to such measures because of a poorly thought out regulation >:(
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: Luffy on Mar 20, 2007, 03:05 PM
Our local shop is great!  (Mitchells - Rochester, NY)  Always open, has everything, good prices, the bait lasts for weeks, throws in a couple extra, etc. etc....    I always try to get bait there before going on road trips, as you can never tell what you're going to get when you're away from home...  recently had a bad experience in black lake with the half the damn bait dying between the shop and the lake...   happened everyday, all week...  we'll stop at mitchells first next time
Title: Re: Cheap A ## bait shops
Post by: SpEeD on Mar 20, 2007, 04:12 PM
Our local shop is great!  (Mitchells - Rochester, NY)  Always open, has everything, good prices, the bait lasts for weeks, throws in a couple extra, etc. etc....    I always try to get bait there before going on road trips, as you can never tell what you're going to get when you're away from home...  recently had a bad experience in black lake with the half the d**n bait dying between the shop and the lake...   happened everyday, all week...  we'll stop at mitchells first next time

Agree 110% with you Luffy regarding Mitchell's bait - That is where I get all my bait from too even though they are on the other side of town and a little out of the way for me when fishing my favorite ponds. I have complimented them many times on the hardiness of there bait and that is where the problems lies with the new 7 day rule as I do keep my leftover certified bait to use the following days\weekends and the minnows just don't die off storing them in the garage waiting to go fishing with me again;D