I prefer the GULP product myself......the eggs are a good producer and the small jar has close to 50 eggs in it. I have also heard alot of guys using the GULP roe saks......not sure how many come to a jar since i can't find any. Not sure if thats the tip off or not. Like any day some will outfish the other. When trout fishing its better to have the lot with you....spikes, GULP baits, waxies and sometimes even the good'ol nightcrawler. Trout will "key" in on one food source over the other alot. The best bet is to ice the first keeper and play doctor to see whats on the menue for the day........"match the hatch"!!!!!!