It has been a tough year. Why the fly reel? Just trying to avoid the spinning action of the lures? Interesting thought and may be worth trying (for trout).
I was out today and had nothing in shallow then went out over the channel near Lazy Boy and had five on within 30 minutes (only two landed, 2 lost at the hole!??). All were at the bottom in 29FOW and took Radical Glow pink tube jigs, deadsticked and tipped with waxies. I only saw one more fish the rest of the day (until 4PM). Yikes! Maybe I'll give the Mile a rest for a week.
I sure would have loved to fight a pike for 20 minutes. It's been a while since I've had a decent one through the ice.