I have the 48" Jiggler and the 54" Pulsator. I use each one about equally as much as the other - whatever I grab first. Each line holder (reel) has its pros and cons, but they both signal a bite, set a hook well, and are fun to use. The Jiggler reel is more susceptible to having the line slip out of the spool and get tangled, but once I learned to pay attention, it's not a big deal.