Rose Valley Lake

[moosefeet]

How is the perch and Walleye fishing on this lake?

[isthereiceyet89]

It's nickname is death valley and I have experienced it's truth!!! Lol

[hard water jim]

I have fished it 3 times and never did well. Bunch of hammer handles is all I ever caught. Some guys say they do ok there just hasn't been good for me.

[wayno2469]

i have fished there quite a bit. I have never done well ice fishing. In the summer I have had good days and bad. i have never been able to figure the place out. Have fun and stay safe

[Jason1817]

I’ve spent many hours searching for walleyes haven’t caught one out of rose valley. If you can find the perch they are generally nice ones. I have noticed they can be quite finicky. Personally Id skip rose valley and head to tioga county.

[Bra]

I fished Rose Valley about 5 times last season and enjoyed every trip I was looking to walk across new lake which one do you suggest in Tioga county

[PAFishFiend]

Hills Creek in Tioga County is a pretty reliable lake to have good safe ice when others don't.

[PAFishFiend]

Black Moshannon is one in Centre County that gets and holds ice pretty reliably. It's the elevation there and the fact that it's in a deep "pocket" that makes it pretty reliable for good ice.

[nindo24]

Black Moshannon is one in Centre County that gets and holds ice pretty reliably. It's the elevation there and the fact that it's in a deep "pocket" that makes it pretty reliable for good ice.

This lake can be a pain too though.

[PAFishFiend]

The best way to fish Black Moshannon is to dig a lot of holes and keep moving. I know that's the strategy for many lakes but at Black Mo, I don't even start until I've dug 10 holes.

[tipwaydown]

I know with the weather and rain things aren't probably any good. But did it open it wide open or break away from the banks.

[JK]

Passed by at noon there were two guys north of the cause way.  A few south of the north parking lot in the cove.  None in the center half of the lake and 4 or 5 groups scattered around the East and south boat launch.  So about a dozen people and I am not one of them yet.  I could not find anyone to talk to, do know how think the ice is.  I will wait.  Becareful and have a buddy with you......jk

[JK]

one person only and they were south of the north boat launch.  That is all folks.  Not for me yet......jk

[beerduck]

saw the same person ice sketchy at best just not ready yet possibly hit the right spot and there will be another cold water rescue