IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community
Ice Fishing Tips -Check your local regulations! => Dressing for ice fishing => Topic started by: noelaar on Dec 17, 2012, 03:48 PM
-
Anyone have their insite on what boot would be warmer and hopefully last alittle longer? Looking to buy a boot that will keep me warm in our negatives we get. Please feel free to post what boot you suggest!
Thank you!
-
Rubber insulated boots tend to leak alot less...I've switched over to Muck boots and haven't used anything else since...but then again, my feet don't get cold, so that plays no part in my decision.
-
I was looking into a Cabela's Comfort Trac 2,000 gram. The muck is right along the lines of that
-
i use the arctic sport muck boot.nice for many reasons.my feet dont get cold in them and if its sloppy on top my feet are dry.i do move around alot but have been up on a small lake in indian lake where it was 30 below wind chill and these kept me warm.just my opinion to get these.you will pay for em but they are great.
-
I have both lacross burleys and artic sport muck boots. When I go outside for extended periods, I always grab the lacross. Good thing is, the muck boots still look new. ;D
-
Cant go wrong with the Lacrosse Burlys espically when the ice is slushy and wet
-
I gotta go with the Mucks. I have a 250.00 pair of Rockys I bought for hunting and I have not put them on since I got my Mucks. And I don't even have the Arctic Mucks.
-
go with Mucks!
-
What gram insulation do you guys have in your boot?
-
I use Muck - Arctic Pro. Feet will stay warm to -30, and your feet can't get wet! I WILL NEVER USE ANYTHING ELSE FOR ICE FISHING
-
What gram insulation do you guys have in your boot?
I wear the Muck Wetlands. The only insulation they have is the neoprene.
-
Irish Setter Rutmasters here, and they are without a doubt the nicest thing I have ever owned.
Pac boots are warm, but they cant stay submerged without leaking somewhat.
-
A good ice boot should be rated at -80 to -100. I like the pac boot, they do need to be sealed with bee's wax once a yr.For standing in more water the muck boots would be better. Right tool for the right job
-
Cant go wrong with the Lacrosse Burlys espically when the ice is slushy and wet
this is what i wear all ice season with an extra felt in the bottom of the boot
-
I've got lacross burlies in 1200 gram. Love em. Getting he wife mucks for Christmas.
-
Muck boots are great. If I didn't destroy them they will last you. I have had mine for four years. I used these boots through blow downs and clearcuts they still are dry despite the quarter inch tear I put in the exterior of the boot. Great set of boots that being said I dont have experience with other rubber boots.
-
Mickey mouse boots. I also wear 800 gram read head burly boots on warmer days.
-
Check out Baffin Impacts. The 8 layer liners are like walking on air and they aren't to heavy at 3.5 lbs each (size 12). They run a size small.
http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm (http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm)
(http://img-1.gearbuyer.com/baffin-impact_snow_boot-mens_color_black_p1_.jpg)
The Lacrosse 2000 gram boots are rated to -80*f, the Baffin Impacts are rated to -148*f. I've never worn the heavy insulated rubber boots, but once I wore the Impacts I don't need to. I will end up with a pair of 1200 rubber boots for hunting and warm weather ice fishing. But when it's cold I'll be sporting my Impacts.
-
Check out Baffin Impacts. The 8 layer liners are like walking on air and they aren't to heavy at 3.5 lbs each (size 12). They run a size small.
http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm (http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm)
(http://img-1.gearbuyer.com/baffin-impact_snow_boot-mens_color_black_p1_.jpg)
The Lacrosse 2000 gram boots are rated to -80*f, the Baffin Impacts are rated to -148*f. I've never worn the heavy insulated rubber boots, but once I wore the Impacts I don't need to. I will end up with a pair of 1200 rubber boots for hunting and warm weather ice fishing. But when it's cold I'll be sporting my Impacts.
Baffins rule :thumbsup:
-
For me, it's Mucks 99% of the time. Can't beat them, in my opinion...
-
I have a pair of the cabelas Saskatchewan PAC boots and they are warm and kept me dry on a day where we were fishing in4" of water on top of the ice last year.....and they r scent lock so if I ever hunt in cold cold weather I'll be warm too.
-
I use 1200 gram burleys. Same pair for two seasons of ice fishing and deer season. Feet never get cold or wet.
-
I just got my cabelas trans alaskans in the mail the other day. Have not been able to use them yet this year but have heard nothing but good reviews about them. I upgraded from a pair of 2000 g itiscas from gander mountain. They made my feet sweat and then they would get cold no matter what sock combo I would try.
-
I just got my cabelas trans alaskans in the mail the other day. Have not been able to use them yet this year but have heard nothing but good reviews about them. I upgraded from a pair of 2000 g itiscas from gander mountain. They made my feet sweat and then they would get cold no matter what sock combo I would try.
I wear very thin wool socks so my feet dont sweet. I carry a pair of heavy socks with me in case its extra cold but rarely need them
-
Ever since they came out with those chemical toe warmers I haven't suffered from cold feet. I wear a pair of insulated rubber boots, knee high and if it is going to be cold out I just get a pair of the toe warmers, stick them on the top of my wool socks and put the boots on. No cold feet. They last a long time and I've never used more that one in a day. I used to get forced off the deer stand due to cold feet, but haven't had that happen in years now. You just need to make sure you have a little extra room in the toe of your boot to accomodate them.
-
I've always wore my 1500 gram Alphaburlys and my feet are always warm. However I think I'm gonna get a pair of the artic sport muck boots for this winter ( if it ever shows up). The rubber on my Alphaburlys is in pretty rough shape
-
Had good luck with the mickey mouse boots. The black or the white ones will work well even in conditions when inches of water are on the ice.
-
Love my Mickey Mouse Boots
-
Mickey mouse boots have always kept my feet warm and dry and my feet are usually cold....
-
The thing I didnt like about rubber boots is they dont breath good. And your feet are only an inch off the ice. New ones I got have 3 inches beneath feet. Hopefully soon I will get to try them.
-
Thank you all for the information ill be researching all the suggestions! We'll be out there on Christmas the weather is looking good after friday in the ADK :tipup: :icefish:
-
Like many of the others said, you can't beat the Mucks. Not only do I use them for fishing, I wear them for work almost every day. One of the most comfortable boots I have ever owned. I have, on several occasions, had to walk 2-5 miles through the woods wearing them. they are awesome.
-
I have had Muck Arctic Sports for 5 years and love them. Light comfortable and warm enough for me. I have fished in 10'' of slush all day and stayed warm and dry. You won't regret buying them. You will wonder how you fished without them.
-
I swiched to lacross burlys a couple years ago and I think they work great. The only problem I had was cold creeping in through the sole from standing on the ice so I cut an old felt boot liner and made inserts to help insulate the bottom of my foot. Another thing I noticed is if the walk is tough and my feet sweat they would get cold when I stopped to sit and fish. To remedy that a good pair of polypropelene socks under my wool socks will wick the moisture away.
-
MUCKS awesome,hanksclothing.com best prices
-
I have LaCrosse boots also. Work well, but heavy. Muck boots do not work for me even in early bow season. :tipup:
-
I have a pair of cabela's inferno pack boots i look them much more them my rubber boots.
-
I have been a pacboot guy all my life and love the Baffin Expeditions.... They are great but a little heavy... I just got a pair of Muck Arctic Pros that i cant wait to try out.... They are 1/3 the weight of the Baffin's...
-
i wear Bogs. Same thing as mucks for the most part with 100% satisfaction guarantee. Great customer service. I complained about teh camp rubbing off one pair i had and they sent me out a brand new pair the next day and let me keep the old ones no questions asked. I just recently picked up their blaze 1000's rated to -65. Very light and comfortable as well as waterproof.
-
If you don't mind spending $250 to $300 or more for a pair of boots.....that's fine BUT No matter how much money you spend, you will never find a better pair of boots to keep your feet WARM & DRY than MICKEY MOUSE BOOTS (by Bada).
After more than fifty (yes, 50 ) years on the ice, I will never wear any other boot for warmth, comfort, and dryness.
PS....MICKEY MOUSE BOOTS CAN BE BOUGHT FOR ABOUT $35 TO $40 DOLLARS !!!! Spend the rest of your money on a nice dinner out for you and the wife (or GF).
-
Love my Trans Alaskans!
-
micky mouses for me!
-
lacross alpha i had for 6 years now not one problem only use them for iceing there are 130 bucks rated mi 100 below .very good boot pac
-
I have an old pair of Sorels that were made in Canada and I still use them all the time. You do need to seal them once a year and I've never had them leak. I also have Trans-Alaskas but find them a little hard to walk in. However, they are warm.
-
My feet are always cold. I have a set of LL bean Maine hunting boots that I've had for over 25 years (whew). When I wear them, my feet are warm and toasty. They are still waterproof despite the fact that I've never treated them.
If they still made them this way, I'd buy another set in a heart beat just to have a back up.
I just picked up some Mickey's and am looking forward to trying them out. I do have a set of 1000g neoprene mucks from dicks that are ok for early bow, but I wouldn't wear them on the ice for an extended time.
-
:-\ can't seem to keep my feet warm. What do you guys wear I can't wear heavy boots bad knee,I've tried muck,rockys,PAC you name it.thanks
-
wear a comfortable boot with warmers in them
-
I would say artic mucks but you said you tried mucks I had issues with my feet too but once I got the mucks haven't had issues since once in a while throwing a little foot warmers for the real cold days
-
Cabelas Trans Alaskas.
ave.wt 5.8lbs/pr
Almost too warm and dry. 6 or 7 years on mine this year.
RG
-
Try the Sorel Glacier boots they are very warm and rated for 100 below I use them and love them
-
Definitely look at the Muck Arctic Boots. I have a pair of high ones. Totally waterproof, no laces, good tread, lightweight, easy on & off, these have really made the difference for me out there. They're also great for winter tractor work when you're exposed for long periods to wind and cold.
Love 'em!
Grady
-
go on ebay and get yourself a pair of white mickey mouse boots for under 50 dollars. i promise you you will never buy a different boot again. they are the best boots i have ever owned hands down i have turned many people onto these boots and everyone has said they are the best boots they have ever worn. i usually get my boots from alleghany outlet store through ebay. jost got three pairs for my buddies last week
-
I have a pair of boots that are rubber bottom and leather tops. They have a foam pull out liner in them. I believe they came from Cabela's. They were very in-expensive and very warm.
kc
-
Try the new ThermaCell remote controlled heated insoles.
-
the best part about mickeys is that they have no liners it is all rubber on the inside i have fallen in and filled the boots with water and dumped the boots out wiped them with a towel put them on my feet and spent the whole rest of the day outside
-
go on ebay and get yourself a pair of white mickey mouse boots for under 50 dollars. i promise you you will never buy a different boot again. they are the best boots i have ever owned hands down i have turned many people onto these boots and everyone has said they are the best boots they have ever worn. i usually get my boots from alleghany outlet store through ebay. jost got three pairs for my buddies last week
X2
-
Sportsman Guide 2400 gram insulated boots, I too had a hard time keeping my feet warm. Keyword - HAD, those boots are awesome
-
Baffin-impacts. There is no other to solve cold feet. Rated to -148. Don't buy white or black mickeys If you have cold feet problems already. The mickeys will get you out there, but you won't stay long. So what you can dump water from the boot and keep on fishing. How about the days when it's one of the coldest days of the year? No chance of a wet foot, only super cold toes. The Impacts will make your day more enjoyable.
-
I've tried muck,rockys,PAC you name it.thanks
Tried all those myself...I now wear cabelas trans alaskans. They have a pocket for chemical warmer built right in them, and I have never had to use the warmers. ;)
Everybody's foot is different, you have to keep trying different boots until you find the ones that work for you.
I found mine. ;D
-
cabelas knee high rubber boots 2000 gram thinsulate, or cabelas pac boot 1200 gram is what i wear but i wear a pair of goriga low heel loggers steel toe non insulated all day long working on the rail and my feet are just as warm as my rubber boots, so im not sure im a big help, but i like my pacs and my rubber boots, for fishing both my knees, and 1 hip are messed up and i dont have an issue with those boots.
-
I just got the Cabelas Inferno boot and they are just that! These boots keep my feet toasty warm. They seem pretty light but they are bulky. They are pretty wide. The other day I was on the ice for about an hour with these boots slush covered and my feet were super warm. Sounds like you have pretty picky feet though so maybe you should make a day trip to a Cabelas north or south of Ny and try on a bunch of boots and finish your shopping for ice gear ;)
-
I have been impressed with Muck boot (woody Max) . Never had cold feet in two years of pretty rugged abuse deer hunting and ice fishing. I am over 300lbs and usually destroy boots in a season but these have fared well light comfortable and warm . Good lugs and traction for mud also but way to warm for bow season though. They are pricey but foot comfort you cannot put a price on.
-
NEO's insulated overshoe covers i haven't tried them but know people who swear by them.
-
i have used 1500 thinsulate rubber boots for 10 or so years. may very well be the best investment i evet made.
-
Military Surplus "Mickey Mouse" or "Bunny" boots. You can get them in any military surplus store or on line for less than $100.00 (sometimes far less). Open the airvalves on the side all the way open. I've been wearing them for nearly 40 years. I've found nothing else like them.
-
predator extremes or inferno boots at cabelas
-
my vote is for predator extremes. Wanted the baffins, but had a couple of gift cards and needed a road trip to cabelas in ct anyway. Tried on the infernos and some of the mucks, but didn't like the feel of the infernos. Looked at the sorels, but they arent made like that used to be. Besides the extremes were on sale for 129.97 instore only. With coupons and gift cards, cost me under a 90.00. will post a review after first trip out. Have the black mickeys, and thinkin about getting rid of them, just cant remember what size they are. Kept my feet fairly warm, but some of that was probaly due to heater in shanty. I believe the mickeys are size 12. i will check and post in a few.
-
I've been using the same pair of military surplus "bunny boots" for about 10 years. My feet are NEVER cold-and they're cheap compared to alot of other boots. They are a little heavy though...
-
predator extremes or inferno boots at cabelas
X2. Love my predator extremes.
-
The artic mucks are warm and dry
-
mickey mouse boots, there a little clumsy but you'll be warm... when I'm fishin in a shanty on warmer days, mucks work descent. my 2 cents...
-
Got those Alpaca socks for ya Shane, might be up tomm. ;)
-
cabelas infernos!
-
my money goes to baffin titan-100 they are all rubber with 8 layer inner liner that is removeable. have had a pair for four years and my feet never get cold.cost is about $100.00 but i got mine on sale at philipsons for $60.00.
-
rubber thinsulate, more mgs the merrier...
-
mickey mouse boots. ebay. thank me later.
-
I hunted and ice fished in a pair of Rocky Buckstalkers for 10 years with just a pair of heavy socks. Last year they finally ripped apart so I replaced them with the new rocky pair of rocky deerstalkers 1400 and again just a great boot one pair of smartwools and that's all you need. Last week I was introduced to a pair of Baffin Apex these have to be the best thing I have ever put my feet in just absolutely amazing. I haven't yet had the chance to use on the ice but from all I have seen wearing them around in the snow and cold they are a great buy. They go for 269.00 on baffin.com but I found them on Amazon for around 189.00.
Hope this helps.
-
It will help some, but not the hardheads who want to wear antique boots. If I won the powerball I would buy everyone on this site some boots from the future.
-
micky mouse/bunny boots rule!
-
Went in today with my 1000 gram field and stream rubber boots on today with smartwool socks after I wrung the water out of my socks and dumped the water out of my boot I fished all day np
-
Only prob ive ever had with neoprene or rubber boots is splitting due to lots of walking during ice season. On oneida some of the guys do a TON of walking and the rubber boots don't hold up too well.
-
mickey mouse boots. ebay. thank me later.
I was looking at this thread and knew I had to replace my red head insulated rubbers... they got some holes in them from hunting in thorns. Anyway just placed my order on eBay for black Mickey mouse boots, shipping included came to $54.77. I told my wife I don't plan to wear them in the woods, just on the ice....can't wait to try them
-
spend 40 bucks on mickeys i promise you you will never buy any other pair of boots again.
-
Once you go Mickey , you dont go back...
-
My last pair of Lacrosse boots tore open after the first season, so I stepped up my budget a bit and pulled the trigger the Cabellas inferno pac boots. This will be my 3rd season with them, so far my feet have never been cold.
http://www.cabelas.com/product/Fishing/Ice-Fishing/Ice-Clothing-Footwear|/pc/104793480/c/104735880/sc/110969280/Cabelas-Inferno8482-2000-Pac-Boots-150-Black/731369.uts?destination=%2Fcatalog%2Fbrowse%2Ffishing-ice-fishing-ice-clothing-footwear%2F_%2FN-1105958%2B4294769875%2FNe-4294769875%3FWTz_l%3DSBC%253BBRprd731369%26WTz_st%3DGuidedNav%26WTz_stype%3DGNU&WTz_l=SBC%3BBRprd731369%3Bcat110969280 (http://www.cabelas.com/product/Fishing/Ice-Fishing/Ice-Clothing-Footwear|/pc/104793480/c/104735880/sc/110969280/Cabelas-Inferno8482-2000-Pac-Boots-150-Black/731369.uts?destination=%2Fcatalog%2Fbrowse%2Ffishing-ice-fishing-ice-clothing-footwear%2F_%2FN-1105958%2B4294769875%2FNe-4294769875%3FWTz_l%3DSBC%253BBRprd731369%26WTz_st%3DGuidedNav%26WTz_stype%3DGNU&WTz_l=SBC%3BBRprd731369%3Bcat110969280)
-
I use muck arctics. knee high and warm.
-
Since I've been wearing my Arctic Pro muck boots my toes haven't been the least bit cold. I have poor circulation in my toes so my feet would feel the cold before anyone else did, no fun! I even have a pair of expensive thermacell heated liners that I have yet to turn on because my feet just haven't gotten cold. They're lightweight enough that I also use them deer hunting in the cold as well. Get them, you'll be glad you did! ;)
-
I use muck arctics. knee high and warm.
x 2 !
-
You just sold me on the Muck artics. Amazon here I come!
-
i think i got me a new pair of mucks to try out this year..so far they have been good..but we'll see how the hardwater treats em..
-
I have the artic sport muck boots, by far the warmest and dryest, git my sock wet putting them on. Put my boots on an they dried themselves out, best boot ever made
-
Thanks guys
-
get the feet warmers at dicks or walmart they last long and work great
-
For the average days I don't think you can go wrong with a pair of Sorels. They keep your feet dry and they are breathable. If you plan on going the next day the inserts come out and can be dried pretty quickly. For those nasty near zero days Cabela's Trans-Alaska Pac boot. They are the warmest boot I've ever put on my feet and the 3 inch sole keeps your feet off the ice.
-
another good pointer there ;) keep yr feet off the ice,make a world of difference in how cold they get. I have a piece of 2" think foam padding that's the length of my jet sled and around 12" wide, supper light wight and fists inside along the edge of my gear, that i place down along the edge of the sled after im all set up works good to keep my feet off the ice and also to place things on for those days that the water on top of the ice, also i can place hooks into the edge of it.
-
mickey mouse boots. when im in my shanty sometimes i wear my 800 redheads.
-
I like a boot with a rubber bottom and leather upper. They keep your feet dry and let them breath. My feet sweat a lot and in an all rubber boot my feet get wet and cold.
-
I just got sorrel glaciers and love them. Very warm
-
lacrosse ice kings best boots on the market
-
I had the same problem till I tried Muck boots with only one pair of socks. On real cold days toe Warner's work great.
-
hey try mickey mouse boots the military cant be wrong. search the net and found new ones for $69 + shipping wore these for years
-
Cabelas Trans Alaskas.
ave.wt 5.8lbs/pr
Almost too warm and dry. 6 or 7 years on mine this year.
RG
....and I saw them on sale at Cabela's site last week.
-
I just got a pair of Baffin Impact boot from gander mt. in Johntown PA ,mark down half price for $79.99 ,how great is that.................. ...
-
http://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/70645?feat=pac%20boots-SR0&page=l-l-bean-pac-boots&attrValue_0=Chocolate%20Brown&productId=1155216 (http://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/70645?feat=pac%20boots-SR0&page=l-l-bean-pac-boots&attrValue_0=Chocolate%20Brown&productId=1155216)
-
BTW I realize $240 is alot but being a smoker (poor circulation) and genetically lanky as hell.. i get extremely cold feet, easily. These are worth every penny.
-
I love my mucks.....feet have never been cold in them. Mickey Mouse boots work too but are bulky and overkill unless it is extremely cold out. IMHO. They do keep your feet warm but do not breathe either so you gotta keep dry socks on hand. do a lot of walking and your feet will sweat stand still all day and they'll be warm, though
-
cabelas polar cap pack boot they are great they are even on sale right now for 76.99 cant beat the price and quality you will never have cold feet again
-
I have bad circulation and always get cold feet first before most do.
Have you tried the Arctic Pro Mucks? The insulation is much more than their base model. Also make sure you're boots aren't fitting too tight because that will limit good circulation and breathe-ability which are both key to keeping feet warm.
Look into Thermacell foot warmers as well, pricy but nice.
Good luck.
-
Mickeys all day
-
I wear Northern or LaCrosse, dosent matter which. With a felt insole in the bottom and that keeps my feet warm all day long. But they only last me a year, but i do wear them every day. Also a good pair of wool socks helps.
-
i have had army mickey mouse boots in the past looking to buy another pair. the price is right and they are warm not great for walking sides of hills hunting but would be great on ice
-
i have had army mickey mouse boots in the past looking to buy another pair. the price is right and they are warm not great for walking sides of hills hunting but would be great on ice
Might try the antique store.
-
Tthank guys I will try
-
A lot of these boots seem to be very bulky. I'm constantly on the move and I'm just not a fan of walking five miles in clogs. Any suggestions for someone like me?
-
artic pro mucks for me also lite warm and comfortable
-
mickey mouse boots. when im in my shanty sometimes i wear my 800 redheads.
Its hard to beat a pair of surplus boots, especially price. Mine must be good to over 30 below easy. Drawback, 4 lbs each.
-
My feet get very cold in mickeys, I'm thinking of the trans Alaskan or the predators myself. My feet are almost always cold tho
-
My feet get very cold in mickeys, I'm thinking of the trans Alaskan or the predators myself. My feet are almost always cold tho
We must have the same kind of feet. Get the Baffin impacts.
-
I'm a Muck Boot fan. I love my Wetlands for spring through fall and they kept me out of jam on sloppy ice last week. That being said, I'm looking for a warmer pair for all around ice fishing. So should I be going with the Arctic Sport or the Arctic Pro? Thanks.
-
I tried a pair of black Mickey's, My feet were still cold.
-
I tried a pair of black Mickey's, My feet were still cold.
Hope everyone reads this!!!!!
-
These things rock, one pair of socks below zero, not moving much, no problems.
Check out Baffin Impacts. The 8 layer liners are like walking on air and they aren't to heavy at 3.5 lbs each (size 12). They run a size small.
http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm (http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm)
(http://img-1.gearbuyer.com/baffin-impact_snow_boot-mens_color_black_p1_.jpg)
The Lacrosse 2000 gram boots are rated to -80*f, the Baffin Impacts are rated to -148*f. I've never worn the heavy insulated rubber boots, but once I wore the Impacts I don't need to. I will end up with a pair of 1200 rubber boots for hunting and warm weather ice fishing. But when it's cold I'll be sporting my Impacts.
-
my lacrosse icekings keep you warm and dry nomatter the temps but I also have a pair of rubbers for sloppy warm days. Can't wear the rubbers when its cold my feet freeze in them
-
my lacrosse icekings keep you warm and dry nomatter the temps but I also have a pair of rubbers for sloppy warm days. Can't wear the rubbers when its cold my feet freeze in them
I agree. With rubber boots feet don't breathe good. Insulated pac boots with some space between your feet and the ice is the key. I mostly use kneehighs for hunting.
-
Mickey Mouse boots on ebay. Get the white ones there warmer. Best boots ever. dont need to go into the future for something that works awesome.
-
i just use lacross 1200 and my feet get chilled but i started to use styrofoam sheets under my boots and its alot better
-
Mickey Mouse boots on ebay. Get the white ones there warmer. Best boots ever. dont need to go into the future for something that works awesome.
I wish there was a top gear show on the coldest day of the year and solve this boot issue once and for all! Those outdated Mickey Mouse boots don't stand a chance against my future boots.
-
Mucks are where its at
-
Take a look at Irish Setter for Extreme Cold. IRISH SETTER SNOW CLAW XT. The Boots outstanding.
-
I'll be wearing my Lacrosse Ice Kings when I am out fishing in the 1 degree morning we will be having on Wednesday. My feet won't even know it's 1 degree out, they are down right toasty. I do have a pair of Lacrosse Alpha Burly's for those real wet days at the end of the season.
-
Check out Baffin Impacts. The 8 layer liners are like walking on air and they aren't to heavy at 3.5 lbs each (size 12). They run a size small.
http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm (http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000048.htm)
(http://img-1.gearbuyer.com/baffin-impact_snow_boot-mens_color_black_p1_.jpg)
The Lacrosse 2000 gram boots are rated to -80*f, the Baffin Impacts are rated to -148*f. I've never worn the heavy insulated rubber boots, but once I wore the Impacts I don't need to. I will end up with a pair of 1200 rubber boots for hunting and warm weather ice fishing. But when it's cold I'll be sporting my Impacts.
Buy Baffin, buy the best.
I've got a pair of Baffin Doug Stoup Polars. Same rating -148. Most comfortable, warmest boot I've ever owned.
Yeah, they're going to set you back a few bucks, but aren't your feet worth it?
http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000122.htm (http://www.baffin.com/product-p/40000122.htm)
-
And cats love them too!
(http://i248.photobucket.com/albums/gg161/michianiafisherman/IMG_2703.jpg)
-
Recently purchased my first pair of Muck Artic Sports -- tried a lot of boots over the years -- I am now hooked on the Mucks -- very warm, 100% waterproof and very comfortable to walk and stand in all day on the ice...!
-
I was looking at the Arctic muck boots, and there doesn't seem to be a lot of boot between your feet and the ice.
-
There is more material than you think -- whatever it is, it does the job -- we were out Sunday standing for 6 hours in that wind, along with the snow squalls -- feet never even began to get cold, or tired/sore from standing -- best price I found is on the sponsor Muck site above -- $129.95 with free shipping...!
-
I've had the same pair of Sorel boots for 20+ years, leather uppers, rubber soles, with the same insulated insert that came with them. Bought em at Dick Sports for about $59 at the time and they are still going strong. Course you can't buy them at that price anymore but the point is that Sorels last, period. I'm reading about these boots that are good to minus 80 degrees, well....I've ice fished when it was minus 8 degrees and not many are going to be out there at those temps so why waste your money on that kind of overkill?
-
BAFFINS!!!!!!!!!!!!! LIKE WALKING ON A CLOUD AND FEET NEVER GET COLD EVEN ON THE WORST BELOW ZERO DAYS
-
Cabelas trans alaskans. Its like you have warmers inside. Best boots I have used icefishing so far.
-
I wear 2000 gram rockys fishing and they are very warm for work I wear muck artic sports and think they would be plenty warm also
-
The article sport muck boots are warm as hell, only need a mid weight sock fir this boot
-
Hi all, just joined the site. I picked up a pair of military surplus mickey mouse boots on ebay a couple of years ago. If you don't mind some extra weight, they're hard to beat for around 30 bucks for a brand new pair. The black ones are rated to -20 degrees.
-
military mickey mouse boots www.sportsmansguide.co m best boots i ever used for ice fishing they are a little on the heavy side
-
Just got home from fishing with my friend who has the white mickeys. Fished from 6:30 am to 3:00 pm outside no shanty. His feet got cold and I got him to admit it. He did hang in there and would of stayed longer, or tough it out, but my baffins were good in the mild weather. Regular socks, no sweat or wet feet. Walked around in about three inches of slop from the melting snow but no leaks and my boots are not new. I know I will never convince someone who has used the mickeys their whole life to change now, but I hope to show fellow fisherman that there are better options for cold feet.
-
If you can find apair of white WWII mickey boots get them for what they cost theres nothing out there like them for sitting static on the ice Wouldnt want to go cross country hiking them heavy and your feet would get hot.
-
Just got home from fishing with my friend who has the white mickeys. Fished from 6:30 am to 3:00 pm outside no shanty. His feet got cold and I got him to admit it. He did hang in there and would of stayed longer, or tough it out, but my baffins were good in the mild weather. Regular socks, no sweat or wet feet. Walked around in about three inches of slop from the melting snow but no leaks and my boots are not new. I know I will never convince someone who has used the mickeys their whole life to change now, but I hope to show fellow fisherman that there are better options for cold feet.
180 dollars for baffins. or 30 dollars for mickeys. hmmmmmmmmm
-
You can't wear two or three pair of mickeys to keep your feet warm. There are days if I could of put more mickeys on the same foot I would have done it. Price is only what pain you are willing to put up with to save a little cash. Cash for what? A new pole? A new Vex? A new coat? Oh, how bout hundreds of jigs at a buck a piece? The baffins I use only cost 130 online. Size 14. I will say I would tell first timers who aren't very committed to the hobby and only go out a few times a year mickeys will work fine, but not if you go everyday and stay out extended periods of time. If a person simply doesn't have the money is one thing, but to have all the other ice fishing goodies, shanties power augers, etcetera, I don't buy the cost argument.
-
I own the same Baffins, Mickey's and Artic Mucks. in my opinion the Mickey's are the warmest but also very heavy and awkward. if I know I'm going to be fishing in a shanty or moving around a lot I wear the mucks. The mucks are light and warm. The Baffins are actually my third choice but a very god boot. I actually like the baffin APEX better, again just my opinion. This also from many years of working outside in the cold as well. Field and Stream did an article on Alaskan trappers a couple years ago and many of them stated that they wouldn't leave home without a pair of mickeys........
-
You can't wear two or three pair of mickeys to keep your feet warm. There are days if I could of put more mickeys on the same foot I would have done it. Price is only what pain you are willing to put up with to save a little cash. Cash for what? A new pole? A new Vex? A new coat? Oh, how bout hundreds of jigs at a buck a piece? The baffins I use only cost 130 online. Size 14. I will say I would tell first timers who aren't very committed to the hobby and only go out a few times a year mickeys will work fine, but not if you go everyday and stay out extended periods of time. If a person simply doesn't have the money is one thing, but to have all the other ice fishing goodies, shanties power augers, etcetera, I don't buy the cost argument.
over the last 10 years i have spent many hours on the ice in my white mickeys. I have been out all night and all day in -10 and still NEVER had cold feet. If i did i would gladly spend more on different boots. I have all the ice goodies you speak of. I just don't see spending five times the price on boots if mickeys will do the job. Im sure the baffins are warm but I can guarantee you baffins won't take the abuse i put them through. Just look at all the alaska shows they all have mickeys on.
-
Out all day and night, I would say in a shanty? I also forgot to mention the fact I wear cheap socks in my Baffins. Add that to the cost of the mickeys. Need at least two pair of twenty to thirty dollar socks to keep fishing.
It depends on how you use your boots as to how they perform. They work for some but the posts don't say they had their feet up against the wood stove or over a lantern. I am telling you guys I have used both, outside, no shanty and inside with a shanty. I will admit the mickeys will get you there and back, but there is better without the fuss.
-
Everyones feet are different. What works for one person, may not work for the next. I've had cold sweaty feet all my life, then I went through a nasty round of chemo that really messed up my nerves in my feet and hands. Now I have to wear socks to bed at night to keep them warm.
My next pair will have to have to be roomy enough for a handwarmer in the toe area. Im thinking about the Cabelas Trans alaska or predator boots. I hear good things about them and they are on sale right now.
Opinions?
-
I switch to Muck Arctic Pros about 4 years ago. Great boot and well worth the investment. I use them for everything from snow blowing to ice fishing to playing outside with the kids. If anything, my feet get a little to hot if I'm up and moving around a lot. I've had multiple pairs of Lacrosse Burly Air Grips over the past 20 years and they worked well, but there is a no comparison between them and the Muck Boots. The Muck Boots are light, comfortable, and do a much better job keeping your feet warm.
-
thanks ill try them ;D
-
I use Kamik. They have an arctic model which has kept my feet dry and warm. I use them as well in my deer stand and never had a problem. There are no laces to fumble with. Slip on and slip off. My yak-trax also fit nicely around them as well. i have a cabelas pak boot inferno but they are too stiff to be running around chasing flags...great for the woods not the lake.
-
I used to wear mickys, never got cold feet but they are very heavy and clumsily large. Not to mention if your sock ever slips down they will wear a hole in your leg very fast. I have Baffin Impacts now and would recommend them highly. Not only are they lighter and warmer, they are much more comfortable and that makes a big difference too.
-
I purchased my first pair of Muck Arctic Pros this year -- been very pleased with them -- fully waterproof, very warm, good support for standing all day and very lightweight -- important if you want to be mobile and do alot of moving around -- no problem running for tip-ups in these boots! Best price I found was using the Muck link above on Ice Shanty.com -- as you go through the check-out process -- click on online price comparison -- came back with $129.95 with free shipping...!!
-
I know this helped me out hopefully its helping everyone else!!
-
I tried mickeys again today because I knew it was going to be wet and sloppy. Again my feet were cold. I guess for some they work, and some they don't. For the little money I spent on them, I had to give them a try. I've wasted $40 on a lot less
I might try the arctic pros next.
-
I tried mickeys again today because I knew it was going to be wet and sloppy. Again my feet were cold. I guess for some they work, and some they don't. For the little money I spent on them, I had to give them a try. I've wasted $40 on a lot less
I might try the arctic pros next.
Do the Baffin Impacts one size over your regular and don't look back. Let your enemies borrow your Mickeys.
-
I recomend the lacrosse 2000 gram boots a wee bit pricey but you wont regret it one bit!
-
Muck Arctic Sport. I've got a pair, but when I bought mine I took a heavy pair of socks with me to try them on so I would be sure to get the proper size, and I love them. When it gets really cold I put a pair of the adhesive backed foot warmers on my socks before putting my boots on. I also never put my boots on until I'm leaving the truck to fish, I have an old stretched out pair of boat shoes that I wear until ready to leave the truck. I bought mine at a local feed store last spring on a close out, they were under $100.
-
Good price.
-
I read this entire thread and did a bunch of reading and here’s what I found out.
The most popular boots are
1. Muck Boots
2. Mickey Mouse Boots
3. Lacrosse Burleys
4. Baffin Impacts
5. Cabelas Trans Alaskans
6. Baffin Impact
7. Sorels (I picked the “Glaciers” as being at the top of the line)
Here are the specs.
Muck Boots:
Arctic Pro
Professional Extreme-Conditions Sport Boot
All the standard MUCK BOOT™ features plus:
• Fleece lining
• Stretch-fit topline binding snugs leg to keep warmth in and cold out
• 8mm CR flex-foam bootie with four-way stretch nylon, 100% waterproof, lightweight and flexible
• Bob-tracker molded outsole is rugged, aggressive and durable for maximum protection and stability
• Double reinforcements on the instep, heel and achilles areas
• 2mm thermal foam underlay added to the instep area for additional warmth
• EVA molded midsole with contoured footbed
• Reinforced toe
• Added toe protection with a wrap-up bumper
• Comfort range of -60° F to 40°F
Mickey Mouse Boots:
World-renowned "Mickey Boots" are 100% rubber with thick wool insulation all around.Add in an insulating air pocket, all sandwiched between the layers of rubber.
Presto! Warmth rated to -20°F! Rugged nylon laces go through the second eyelet twice to lock your foot in place. Gusseted tongue, heel wedge accepts ski or snowshoe bindings.
The interior is nylon lined for easy on / off. High-traction soles and heels, and double-thick rubber in all wear areas. Built-in altitude air valve pressurizes the Boot when our troops are airborne. It's a handy feature... if you parachute in to watch penguins. Each approx. 11 1/2"h., 53 ozs. Condition: brand new, army surplus, never issued.
LaCrosse® 18" Burly® Rubber Boots
The 100% waterproof, ozone-resistant rubber construction is proven to be reliable in demanding environments. Nylon-net lining with AgION™ antimicrobial protection. Removable EVA footbed. Fiberglass shank. Contoured ankle-fit design. Cam-Loc™ buckle adjustment accommodates all calf sizes and keeps moisture out. Polymeric Foam Insulation. Air-grip outsole. Imported.
Height: 18".
Average weight: 5.3 lbs./pair.
Cabela's Trans-Alaska™ III Pac Boot
From the Iditarod trail to the treestand, these boots have proven they are true cold-weather performers. A 13mm Texel® removable liner reflects heat inward to minimize loss. Beneath that, the Moisture Trap footbed wicks away perspiration and condensation. A 1/2" layer of EVA foam, coupled with the nylon-covered Phylon midsole, puts 3" of cold-blocking material between your feet and the ground. The tough, flexible vamps are protected by a triple-layer, abrasion-resistant toe guard, and the rubber toe cap ensures longer wear. These boots have a reflective, lightweight waterproof shell with lightweight, reflective nylon shafts. Radiantex™ reflective coating. The 8" liner allows for pants inside the boots, and the rip-stop nylon gaiter has a cord-locked drawcord to keep out snow. They're easy to tighten, thanks to a one-pull ball bearing lacing system. Inside, a heat pack pocket allows you to insert toe warmer heat packs.
Height: 15".
Average weight: 5.8 lbs./pair.
Baffin Impact:
RATING -100°C/-148°F
BASE Integrated Arctic Flex rubber base
INSOLE Waffle sole and reflective “air bubble” underfoot
OUTSOLE Premium polar rubber
LINER 8-layer inner boot system with Thermaplush
UPPERS Timberwolf leather and Diamond-Lite insulated nylon
Sorel Glacier:
This durable, weather-defying boot is perfect for keeping feet warm, dry and protected in deep snow and extreme cold; in addition to a waterproof rubber shell, it features a water and wind resistant upper, built-in gaiter and removable 13mm ThermoPlus™ felt inner boot.
Construction:
Durable water and wind resistant PU backed synthetic textile upper
Built-in gaiter with barrel lock closure system
Removable 13mm ThermoPlus™ felt InnerBoot
25mm bonded felt frost plug
Removable 13mm Sorel Meltdown Midsole™
Handcrafted waterproof vulcanized rubber shell
Sorel AeroTrac™ non-loading outsole
Shaft Height: 16 in / 40.6 cm
Weight: 42 oz / 1191 g
Sorel rated: -100° fahrenheit / -73° celsius
Imported
Fabric:
UPPER
PU backed synthetic textile
LINING
13mm Thermoplus felt
MIDSOLE
13mm Sorel Meltdown Midsole
SHELL
Vulcanized rubber
OUTSOLE
Sorel AeroTrac
Conclusions:
An ice fishing boot should be completely waterproof, warm, and comfortable. Not all of these boots are completely waterproof and of those that are completely waterproof, due to design flaws, they will not stay waterproof. Of those that are completely waterproof, not all of them are comfortable.
From looking at all the specs. and reading the reviews it comes down to the Muck and Baffin Boots. The Baffin Boots appear to be more comfortable, however the Muck Boots appear to be the more durable.
-
I read this entire thread and did a bunch of reading and here’s what I found out.
The most popular boots are
1. Muck Boots
2. Mickey Mouse Boots
3. Lacrosse Burleys
4. Baffin Impacts
5. Cabelas Trans Alaskans
6. Baffin Impact
7. Sorels
Conclusions:
An ice fishing boot should be completely waterproof, warm, and comfortable. ;D Not all of these boots are completely waterproof and of those that are completely waterproof, due to design flaws, they will not stay waterproof. Of those that are completely waterproof, not all of them are comfortable.
From looking at all the specs. and reading the reviews it comes down to the Muck and Baffin Boots. The Baffin Boots appear to be more comfortable, however the Muck Boots appear to be the more durable.
Read all the reviews you want!
Now go out and buy and wear out each of those boots on your feet...like some of us have.
Then you will realize there was one, that was perfect for your foot.
Your foot, is different than MY foot.
My foot is perfect for the Trans Alaskans. ;)
-
I picked up the Muck Arctic Pro and like the convince of the slip on, but still wonder how warm they will be when it gets cold again.
I got a good deal locally and figured what the heck.
My toes were cool even though it was only mid 20's that morning. I re-read the tags on the boots, and realized that they read for ACTIVE warmth. I guess they won't be too good for late season deer hunting in the stand. For walking and moving they'll be warm.
Ill keep them for a back up pair, but not my main wears.
-
Read all the reviews you want!
Now go out and buy and wear out each of those boots on your feet...like some of us have.
Then you will realize there was one, that was perfect for your foot.
Your foot, is different than MY foot.
My foot is perfect for the Trans Alaskans. ;)
I posted this for myself and others to compare specifications.
Since I can't possibly buy and wear every type of boot listed above, I can only rely on research and opinions.
Remember, that all of the above boots, and some not listed, are first rate boots.
Most of the people that posted here listed only the positive aspects of their boots.
I am hoping to get feedback from the same people as to how long their boots stayed waterproof, how long they lasted, and how they performed. Just like the post directly above this one.
Apropos of that, I bought the Sorel Alpha Pac boots three years ago. They were waterproof for two years, then due to poor design, they are no longer. Don't buy them.
-
I also tried the black Mickeys. Not good for me.
My toes were cold on warmish days. They are big and clunky as well.
They don't come up too far, and my pants ended up getting wet from snow and slush.
Not too comfortable either (for me). Glad I didn't pay allot for them. If anyone local wants a set real cheap, PM me for the size and we can set something up.
-
Read all the reviews you want!
Now go out and buy and wear out each of those boots on your feet...like some of us have.
Then you will realize there was one, that was perfect for your foot.
Your foot, is different than MY foot.
My foot is perfect for the Trans Alaskans. ;)
By the way, how long have you had the Trans Alaskans and are they still waterproof?
And I just noticed that the Baffin Impact specs. don't say that they're waterproof. Anybody know if they are and how long they stay that way?
-
+1 on trans alaskans. Warmest boots I have ever wore. Cabelas has lifetime warranty also.
-
+1 on trans alaskans. Warmest boots I have ever wore. Cabelas has lifetime warranty also.
How long have you had them and are they still waterproof?
-
One season and yes still waterproof. Lifetime warranty.
-
One season and yes still waterproof. Lifetime warranty.
They look like a great boot. A lifetime warranty is all good, but like my old mechanic used to say, "Sure, Craftsman tools have a lifetime warranty, but I can't be bothered with taking back. I buy tools that are going to last."
-
Personal opinion. I like craftsman. And cabelas is awesome with returns. Good luck with whatever you try.
-
My next set will be the preditor extremes or the trans alaska's.
I also like craftsman tools.
-
What a thread !
WS
-
By the way, how long have you had the Trans Alaskans and are they still waterproof?
On my second pair...First pair I wore three seasons, they were still waterproof, EXCEPT...I wore a hole on top of the boot in the laces from constant rubbing in the snowmobile stirup... My fault.
On my second pair now for two seasons... @) Still waterproof. I still wear the first pair if it is not slushy or, if I am taking the machine. no sense in ruining another pair the same way. ;)
I loved the Alpha Burlys...my ankles didn't...I have scars from walking too many miles in them, and one beaver chew will rip a hole so fast in them ... :'(
Mickeys were never comfortable for me. Warm, yes, waterproof? Only as high as they are.
Mucks were waterproof and warm..NOT comfortable. I gave mine to a guy I didn't like. He loves them! >:D
Baffins did alright for me...kept me warm, dry as toast,(can't remember deep slushing in them though..) wrong design for my foot to be comfortable , again... My son is wearing them now that he grew into them!
Sorels were not tall enough to wade through the local slush, and BOTTOM of my feet got cold in them....We stand on ice all day...you need insulation UNDER your foot, like the Trans Alaskans HAVE. ;) ;D Most boots will keep you warm to and from a shanty with a floor... ::)
If you use your boots, you are going to have to replace them....Not happy with the last pair you wore out...try a different kind! Then you find the one that works best for your foot, and your style of use.
I refuse to hike without a broken in pair of Asolo 520 GTX's......If they still made Longitudes, I would be wearing them. If I knew they were going to stop making Longitudes...I would have bought 20 pair and stashed them!
Other hikers have their favs as well...
It all depends on YOUR FOOT....your foot is different shape and arch then the next guys...Not every "good" boot is good for everybody. You need to find what is good for you.
-
On my second pair...First pair I wore three seasons, they were still waterproof, EXCEPT...I wore a hole on top of the boot in the laces from constant rubbing in the snowmobile stirup... My fault.
On my second pair now for two seasons... @) Still waterproof. I still wear the first pair if it is not slushy or, if I am taking the machine. no sense in ruining another pair the same way. ;)
I loved the Alpha Burlys...my ankles didn't...I have scars from walking too many miles in them, and one beaver chew will rip a hole so fast in them ... :'(
Mickeys were never comfortable for me. Warm, yes, waterproof? Only as high as they are.
Mucks were waterproof and warm..NOT comfortable. I gave mine to a guy I didn't like. He loves them! >:D
Baffins did alright for me...kept me warm, dry as toast,(can't remember deep slushing in them though..) wrong design for my foot to be comfortable , again... My son is wearing them now that he grew into them!
Sorels were not tall enough to wade through the local slush, and BOTTOM of my feet got cold in them....We stand on ice all day...you need insulation UNDER your foot, like the Trans Alaskans HAVE. ;) ;D Most boots will keep you warm to and from a shanty with a floor... ::)
If you use your boots, you are going to have to replace them....Not happy with the last pair you wore out...try a different kind! Then you find the one that works best for your foot, and your style of use.
I refuse to hike without a broken in pair of Asolo 520 GTX's......If they still made Longitudes, I would be wearing them. If I knew they were going to stop making Longitudes...I would have bought 20 pair and stashed them!
Other hikers have their favs as well...
It all depends on YOUR FOOT....your foot is different shape and arch then the next guys...Not every "good" boot is good for everybody. You need to find what is good for you.
Now that's what I call research and analysis. Those are the sort of reviews that we need.
Barring the fact that everybody's feet are different, a "good" boot should be long lasting, in addition to comfortable, warm, and waterproof.
When I read about a guy that says he's worn the same boots for 30 years (5 or 10 should be enough), I want to know what kind of boots he's wearing, and what he's using them for.
-
Now that's what I call research and analysis. Those are the sort of reviews that we need.
Barring the fact that everybody's feet are different, a "good" boot should be long lasting, in addition to comfortable, warm, and waterproof.
When I read about a guy that says he's worn the same boots for 30 years (5 or 10 should be enough), I want to know what kind of boots he's wearing, and what he's using them for.
He must watch a ton of television and spend all his fishing time on the internet..... :P
;D
The Sorels I owned were NOT 15 inches tall either.... ::) I thought I still had them buried in a closet here somewhere, I just went and looked for them so I could measure them....the wife must have throw them out.
-
He must watch a ton of television and spend all his fishing time on the internet..... :P
;D
The Sorels I owned were NOT 15 inches tall either.... ::) I thought I still had them buried in a closet here somewhere, I just went and looked for them so I could measure them....the wife must have throw them out.
Back in the day, all the boots were Pac boots with leather uppers. Mink oil or bee's wax them and you were good to go. And they lasted a long, long time.
-
I like my $30.00 Baffin with felt liner. Fit good and keep "my" feet warm and dry.
You guys from NY kill me with all the talk about - 40, -60, -100 boots.
-
x2 on the Trans Alaskens, Going on 5 yrs now and still warm and dry.
-
I like my $30.00 Baffin with felt liner. Fit good and keep "my" feet warm and dry.
You guys from NY kill me with all the talk about - 40, -60, -100 boots.
How long have you had the Baffin's and are they still waterproof?
-
I wear the Baffins for ice fishing, hunting, quading and walking the dog. I wear out a pair about every 2 years. Usually I get a cut in the side or across the top of the toe, then they are tossed out. They are worn about every day from Oct. thru to April.
-
I don't understand why guys seam to wear out boots faster than others? Perhaps we should make boot users show pictures of there work shoes and see if its things like walking on the sides of their feet. If it is something like the side of the tennis shoe is broken? Might be not so much a difference in feet as much the way each of us walk on our own two feet. The way we may drag or not pick up our feet when we walk. Or while standing, to let our feet roll to the side. The amount of weight may make the biggest problem with pack boots. Smashing the liner and not to mention the ankle support not built into this type of boot. So what I am saying for everyone, is that reading all this boot chit chat is hard to figure, but more than feet are not the same.
-
I don't understand why guys seam to wear out boots faster than others? Perhaps we should make boot users show pictures of there work shoes and see if its things like walking on the sides of their feet. If it is something like the side of the tennis shoe is broken? Might be not so much a difference in feet as much the way each of us walk on our own two feet. The way we may drag or not pick up our feet when we walk. Or while standing, to let our feet roll to the side. The amount of weight may make the biggest problem with pack boots. Smashing the liner and not to mention the ankle support not built into this type of boot. So what I am saying for everyone, is that reading all this boot chit chat is hard to figure, but more than feet are not the same.
Barring an accident, such as a cut in the boot from an auger or a beaver chewing on it, wear-out will occur due to the amount of use, the type of foot, or poor design.
What we need on this thread is to weed out poorly designed boots, and find well designed boots.
If you've had boots that wore out ahead of their time due to poor design, lets hear about it.
If your boots are holding up due to good design (i.e., stayed waterproof, and the seams and material kept their integrity) lets hear about it.
The Sorels Alpha Tracs are poorly designed, and destined to fail.
-
If you wear a boot every day, it's going to wear out faster then if you only wear it on the weekends when you hunt or fish. I wear work boots everyday for work, and the soles are shot in a years time. My fishing/hunting boots are 20+ years old, and are just getting around to needing to be replaced.
-
If you wear a boot every day, it's going to wear out faster then if you only wear it on the weekends when you hunt or fish. I wear work boots everyday for work, and the soles are shot in a years time. My fishing/hunting boots are 20+ years old, and are just getting around to needing to be replaced.
;) You are correct. I fish just about every day... ;D
Two seasons of ice fishing for me, is equivalent to 20 seasons for some guys . @)
In the summer I go through two pair of Perry Docksiders every charter season...12-14 hours a day being wet, they don't last as long as the ones worn by weekend warriors sitting at the dock.
-
Stay focused. Which ice fishing boots stay waterproof, are warm, comfortable, and long lasting?
-
Stay focused. Which ice fishing boots stay waterproof, are warm, comfortable, and long lasting?
These ones? ::)
1. Muck Boots
2. Mickey Mouse Boots
3. Lacrosse Burleys
4. Baffin Impacts
5. Cabelas Trans Alaskans
6. Baffin Impact
7. Sorels (I picked the “Glaciers” as being at the top of the line)
-
Here is my extra .02 cents I am 6' 345lbs and wear a size 14 eeee I buy boots that fit before any type of loyalty. That being said most boots last maybe a season hunting and icefishing . I destroy boots!!! Tried on a pair of the boots with the "extra " give to put on knelt down and the calf seam just separated! I have had this pair of Muck Boot Woody Max for two seasons and have NEVER had a lighter warmer more supportive and comfortable boot ever hands down! 180 $ made me balk for "pack" boots but well worth it. I have worked in Lacrosse side buckles, lace ups and many commercial boots and shoes always 6 months max Red wings wolverines etc . These particular boots are Just too hot for early bow season and summer.
-
If you wear a boot every day, it's going to wear out faster then if you only wear it on the weekends when you hunt or fish. I wear work boots everyday for work, and the soles are shot in a years time. My fishing/hunting boots are 20+ years old, and are just getting around to needing to be replaced.
I have work boots over three years old. I use Danner workman. I am in a factory and walk from end to end of the 50,000 square foot. Over, under, you name it, my boots get used. I am six foot 200 lbs and I walk correctly. I know this because I check the bottoms of my shoes for wear. Something my dad would kick me in the hind end if I walked funny in front of him when I was a kid. Thanks dad!
-
...Tried on a pair of the boots with the "extra " give to put on knelt down and the calf seam just separated!
Which boots were those?
-
These ones? ::)
1. Muck Boots
2. Mickey Mouse Boots
3. Lacrosse Burleys
4. Baffin Impacts
5. Cabelas Trans Alaskans
6. Baffin Impact
7. Sorels (I picked the “Glaciers” as being at the top of the line)
And if you've worn all of the above, or some of them, which ones are the longest lasting, while staying waterproof in your opinion?
-
I have work boots over three years old. I use Danner workman. I am in a factory and walk from end to end of the 50,000 square foot. Over, under, you name it, my boots get used. I am six foot 200 lbs and I walk correctly. I know this because I check the bottoms of my shoes for wear. Something my dad would kick me in the hind end if I walked funny in front of him when I was a kid. Thanks dad!
I need a pair of work boots and I'm going to remember that. Dad's have strange ways, I know, I am one.
-
Ill check out Danners next time, but I walk in concrete/blacktop/stone allot and it wears soles really down quickly.
Thanks
-
I , for one would not wear a set of sorrels. I had a pair many years ago and my feet were always cold. Right now I have a set of the white bunny boots. I think I paid $60 for them and they have been good to me. I did buy a pair of ice cleats to put on the bottom for early ice and that helped tremendously
-
And if you've worn all of the above, or some of them, which ones are the longest lasting, while staying waterproof in your opinion?
Cabelas Trans Alaskans...
-
The best.
-
I had a pair of low end Sorrels for 18 yrs and finally wore out the sole. The last 2 years I have bought a pair of Kamiks and Sorrels and have pierced the rubber toes on one pair and cut the toe on the other. I did not notice when I did the damage on either pair. The rubber on my old Sorrels was much thicker and damage resistant.
What boots have a tough toe. I was thinking the Infernos..
Any thoughts?
-
Does anyone have experience with the Cabela's Polar Cap boots?
http://www.cabelas.com/catalog/product.jsp?productId=749361&destination=%2Fcatalog%2Fproduct.jsp%3FproductId%3D1217229%26type%3Dproduct%26Ntk%3DAllProducts%26searchPath%3D%252Fcatalog%252Fsearch.cmd%253Fform_state%253DsearchForm%2526N%253D0%2526fsch%253Dtrue%2526Ntk%253DAllProducts%2526Ntt%253Dpreadator%252Bboots%2526x%253D-806%2526y%253D-51%2526WTz_l%253DHeader%25253BSearch-All%252BProducts%26Ntt%3Dpreadator%2Bboots%26WTz_l%3DHeader%253BSearch-All%2BProducts&WTz_l=YMAL%3BIK-813749
-
mickeys black or white last me the longest with being waterproof and no liner to wear out.ive had them over 6 years so far. my lacrosse ice kings cracked after 2 years. my ithasca boots have lasted but the liners are junk along with not being very waterproof.after my next pair of mickeys I might try some mucks.
-
Does anyone have experience with the Cabela's Polar Cap boots?
http://www.cabelas.com/catalog/product.jsp?productId=749361&destination=%2Fcatalog%2Fproduct.jsp%3FproductId%3D1217229%26type%3Dproduct%26Ntk%3DAllProducts%26searchPath%3D%252Fcatalog%252Fsearch.cmd%253Fform_state%253DsearchForm%2526N%253D0%2526fsch%253Dtrue%2526Ntk%253DAllProducts%2526Ntt%253Dpreadator%252Bboots%2526x%253D-806%2526y%253D-51%2526WTz_l%253DHeader%25253BSearch-All%252BProducts%26Ntt%3Dpreadator%2Bboots%26WTz_l%3DHeader%253BSearch-All%2BProducts&WTz_l=YMAL%3BIK-813749
I haven't tried the boots in question. It has been pointed out on another thread that Cabela's is not good with boot returns.
-
I think this is going to be a purchase I do not make on line....at least not until I try some on in person
Thanks for all your research
-
The guarantee on the boots is not an online shopping issue. The Cabela's guarantee is for the lifetime of the product. Cabela's determines how long that lifetime will be. In the post entitled "Don't buy Cabela's", the gentleman returned his $80 boots to Cabela's within 2 years (?) due to stitching coming loose. They offered him $40 for them, he spoke up and they offered $60 in gift certificate. That's a poor "lifetime" guarantee.
We don't expect boots to last a lifetime, but we don't accept their falling apart within two years unless we wear and beat them so much that they fall apart.
-
That is good to know.
Thanks
-
I am wearing either Kamik Ultralight Pack boots (same as Oslo) and Baffin Titan's.
Both are rated to -100F.
With lots of water on the ice I wear the Titans, lots of walking I wear the Kamiks.
Both are very warm in all conditions I have encountered.
Burt :)
-
I have read all the threads and am surprised there has been no mention of Steger Mukluks. I have had a pair for 25 years and love them. Light as your bedroom slippers and warm. I discovered them when I ran sled dogs 25-30 years ago. They are made by Will Steger's wife Patti. Will went to the north pole by dog team back in the day, so they should know a thing or two about warm boots.
-
Baffin titans...not pretty, little bulky, but dry andWARM...guaranteed !!! I have the coldest feet in the world and these are the only ones that worked for me. You can get them for under 100$
-
read all the reviews .... I've had mickey's for years, uncomfortable as hell. I've worn sorels for years now, but they are not waterproof when standing in 6-8" of water and slush, and my feet on occasion have been cold.... this year I bought an Eskimo 949i, but I am in the market for knew boots also.
Today I went to the local Sam's to try on and compare the Mucks/AlphaBurley's ...
-The Muck's don't appear to be very rugged but were very comfortable, and I worry about the neoprene where it meets the rubber that it's waiting to blow apart.
-The AlphaBurley's went on much easier and felt good but the width wasn't enough which hurt the side of feet while walking around the store...unfortunately the store didn't have the next size larger .....
I still have yet to decide, but i'm leaning towards the lacrosse.
-
The nice thing about PACs is your feet will breath better. Rubber boots don't breath good and your feet stay wet when you sweat.
-
bought the muck arctic pros this year and wear them every day for work and am going to wear them fishing plenty warm and comfortable actually little to warm for work
-
mickeys black or white last me the longest with being waterproof and no liner to wear out.ive had them over 6 years so far. my lacrosse ice kings cracked after 2 years. my ithasca boots have lasted but the liners are junk along with not being very waterproof.after my next pair of mickeys I might try some mucks.
I have had my black mickies for 22 years (what'd he say?). They weigh a ton, but are warm and I can stand in slush all day long. With the ATV, I never walk much so the weight isn't so important standing around catching fish. I bought them for $40, a bargain for the years of use.
If they get wet in side at the end of the day, put dry rice or dry wheat in over night. Works like a champ.
-
DON'T BUY COLUMBIA BOOTS!
Whatever your boot decision, never purchase boots by COLUMBIA. I purchased a pair of Columbia Bugabootoo's a couple of years back. They failed shortly after my purchase where the rubber separated from the leather uppers. I sent them back for Warranty repair and/or replacement. They sent them back stating in a few words: "Tough Luck".,. no warrany authorized.
They didn attempt to make it right or an alternative solution... Discount coupon on another pair, etc.
Since then, I havent purchased one darn thing that has the Columbia Logo.
I DON'T RECOMMEND COLUMBIA PRODUCTS AT ALL., ESPECIALLY THEIR FOOTWEAR.
-
Cabelas trans Alaskans are the warmest ones to date for me. And your feed won't feel wet like with rubber knee high boots.
-
look, i'v worn pac boots and mickey's they are good IF..you don't plan on moving alot and they are heavy if you got alot of snow, as far as someone saying they breath better than rubbers i don't think so...,if you have cotton socks you are gonna sweat and get cold. You gotta have a good sock, one that doesn't hold your sweat(a wool blend or under armour type) As far as comfort and warmth goes, and you can use them for deer hunting too, Rubber insulated is the way to go.
-
perhaps this thread is too old ::) i will see if i get any members to join a new thread.
just read the entire post. Still not sure which way to go. Baffin titans, too warm, feet sweat, cold toes. Muck arctic pro , less sweating, still cold toes. Uhg
-
i read this from the beginning,, i had to temp seal my old conquest sorels finally started leaking last seasons slush .. i like them still only 400grams thinsulate but i use hand warmers ..i'.m a 10.5 and 11.5 fit perfect ..enough room to move my toes with a good blend wool sock cushion wicking high tec sock i guess ..cabelas got them for 16.00 ,, any way aquasealed where the rubber meets the leather last season..this weekend ,,i had brand new cabela trans alaskan size 11 boots i thought i was going to use but out of the box they felt so tight , i said no way and put them back in the truck..luckily i brought along my old pair of sorel conquests on this outing too. Sorels seem okay for now..aquaseal is amazing sealant for emergencies like waders rubber boots,so far to date still waterproof and feels like a durable bond. I called Cabelas and they said they will honor return with no chanrge for return shipping. I was looking at the inferno 2000 on sale 127.00 but afraid to order size 11 knowing the transalaskans 11 was so tight.. I do not think i want to risk ordering size 12 knowing my foot size is 10.5 .. ??? i guess i will call Cabelas and find out what they may offer.. i know shoebuy and zappos has pac boots with free both way shipping policy. I guess it is how you tell them.. exchanges they usually charge unless the product is defective or made defective(including sizes no true to fit)
the trans alskans are great only wear mine when its below 0 alot of boot to lug around(heavy)
-
I have the trans Alaskans in size 12. My not size is 10.5 and 11's were to tight. The 12s fit great with one set of nice socks. Its hard to find creepers that will fit so I put hex head screws in the bottom and they work awesome.
-
Baffin titans are the best ice fishing boot period, I have arctic mucks, acton adventurers, sorel pack boots, and the titans stand out, super comfort all day, easy drying even if you don't have a boot dryer, easy on and off, real rubber, only con is they are huge in the calf area so your pants my not fit over them, I have striker bibs, they fit over, buddy has AA they also fit over
-
What gram insulation do you guys have in your boot?
I have 800 gram, which are plenty for me just got to wear the right socks so your feet don't sweat.
-
#1 for me cabelas trans Alaskans. Little bulky but not too heavy. Best boot I have tried to date. Feet used to get cold not anymore.
-
And with rubber feet sweat and doesn't evaporate.
-
yes but if that is what you got and you want to insure warm toes, just toss a handwarmer in before you go out..also wear only one quality long pair of merino blend pac boot socks..they are designed to help with sweaty feet but, the warmers should suffice all day no matter. I would of coarse go with a felt boot slip on with rubber during really slush conditions .. my Baffin hunters are rated minus 70 but are totally water proof.. I would toss in hand warmers if I planned standing in ice slush all day.
Cabelas trans Alaskans don't need any hand warmer hey are that warm. They have 3" between your feet and the ice. This help a lot. Never used the Baffin's. All I know is knee highs for me don't cut it ice fishing, hand warmer or not. Plus who wants to use a footwarmers evertime you fish?
-
after a really bad experience with a higher dollar pair of pac boots only lasting me half of a season if that(rubber shredded and cracked all over), and customer service telling me it was my fault, i kept putting shoe goo on them until i decided what boots i was going to order next. i did the shoe goo for about a month and it only lasted a few outings on the ice before leaking again.
i was walking through walmart to get more goo when i happened to see some clearance boots for 30 bux that i figured would get me through the rest of the season and retire the pac boots hassle. well that was 2009 or 10 and i am still wearing those 30 dollar boots and they are warm and holding up good still. i will wear them until they fall apart and then i will get some baffin titans. when i got them i had googled them and found that they were actually exactly same as some other higher dollar brand boot, but i can no longer remember what brand it was. they have herman survivors 1000g thinsulate and i think are rated to -40 or so. i even wear them in spring and fall walking in water fishing and they have never leaked at all. it is not very often you get a good pair of shoes or boots from walmart, but these seem to be the odd ball that will last. i will say that the tags on them are all wacky though, mine say 12 on them on some parts and 11 on others and 1 spot says 13. i usually wear a 12 or 13 depending on brand. i saw the odd tags when i bought them and made sure they were same length and fit right before i actually paid for them. they fit perfect , but i really don't have a clue which of the size tags were right, but again they fit perfect so i didnt care. i went back to get a second pair the next day, but they sold out. they were all the same size that they had left so figured a spare pair couldnt hurt at that price. this is a link to the boots i just found online for reference.
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Mens-1000g-Thinsulate-Hunting-Fishing-Camo-Wellies-Snow-Rain-Wellington-Boots-/261321869588
-
I have the muck muckmaster ,its comfortable but it is hard to get pants over.if I am standing in the snow for 15 min I feel the cold I would say they are comparable to sneakers.they are rated for -20 which is a absolute joke.i do not have the slightly heavier ones rated for -60 .after over 10 years of leak free warm feet performance my cabelas pack boat,i think the predator,have developed cankles and need replaced.not sure if I will go cabelas again or try the lacrosse ice kings.i cant imagine buying boots that I had to put handwarmers in
-
I have the muck muckmaster ,its comfortable but it is hard to get pants over.if I am standing in the snow for 15 min I feel the cold I would say they are comparable to sneakers.they are rated for -20 which is a absolute joke.i do not have the slightly heavier ones rated for -60 .after over 10 years of leak free warm feet performance my cabelas pack boat,i think the predator,have developed cankles and need replaced.not sure if I will go cabelas again or try the lacrosse ice kings.i cant imagine buying boots that I had to put handwarmers in
Do you put your pants outside your boots? I tuck pants inside boot, then zip striker bibs over the outside of everything!
-
I bought them to run around when snow is on the ground.i could never were them ice fishing.last time we had a 2 hr drive so I wore them to drive and my feet were freezing.now these are not the arctic pros but they are not warm at all.
-
I have the Arctic Pros and was out on the ice all day Saturday. They never got cold but they did sweat a little on the walk out and the walk way in. Not saying that Muck boots are for everyone because their not. I put my pant legs inside to keep from the water getting to them, but I also tried them on the outside and a pain in the butt to pull down around.......
-
Do you put your pants outside your boots? I tuck pants inside boot, then zip striker bibs over the outside of everything!
I don't wear street clothes under my bibs, just a base layer and fleece mid layer. My bibs and jacket are uninsulated Gore-Tex.
-
This is sorta a tough one because different areas in the country see different conditions. I primarily fish NE Wis and we get a healthy dose of snow with slush under it, but we get a solid helping of bitter cold. The rubber boots, I've used Muck are great for seasonal days. My go to boots are LaCrosse Hunt Pac Extremes. 2000Gs and waterproof. I got them for less than 40.00 and have never looked back.
(http://i.imgur.com/hrSK3A6.jpg)
-
Use to use sorel high artics toasty warm but not waterproof bulky and hard to walk in on snow. Switched to muck artic pro's warm and dry easy to walk in.
-
I've worn the same pair of sorels for 35 years, can't bring myself to give them up. Have never had cold feet. Mink oil rubbed on them once or twice a winter kept them in excellent shape. The soles have disappeared and now I have hex head metal screws in there, and the heels for traction. They are a PITA to walk in, so I only wear them when on the snowmobile, which is the only way I go fishing. I wear regular insulated boots in the truck and change them when I get to the spots I fish. Forgot to change them one time last winter and couldn't figure out why my feet were cold, then I saw that I had the regular boots on. I don't know what to buy because of all the variety that's out there. Maybe the sorels will last a few more years.
-
How do the Muck Artic Pros fit? I'm a 10.5 or 11 depending on the shoe.
-
How do the Muck Artic Pros fit? I'm a 10.5 or 11 depending on the shoe.
Fairly true to size...I would suggest two things go to a local retailer to test your size with the other Muck models with your sock/liner set up and/or order a size larger ...I like to wear a liner and a wool sock ...a size larger will give you more layering options ..love my mucks ...slip on/off and are warm.
-
Thank you