IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

Maine => Ice Fishing Maine => Topic started by: HardwaterFish on Oct 10, 2013, 08:36 AM

Title: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: HardwaterFish on Oct 10, 2013, 08:36 AM
Well I saw some chatter about trapping bait, the flood gates have opened. Troutaddict and myself have been out a few times and already started collecting more and more chest freezers, and stocking up on bait. Here is some early season bait porn from this past weekend.

(http://i1221.photobucket.com/albums/dd463/hardwaterfish/IMG_20131006_164253_201_zps329c1175.jpg) (http://s1221.photobucket.com/user/hardwaterfish/media/IMG_20131006_164253_201_zps329c1175.jpg.html)

(http://i1221.photobucket.com/albums/dd463/hardwaterfish/IMG_20131006_162234_101_zps6287abe1.jpg) (http://s1221.photobucket.com/user/hardwaterfish/media/IMG_20131006_162234_101_zps6287abe1.jpg.html)


Good Haul:
(http://i1221.photobucket.com/albums/dd463/hardwaterfish/IMG_20131005_181747_266_zps157d5589.jpg) (http://s1221.photobucket.com/user/hardwaterfish/media/IMG_20131005_181747_266_zps157d5589.jpg.html)

(http://i1221.photobucket.com/albums/dd463/hardwaterfish/IMG_20131006_182024_zps9da7cfe9.jpg) (http://s1221.photobucket.com/user/hardwaterfish/media/IMG_20131006_182024_zps9da7cfe9.jpg.html)

Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: NorthernFishFinder on Oct 10, 2013, 11:21 AM
Nice haul HardwaterFish.  I too have been trapping bait for a week or so but haven't put up the numbers like you guys have.  Guess I have to still do some pond searching :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: mainefishpig on Oct 10, 2013, 08:31 PM
I  like to use finer shinner on my bait, that you can order in the mail.   If you trap your bait really early in the year.  Also using a big chest freezer works very well for me also, if you have alot of bait.   I check my bait daily for fungus on the tail of  the bait,  if so it will kill your bait off bigtime.   water change  and finner shinner and  keeping your tank temp under 5o degrees also helps .  And also a regular fish tank airator with a big air stone on it.  thats all I use for the season and works well.    I like the dace shinner for white fish and perch the best becauce they can live in a mudd puddle.  Butt if you have dace over 3 inches or bigger they will eat the heads of you bait, no matter what type of bait you have.   I keep them seperated from the other ones.   
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: nbourque on Oct 11, 2013, 05:06 PM
Good haul right there. I've always had trouble keeping chubs though.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Keptafew on Oct 11, 2013, 06:04 PM
Ive only been scouting around for different places, another couple weeks I will start keeping some. I do well for most species but suckers, is there a secret to finding/trapping them?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: PINSMELT on Oct 12, 2013, 10:17 AM
Gonna head out tomorrow morning and put out some traps.   :tipup:
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: SparkyT on Oct 12, 2013, 12:49 PM
Put out my first bait trap in a pond in the woods behind the house today.  I know it's got creek chub in it, but not sure if it has anything else.  There's another, larger pond not far from here that I'll check next.

I'm not set up for keeping any bait yet, so it's more of a recon mission at this point!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: treeguymark on Oct 12, 2013, 02:16 PM
what are you using for bait ? ive tried everything and im still having trouble getting them to get in my traps ???
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Oct 12, 2013, 03:43 PM
Why start so early I get my bait in one day :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Oct 13, 2013, 01:47 PM
he is a bait dealer rusty. plus... i think he likes to show off  ;D

ill be checking out a few spots this coming weekend.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: treeguymark on Oct 13, 2013, 03:03 PM
i just got back in from putting out my traps , finally found my bait combo that works  7 dz in about an hr soak !! rebaited and set them back in  different spot for the night  should be stuffed full im hoping ! ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Oct 15, 2013, 12:35 PM
he is a bait dealer rusty. plus... i think he likes to show off  ;D

ill be checking out a few spots this coming weekend.

It was more of a joke cause I had such a hard time finding bait last year up till I hit the honey hole
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Keptafew on Oct 15, 2013, 07:56 PM
It was more of a joke cause I had such a hard time finding bait last year up till I hit the honey hole

LOL....... I was going to comment about that very thing Rusty, I remembered you had some struggles early on last year.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: HardwaterFish on Oct 17, 2013, 11:52 AM
I guess I should have said that the bait isn't going into chest freezers quite yet. They are currently in a secure location  @)

Epkomd, I'm not a bait dealer, just to be clear. That is not the point of this.

Rusty, maybe you can share some tips with us  ;)

Keptafew, no big secrets or tricks, you just need to find water with a sufficient supply.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Sparky208V on Oct 17, 2013, 05:42 PM
Anyone ever try or use a clover shaped trap ?   Just finished making one , and going to try tomorrow.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Oct 18, 2013, 08:14 AM
Here is a tip: DONT forget your bait trapping permit for each water you plan on trapping. :P
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: HardwaterFish on Oct 18, 2013, 09:18 AM
Anyone ever try or use a clover shaped trap ?   Just finished making one , and going to try tomorrow.

I have used them a few times, they seem to be productive, but the shape isn't as important as the location of the trap  :)

Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Oct 18, 2013, 09:26 AM
Good haul !  but a little early for me..  Just got all my permits today for the season so I'm about ready to start.

Looking for a large chest freezer right now.. :)  Got my sucker traps out and ready..
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: moosehunter on Oct 18, 2013, 01:46 PM
it needs to be colder for me to start. maybe after this full moon it will cool down.got my own stocked pond so don't have to look around for ponds to trap.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Oct 19, 2013, 07:35 PM
Here is a tip: DONT forget your bait trapping permit for each water you plan on trapping. :P

Correct, I got mine the other day and pulled a few today. Not to many, but I love the size
(http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii213/coach04222/100_2389_zpsaf47d78d.jpg)
(http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii213/coach04222/100_2390_zpse718872c.jpg)

They also told me this will be the last year we might have to do that, new regulations going into next years rules to fix that.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: nbourque on Oct 21, 2013, 07:41 AM
Couple questions for you guys....Been trapping bait for quite a few years now but wondering how you get your tank started? Do you use a little bit of water that you trapped your fish out of or do you start completely with fresh well water with some additive? Also what brand dog food do you find works best/leaves the best slick in the water? Im going to start trapping soon. Thanks guys.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: gamefisher on Oct 21, 2013, 08:30 AM
Couple questions for you guys....Been trapping bait for quite a few years now but wondering how you get your tank started? Do you use a little bit of water that you trapped your fish out of or do you start completely with fresh well water with some additive? Also what brand dog food do you find works best/leaves the best slick in the water? Im going to start trapping soon. Thanks guys.

I hold mine in a lake so can't help you with the first part but Gravy Train has always done the best job for me, not sure why.  Put a handful in an onion sack or piece of mesh athletic bag, will get several pulls without the mess, good luck.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Oct 21, 2013, 10:47 AM
Just got my permits for all the waters I trap bait, and Nels the fisheries bio, said this will be the last season for permits as for next year you will not need a permit to trap bait for personal use unless specified in the book.
 :thumbsup:
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: nbourque on Oct 21, 2013, 11:00 AM
Just got my permits for all the waters I trap bait, and Nels the fisheries bio, said this will be the last season for permits as for next year you will not need a permit to trap bait for personal use unless specified in the book.
 :thumbsup:
You only need a permit for streams and bodies of waters that are closed for the season, correct?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Oct 21, 2013, 11:08 AM
You only need a permit for streams and bodies of waters that are closed for the season, correct?
Correct.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Oct 27, 2013, 10:44 PM
still waiting on dam permits for me, slowest office I have ever seen
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: NorthernFishFinder on Oct 28, 2013, 07:21 AM
I just pulled my last trap for the season on shiners.  Found a new honey hole and was pulling out 75 on an overnight soak and about a dozen suckers on the same.  Earliest I've ever finished my trapping...
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Oct 28, 2013, 05:15 PM
still waiting on dam permits for me, slowest office I have ever seen
I drove over and got mine, took a whole 20 minutes and put my traps in on the way back home
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: MAS on Oct 28, 2013, 05:31 PM
You only need a permit for streams and bodies of waters that are closed for the season, correct?

Forgive me if this is kind of a "dumb" question, but I have to ask... Do waters that are "closed for the season" in Maine mean they have the "CO" letter codes in the "Official State of Maine Open Water & Ice Fishing Laws and Rules" book?  If "special rules" don't include anything about a water being closed, it is fine to trap bait in?
I actually emailed the IFW about a certain place and "permits" and they said:
"All one would need is a fishing license to trap bait for your own use."  So... between this thread and there... a little confusion sets in...

Michele

Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Oct 29, 2013, 06:29 AM
Forgive me if this is kind of a "dumb" question, but I have to ask... Do waters that are "closed for the season" in Maine mean they have the "CO" letter codes in the "Official State of Maine Open Water & Ice Fishing Laws and Rules" book?  If "special rules" don't include anything about a water being closed, it is fine to trap bait in?
I actually emailed the IFW about a certain place and "permits" and they said:
"All one would need is a fishing license to trap bait for your own use."  So... between this thread and there... a little confusion sets in...

Michele
Just go get a permit for for all the water you trap  than there is no questions.  Closed or not. That what I do and you can have up to 5 areas to trap on one permit. :)  You can do it all on line..
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: tkmoney_99 on Oct 31, 2013, 08:12 AM
Going to give this bait trapping thing a try this year. As with most things I am lazy and looking for an easy out. If anyone has a low end bait tank and is looking to upgrade let me know. I would be happy to throw a few bucks at something that works. Plan on keeping them in my uninsulated garage.

Thanks for your time.
TK
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Oct 31, 2013, 11:13 AM
Going to give this bait trapping thing a try this year. As with most things I am lazy and looking for an easy out. If anyone has a low end bait tank and is looking to upgrade let me know. I would be happy to throw a few bucks at something that works. Plan on keeping them in my uninsulated garage.

Thanks for your time.
TK
Do you have a local dump? ussually you can get a old chest freezer there for free , or a blue plastic 55 gallon drum. Than just get a cheap airator at wal mart  and a hang on the side water filter from wal mart and your good to go.  Oh ya a clamp on light for a heat source it will freeze in your garage.. :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Oct 31, 2013, 01:20 PM
Do you have a local dump? ussually you can get a old chest freezer there for free , or a blue plastic 55 gallon drum. Than just get a cheap airator at wal mart  and a hang on the side water filter from wal mart and your good to go.  Oh ya a clamp on light for a heat source it will freeze in your garage.. :)

we call this the "north of bangor model" :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: treeguymark on Oct 31, 2013, 03:56 PM
thats exactly what i run for a bait tank apj !! been trapping and using it all summer and havent lost a single shiner !! :thumbsup:
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Oct 31, 2013, 05:31 PM
Going to give this bait trapping thing a try this year. As with most things I am lazy and looking for an easy out. If anyone has a low end bait tank and is looking to upgrade let me know. I would be happy to throw a few bucks at something that works. Plan on keeping them in my uninsulated garage.

Thanks for your time.
TK
These both works for me

This is 102 quart Cooler
(http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii213/coach04222/100_1704.jpg)

This is 55 gallon plastic barrel that we have drilled holes into and sunk it into the water
(http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii213/coach04222/100_1719.jpg)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Nov 01, 2013, 05:37 AM
APJ, how do you go abou getting the permits online?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 01, 2013, 05:57 AM
APJ, how do you go abou getting the permits online?
I just sent a e-mail to my local biologist in Enfield    describing each location approximatley. And he sends the permit right back same day.

So you should just call your closest fish and wildlife office ask for a biologist  get a e-mail and thats it. :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Nov 01, 2013, 11:31 AM
thanks.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Keptafew on Nov 01, 2013, 01:18 PM
Hey Coach..... I like that barrel idea. I am currently using a big chest freezer in my unheated garage but live right on the shores of a lake and this year I have access to couple barrels. What do you use to cover your barrel? I may try this setup for keeping smelts this year, or switch over to the barrels from freezer once ice forms and not have to bother with aerators and filtering.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Huemorin on Nov 01, 2013, 02:27 PM
Coach I like that.  When I go north to camp which is usually at least 3 days at a time.  I have a large Rubbermaid bin that I drilled a number of holes in and keep them right in the lake.  Nothing better than natural habitat, especially for smelts.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: jacksmelt71 on Nov 01, 2013, 06:28 PM
still waiting on dam permits for me, slowest office I have ever seen
you don't need to wait rusty. as long as the local warden knows you applied you're good to go!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Nov 01, 2013, 08:33 PM
Hey Coach..... I like that barrel idea. I am currently using a big chest freezer in my unheated garage but live right on the shores of a lake and this year I have access to couple barrels. What do you use to cover your barrel? I may try this setup for keeping smelts this year, or switch over to the barrels from freezer once ice forms and not have to bother with aerators and filtering.


We drilled 3/8" holes all around the barrel and drilled a bunch of holes in the bottom.  A friend of mine cut a One (1) foot hole in the bottom of his and covered it with wire in hopes of keeping the water as clean as possible.  For the cover we got a piece of 1" Styrofoam and cut that just smaller then the opening in the barrel, then we screwed the Styrofoam to a piece of plywood attached a handle on it so we had a place to grab. We screwed 2x6's to each side of the barrel and they sit right on the ice.  Wait for the ice to freeze and then cut your hole and drop it in. Cover it with snow and then you can hide it in plain sight.   
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 01, 2013, 09:44 PM
you don't need to wait rusty. as long as the local warden knows you applied you're good to go!

got it the other day...........thanks for the heads up though
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Keptafew on Nov 02, 2013, 05:45 PM
We drilled 3/8" holes all around the barrel and drilled a bunch of holes in the bottom.  A friend of mine cut a One (1) foot hole in the bottom of his and covered it with wire in hopes of keeping the water as clean as possible.  For the cover we got a piece of 1" Styrofoam and cut that just smaller then the opening in the barrel, then we screwed the Styrofoam to a piece of plywood attached a handle on it so we had a place to grab. We screwed 2x6's to each side of the barrel and they sit right on the ice.  Wait for the ice to freeze and then cut your hole and drop it in. Cover it with snow and then you can hide it in plain sight.

I will be trying it out this year...... If all goes well I will transfer the bait in my chest freezer to the barrels, save my back hauling 5 gallon buckets of lake water all winter changing out my bait tank water. Not to mention the cost running equipment.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: ice cracker on Nov 02, 2013, 09:30 PM
set my first first trap today
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lion on Nov 03, 2013, 07:02 AM
My son and I put our first taps out yesterday.... pulled 7-8 dozen in about 4 hours. ..then set back for the night.  Hoping for full traps this morning.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: gamefisher on Nov 03, 2013, 08:05 AM
I will be trying it out this year...... If all goes well I will transfer the bait in my chest freezer to the barrels, save my back hauling 5 gallon buckets of lake water all winter changing out my bait tank water. Not to mention the cost running equipment.

I've been advocating for years that for those fortunate enough to live on a lake or have access to, you can't find a much easier system than the barrel for keeping bait, just freeze it in at first ice and good to go.  I have a 2" piece of styrofoam in my lid that helps with freeze ups and just bank the outside of the barrel with snow.  Can't get photobucket to work right now but the bottom of my barrel is completely cut out and replaced with 1/4" screen sitting on a wooden frame.  If you don't do something like this you will experience a lot of die off in short order.  I keep 25+ doz. all season long in this setup.   In times of prolonged cold or lack of use you will need to chisel the inside a bit at times but chips off easy on the plastic.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Keptafew on Nov 03, 2013, 11:37 AM
I've been advocating for years that for those fortunate enough to live on a lake or have access to, you can't find a much easier system than the barrel for keeping bait, just freeze it in at first ice and good to go.  I have a 2" piece of styrofoam in my lid that helps with freeze ups and just bank the outside of the barrel with snow.  Can't get photobucket to work right now but the bottom of my barrel is completely cut out and replaced with 1/4" screen sitting on a wooden frame.  If you don't do something like this you will experience a lot of die off in short order.  I keep 25+ doz. all season long in this setup.   In times of prolonged cold or lack of use you will need to chisel the inside a bit at times but chips off easy on the plastic.

The Lake I live on is dam controlled and water level decreases significantly throughout the winter so I would have hard time sitting it on a wooden frame off the bottom but the idea of making a frame and setting on top of ice is ideal for my location. Would you suggest drilling a lot of holes on sides and bottom or cut the bottom right out altogether and screening it closed???
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: gamefisher on Nov 04, 2013, 02:03 PM

The Lake I live on is dam controlled and water level decreases significantly throughout the winter so I would have hard time sitting it on a wooden frame off the bottom but the idea of making a frame and setting on top of ice is ideal for my location. Would you suggest drilling a lot of holes on sides and bottom or cut the bottom right out altogether and screening it closed???
(http://i142.photobucket.com/albums/r106/gamefisher_photos/dcp_20812.jpg)
(http://i142.photobucket.com/albums/r106/gamefisher_photos/DCP_2082.jpg)

Not sure how much fluctation we are talking, maybe two barrels fastened end to end to create a "sleeve" if that dramatic of a water level change??? :-\
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: NorthernFishFinder on Nov 06, 2013, 08:46 AM
Anyone have any idea how one day my trap can have 70-80 shiners, then I reset the trap and throw it in the same spot and get only a dozen or so? I'm using the same bait, same trap, and leaving them for an overnight soak.  It will go up and down like that with each day and seems like this year I can't seem to be consistant with the trapping...
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: gamefisher on Nov 06, 2013, 08:53 AM
Anyone have any idea how one day my trap can have 70-80 shiners, then I reset the trap and throw it in the same spot and get only a dozen or so? I'm using the same bait, same trap, and leaving them for an overnight soak.  It will go up and down like that with each day and seems like this year I can't seem to be consistant with the trapping...

I've always felt that moon and weather factors effect bait trapping just like they do fishing and hunting, after all, bait trapping is really a form of fishing if you think about it.  I don't know why but my bait traps always seem fullest around a full moon.  I like to pull just before dark also, seems better in general. 
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 07, 2013, 10:59 AM
Anyone have any idea how one day my trap can have 70-80 shiners, then I reset the trap and throw it in the same spot and get only a dozen or so? I'm using the same bait, same trap, and leaving them for an overnight soak.  It will go up and down like that with each day and seems like this year I can't seem to be consistant with the trapping...
That happens all the time just keep at it.. you have trapped the bait out right near your traps  just wait a while and more will find it..  I got 92 shiners yesterday and 14 today so same thing.. :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 07, 2013, 11:22 AM
That happens all the time just keep at it.. you have trapped the bait out right near your traps  just wait a while and more will find it..  I got 92 shiners yesterday and 14 today so same thing.. :)

Early start this year huh
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: pegasus on Nov 07, 2013, 05:36 PM
Anyone ever try or use a clover shaped trap ?   Just finished making one , and going to try tomorrow.
I have made two and they fish great. The only trouble I have is that I made my openings too big in one trap and I've caught 12 inch pickerel in it.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 08, 2013, 10:12 AM
Early start this year huh
Ya I found a awesome honey hole last year late and could not make in there, so this year I started a little early so i could drive right to it. All golden shiners getin 10 dozen every 2 days.. :thumbsup:
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 08, 2013, 05:35 PM
I may chuck out a trap just to see how the bait is looking this year.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Nov 09, 2013, 04:24 AM
ive tried two ponds recently that are loaded with bait, you can see huge schools of em everywhere. Any particular reason they aint entering my traps?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: nbourque on Nov 09, 2013, 06:11 AM
ive tried two ponds recently that are loaded with bait, you can see huge schools of em everywhere. Any particular reason they aint entering my traps?
try suspending your traps.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 09, 2013, 05:16 PM
ive tried two ponds recently that are loaded with bait, you can see huge schools of em everywhere. Any particular reason they aint entering my traps?
Ya  I tie a 2 liter soda bottle to it this time of year and just let it float around  and that seems to work pretty good,..
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 12, 2013, 11:09 AM
this cold has me thinking bait real bad
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: ice cracker on Nov 12, 2013, 04:57 PM
just caught 81 shiners in one trap
24 hour soak
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Raquettedacker on Nov 12, 2013, 04:59 PM
Wheres all the pictures this season??    I miss not being able to trap my own bait.....
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 12, 2013, 05:19 PM
Wheres all the pictures this season??    I miss not being able to trap my own bait.....

its still early
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 13, 2013, 11:14 AM
just caught 81 shiners in one trap
24 hour soak
Thats a good haul!   I checked mine last night  and a 48 hour soak produced 100 even..  Just picked up a nice like new chest freezer that I'm pimping out to a nice bait tank..  Should have pics up in a couple of days. ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 13, 2013, 11:27 AM
Thats a good haul!   I checked mine last night  and a 48 hour soak produced 100 even..  Just picked up a nice like new chest freezer that I'm pimping out to a nice bait tank..  Should have pics up in a couple of days. ;D
 

You have ice yet on your bait areas
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: ice cracker on Nov 13, 2013, 04:13 PM
with the this layer of ice on the bait ponds right now it sure makes it harder to get the traps out there.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 13, 2013, 04:41 PM
with the this layer of ice on the bait ponds right now it sure makes it harder to get the traps out there.
 

I'm just hoping for a little more so I can get on my ponds
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Nov 13, 2013, 06:37 PM
 

I'm just hoping for a little more so I can get on my ponds
How much you got up there? The ice lasted all day on the bait ponds down here to bad its going to warm up for the weekend.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 14, 2013, 05:25 AM
 

You have ice yet on your bait areas
Yes a skim coat   it sucks setting traps too.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 14, 2013, 05:28 AM
Set up my new bait tank last night come out pretty sweet. I can keep another 500 extra in this one.. ;D

(http://i1236.photobucket.com/albums/ff452/sadchandler/trapping%20bait/2013newbaittank001_zps5d9157fd.jpg)
(http://i1236.photobucket.com/albums/ff452/sadchandler/trapping%20bait/2013newbaittank002_zps8c5c97da.jpg)
(http://i1236.photobucket.com/albums/ff452/sadchandler/trapping%20bait/2013newbaittank003_zpsd498532d.jpg)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 14, 2013, 08:36 AM
looks good APJ
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 15, 2013, 03:28 PM
bait pond had two inches of ice but it was soft ice so couldn't get out on it
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 19, 2013, 01:32 PM
no ice on the bait pond today so I threw out a trap will check it in a few hours
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: allextremesfishing on Nov 19, 2013, 06:17 PM
no ice on the bait pond today so I threw out a trap will check it in a few hours

how did you do
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 19, 2013, 06:25 PM
got 28 in little over 2.5 hours.  I had to pull the trap for the night its suppose to get down to 15 so Hopefully I can get on it Thursday and set as many as possible cause if we get the 8-12 inches of snow they are calling for I can't get in to the spot without trailering my sled and all that mess so I want as many as possible by weekend
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: treeguymark on Nov 19, 2013, 07:28 PM
8-12 inches of snow ?!!! :unsure: :unsure: where the h... are you located !!!lol
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 19, 2013, 08:29 PM
8-12 inches of snow ?!!! :unsure: :unsure: where the h... are you located !!!lol


Northern Maine little town called Mars Hill
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Nov 19, 2013, 08:42 PM
Set my first bait traps of the season today. Gonna go back and check them Thursday or Friday.  Hopefully got some luck
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 19, 2013, 08:51 PM
Set my first bait traps of the season today. Gonna go back and check them Thursday or Friday.  Hopefully got some luck

I have to empty mine twice a day once I get ice
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Nov 19, 2013, 09:08 PM
No ice here yet. And I can't check them that often. Checked them once a day the last few years, produced more over a few day soak.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 19, 2013, 10:46 PM
I found a honey hole that produces 6 types of bait so my traps are loaded day and night now if the snow holds off so I can get in if not its going to be lots of walking and hauling gear. I got spoiled last year.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 20, 2013, 05:19 AM
I found a honey hole that produces 6 types of bait so my traps are loaded day and night now if the snow holds off so I can get in if not its going to be lots of walking and hauling gear. I got spoiled last year.
About time  Rusty  Took a year but you finnaly found some..   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: NorthernFishFinder on Nov 20, 2013, 07:01 AM
What are folks using as an "intake" on their filters?  No matter what I seem to put on the end of the hose, every now and then I get a shiner that gets sucked up to it and dies.  Only thing I've found that works is to put the intake high in the tank, but then it does not filter the water as nicely as I'd like.  Any ideas?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: moosehunter on Nov 20, 2013, 07:25 AM
I put a plastic cap and on the end and drilled small holes in it. seems to help some.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 20, 2013, 09:36 AM
What are folks using as an "intake" on their filters?  No matter what I seem to put on the end of the hose, every now and then I get a shiner that gets sucked up to it and dies.  Only thing I've found that works is to put the intake high in the tank, but then it does not filter the water as nicely as I'd like.  Any ideas?
 

I took some window screening and zip tied it so that it has a big ball around it keeps them from even getting close
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 22, 2013, 02:18 PM
Was able to walk out on bait pond but it was cracking good so I didn't make big holes but 2 inches
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Nov 23, 2013, 06:46 AM
So I hauled 1 of my 3 traps last night. He other 2 ice froze in around them and cut my lines as I tried to pull them to shore. The one trap had about 3 dozen large shiners and a few meduim dace mixed in. Got to go back today and try to free the other 2 traps. Then I guess I have to wait for a little more ice to reset them
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Hoodoo on Nov 23, 2013, 08:35 AM
What are folks using as an "intake" on their filters?  No matter what I seem to put on the end of the hose, every now and then I get a shiner that gets sucked up to it and dies.  Only thing I've found that works is to put the intake high in the tank, but then it does not filter the water as nicely as I'd like.  Any ideas?
piece of PVC pipe with little holes all the way to the bottom??
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: allextremesfishing on Nov 24, 2013, 03:20 PM
WIll a airator and filer be enough disturbance in the water to keep it from freezing in a 18 gallon plastic tote left in a garage?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Brookieslayer20 on Nov 24, 2013, 03:30 PM
If that's not enough try one of those clamp on heat lamps
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 24, 2013, 06:58 PM
pulled over 20 dozen tonight on a 3 hour soak
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 24, 2013, 07:10 PM
(http://i943.photobucket.com/albums/ad279/malysha2181/fish.jpg) (http://s943.photobucket.com/user/malysha2181/media/fish.jpg.html)


So I think I am getting a mix of these including the hybrid
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: allextremesfishing on Nov 24, 2013, 07:12 PM
(http://i943.photobucket.com/albums/ad279/malysha2181/fish.jpg) (http://s943.photobucket.com/user/malysha2181/media/fish.jpg.html)


So I think I am getting a mix of these including the hybrid

these make up 98% of my bait
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 24, 2013, 07:13 PM
the hybrid or the dace
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: allextremesfishing on Nov 24, 2013, 07:20 PM
the hybrid or the dace

both i get some nice redbellys, and the finscae are twice the size of the hybrids. i guess ima start getting a few dozen for early season. 3 traps should make me set for the month of dec. then ill be fishing smelt and emeralds.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 24, 2013, 08:55 PM
(http://i943.photobucket.com/albums/ad279/malysha2181/bait.jpg) (http://s943.photobucket.com/user/malysha2181/media/bait.jpg.html)

My bait pull from today
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Nov 25, 2013, 06:04 AM
(http://i943.photobucket.com/albums/ad279/malysha2181/bait.jpg) (http://s943.photobucket.com/user/malysha2181/media/bait.jpg.html)

My bait pull from today
Nice haul..  Where are those shiners? ???
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Nov 25, 2013, 03:19 PM
What is the most bait you have ever got in one trap? I set my first 2 trap of the year yesterday hauled them today and one trap had over 800 shiners in it!!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 25, 2013, 07:58 PM
What is the most bait you have ever got in one trap? I set my first 2 trap of the year yesterday hauled them today and one trap had over 800 shiners in it!!
   was that a clover trap
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 25, 2013, 08:03 PM
Nice haul..  Where are those shiners? ???

(http://i943.photobucket.com/albums/ad279/malysha2181/shiner.jpg) (http://s943.photobucket.com/user/malysha2181/media/shiner.jpg.html)

I only got a half dozen but I had never got any from this water before.......what do you guys find if you have a bait pond chucked full of different species of dace but there shiners how do you target the few shiners.  I have plenty of dace and would like to get the bigger shiners..........I did put in my clover trap today that will only capture big bait as it was made with a 3/8 inch mesh wire
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: phatptrck1 on Nov 25, 2013, 09:10 PM
what do you guys use for bait bait? pm me if youd like, i'm putting a bait trap in a beaver pond out back tomorrow am.

i heard of using dog food in a mesh bag. not sure which brand or what else works best.

 i don't have any mesh bags so i'm hoping a sock is an adequate replacement  ???
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: tipman14 on Nov 25, 2013, 09:27 PM
I have used dog food in a onion bag .
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: phatptrck1 on Nov 25, 2013, 09:33 PM
I have used dog food in a onion bag .


tried that earlier actually but the holes seem a bit big, food was falling out pretty easy.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 25, 2013, 09:36 PM

tried that earlier actually but the holes seem a bit big, food was falling out pretty easy.

thats fine some people "go naked" and just put the food in the trap
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Keptafew on Nov 25, 2013, 09:36 PM
Cheetos..... seriously, they work very well
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Nov 25, 2013, 09:51 PM
No Rusty it was just a normal 2 hole style trap, it was 3/4 of the way full of fish my best trap before this was just over 300. I cant understand how that many packed in there.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: tipman14 on Nov 25, 2013, 10:04 PM

tried that earlier actually but the holes seem a bit big, food was falling out pretty easy.

maybe we just using different onion bags mine has tiny holes.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 25, 2013, 10:05 PM
No Rusty it was just a normal 2 hole style trap, it was 3/4 of the way full of fish my best trap before this was just over 300. I cant understand how that many packed in there.

That is sweet, love it when you pull them up and all you see is black
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 25, 2013, 10:06 PM
maybe we just using different onion bags mine has tiny holes.

yep there are two styles I like the smaller hole ones
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Nov 25, 2013, 10:50 PM
Also a quick fact mature creek chub never feed before 1100  cool fact
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 01, 2013, 02:52 PM
Just rounded the tanks today  with 100 dozen in each..  I'm ready to fish now! ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Dec 01, 2013, 05:55 PM
I tried a new spot yesterday. Put one trap in a tiny little rock ledge pond by my house. Didn't think I would find anything. Left it overnight. Checked it this morning, over 12 dozen medium shiners. Set it back and went back at 330 this afternoon. And had more in it than the overnight soak. I guess I found my new favorite spot
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 02, 2013, 11:42 AM
I tried a new spot yesterday. Put one trap in a tiny little rock ledge pond by my house. Didn't think I would find anything. Left it overnight. Checked it this morning, over 12 dozen medium shiners. Set it back and went back at 330 this afternoon. And had more in it than the overnight soak. I guess I found my new favorite spot

wish I found one like that myslef
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Dec 02, 2013, 01:59 PM
I went back again last night and pulled the trap and had another 3 dozen shiners
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Dec 02, 2013, 04:46 PM
Didn't take long for the traps to start getting stolen, I hate crooks!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Dec 02, 2013, 06:52 PM
Where were your traps stolen from?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 03, 2013, 08:03 PM
going to put mine back out tomorrow fill up both tanks I got a new one up and going to seperate them lot easier to grab what you want early in the am
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Dec 04, 2013, 03:21 AM
Didn't take long for the traps to start getting stolen, I hate crooks!

yup. it sucks. i set em out at dark now, and pull em at dark. i see alot of places near the roads i want to trap, but i wont.

ill only trap waters off the beaten path now. a little more work, but it beats having to buy new traps constantly.

checking a big beaver bog thursday. hopefully it produces.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Dec 04, 2013, 03:26 PM
I just found this pond last year after having 4 traps stolen at my old pond, its about 400 yards from a road and you can't even see any water from the pavement, sadley I think it was a deer hunter.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 05, 2013, 08:50 AM
Hi guys, I have a quick question about trapping bait. I go to school up in the 'County' and I do a good amount of ice fishing up here as well. I tried to catch some bait last year in a pond close by that is open to ice fishing with no luck, so this year I want to try and trap some of the rivers and smaller ponds that are closed to fishing during the winter time. Are the wardens/biologists willing to give us trappers written permission for the most part?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 05, 2013, 10:52 AM
Hi guys, I have a quick question about trapping bait. I go to school up in the 'County' and I do a good amount of ice fishing up here as well. I tried to catch some bait last year in a pond close by that is open to ice fishing with no luck, so this year I want to try and trap some of the rivers and smaller ponds that are closed to fishing during the winter time. Are the wardens/biologists willing to give us trappers written permission for the most part?

I have found in the county they do ask a few more questions about where, what, and why........I did get denied a portion of a waterway do to bass being present they were concerned that I would catch juvenile bass and then use them elsewhere, but for the most part its easy,,,,,but time consuming it seems to take a week or two of calling to get ahold of someone.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 05, 2013, 05:01 PM
Thanks for the info! Appreciate it and I will make some calls once I do a bit of scouting around the Presque Isle area!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 05, 2013, 05:25 PM
Thanks for the info! Appreciate it and I will make some calls once I do a bit of scouting around the Presque Isle area!

I could help you out I'm not far from there
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: mainefishpig on Dec 05, 2013, 05:54 PM
You need to talk to a biologist,   that's what my area game warden told me..    He told me that the biologist will  give you a permit to trap it our not.  He knows what areas of water are open for trapping of live bait.   Good luck,  the game wardens will check you and they will fine you also.   I think it is not legal  to trap streams or rivers for bait also,  not sure. 
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 05, 2013, 06:04 PM
you can trap streams and rivers just have to have a permit if its closed to ice fishing.....if its open to fishing at the time you want to put the trap in you can without a permit.  yes you do have to talk to the biologist up here the wardens will not give you a permit
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 06, 2013, 11:06 AM
you can trap streams and rivers just have to have a permit if its closed to ice fishing.....if its open to fishing at the time you want to put the trap in you can without a permit.  yes you do have to talk to the biologist up here the wardens will not give you a permit
So easy down here in Lincoln  Just e-mail the local biologist and 30min later you have a permit. I thought it was that easy everywhere.. :-\
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 06, 2013, 11:10 AM
Question?  Can anyone tell me where I can get bio media like the ceramic or plastic balls that I can fill a 2 liter bottle with and add a air line to?  Saw this on you tube and it looks awesome in a bait tank for keeping it clear and clean.  No room to add it to my filter system.  Going to Bangor so maybe there?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: FRESH-BAIT on Dec 06, 2013, 01:09 PM
I'm...................BA CK!!!!!!!!!!!!
Such a long story, anyways  your looking for the ceramic filter media.  You need to go to petsmart or petco or to any good petshop they should have what you need just ask them.  Or look online,  ebay....     Walmart wont carry it.   For my filters I go to the dollar store and just buy a few packs of the scrubbies.   and thats my bio-filter media.   
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 06, 2013, 01:27 PM
I attach a tray under my waterfall filter with 3-4 of the used old filters and it works like a charm. Drill small holes in the tray and it will drain
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 06, 2013, 01:32 PM
(http://i943.photobucket.com/albums/ad279/malysha2181/filter.jpg) (http://s943.photobucket.com/user/malysha2181/media/filter.jpg.html)

its not fancy by anymeans but keeps my water crystal clear after it cyles
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: tkmoney_99 on Dec 06, 2013, 01:38 PM
Is it legal to bait trap in brooks and streams? If so, any chance I will actually catch any shiners in streams this time of year?
Thanks in advance for any information.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Dags Bait Maine on Dec 06, 2013, 05:44 PM
If its open to recreational fishing, than it is open to trapping bait with a recreational fishing license, and vise versa.

-Dylan
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 06, 2013, 09:51 PM
If its open to recreational fishing, than it is open to trapping bait with a recreational fishing license, and vise versa.

-Dylan

It has to be open during the time you put your trap in
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 07, 2013, 03:14 PM
I attach a tray under my waterfall filter with 3-4 of the used old filters and it works like a charm. Drill small holes in the tray and it will drain
Thanks  Rusty and freshbait.. I will try that for now RUSTY.. ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: FRESH-BAIT on Dec 09, 2013, 07:47 AM
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v700/FRESHBAIT/assembled.jpg)

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v700/FRESHBAIT/bucketfiltercomplete.jpg)

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v700/FRESHBAIT/IMAG0140-1.jpg)

Quick shot at my small set up from last year due to small space requirments.  It held 30dzn med shiners, chubs, killifish all winter.   Total investetment on it was $40 I think.   thats buying the barrel, the pond pump, filter material, some odds and ends PVC pieces and tubing.   Theres a complete build up in the Bait trapping thread under DIY 55gal barrel bait tank.   

link to that thread, hope it works
http://www.iceshanty.com/ice_fishing/index.php?topic=234648.0


This was my setup a few years ago when I had the space, 30gal tote as filter with a 2000gph pond pump with a 400gal tank. 
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v700/FRESHBAIT/FILTER142.jpg)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: MaineOutDoorTv on Dec 09, 2013, 08:45 AM
We are sitting on 17 dozen shiners after just one weekend of trapping with 2 traps!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 12, 2013, 06:19 AM
done with the shiners now and trapping suckers  they are comming in good now  need 10 dozen for the winter got 7 dozen this past week. ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: tkmoney_99 on Dec 12, 2013, 06:59 AM
0 for 4 on my trap so far in the Westbrook area. A couple of quick questions. Do you guys suspend your traps? I have tried Purina,Kibbles and Bits ,Cheez Its and Chicken in a Basket for bait so far. No Luck :P :P :P

I am guessing I just have not found the right spot yet. 24 hour soaks and not a sign of a shiner. Well... Sebago Bait here I come. lol..
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: MAS on Dec 12, 2013, 07:15 AM
I tried trapping bait for the first time this year, I only got a few.  Could be where I went, or...

When I was talking to an older fisherman last week though, he asked me if my trap was black - and it is.  He said silver traps catch more bait.

He could be spinning a yarn, but I plan on putting it to the test next year.

Michele
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Brookieslayer20 on Dec 12, 2013, 07:46 AM
Silver traps work much better and I've noticed that as soon as it gets consistently cold and there's a lot of ice  I just don't catch nearly as many shiners, a few dozen a day.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Dec 12, 2013, 07:50 AM
0 for 4 on my trap so far in the Westbrook area. A couple of quick questions. Do you guys suspend your traps? I have tried Purina,Kibbles and Bits ,Cheez Its and Chicken in a Basket for bait so far. No Luck :P :P :P

I am guessing I just have not found the right spot yet. 24 hour soaks and not a sign of a shiner. Well... Sebago Bait here I come. lol..

yes, suspending your traps makes a big difference as far as shiners go. try adding in a ball of aluminum foil or some styrofoam. works for me.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 12, 2013, 08:19 AM
I tried trapping bait for the first time this year, I only got a few.  Could be where I went, or...

When I was talking to an older fisherman last week though, he asked me if my trap was black - and it is.  He said silver traps catch more bait.

He could be spinning a yarn, but I plan on putting it to the test next year.

Michele

I have painted the black ones with silver paint and still have black ones as well, were I trap it doesn't matter, its more of a location thing...I find that the closer to shore near the weeds is the best for me.  The farther I get from the shore and weeds the less bait I get but bigger bait.  I'm not sold on the color of the trap theory
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 12, 2013, 08:58 AM
0 for 4 on my trap so far in the Westbrook area. A couple of quick questions. Do you guys suspend your traps? I have tried Purina,Kibbles and Bits ,Cheez Its and Chicken in a Basket for bait so far. No Luck :P :P :P

I am guessing I just have not found the right spot yet. 24 hour soaks and not a sign of a shiner. Well... Sebago Bait here I come. lol..
I suspend my traps only in beaver flowages or murky waters, Lakes and ponds go right on the bottom .  Dog food and bread work best for me and pieces of styrofoam.

Also move around and spread the traps out.. I use 12 traps and I can cover some ground. :)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: alpha bite on Dec 13, 2013, 04:58 AM
I heard the same thing about black traps.  I'm trying for tommy cods right now, but so far no luck.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: JustForTheHalibut on Dec 14, 2013, 07:59 PM
I haven't trapped much this year, but I use silver traps. Only problem is much more visable, but if you  not 3 feet off the road should be good.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: woodchip on Dec 14, 2013, 08:33 PM
Tom Cods are in the brooks in September.  I can get a few  now but they move in to spawn in Sept.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: alpha bite on Dec 15, 2013, 06:03 AM
I got a few yesterday.  Gotta go see if I can still find my trap soon.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Dec 15, 2013, 08:13 PM
Scored a new bait tank, now I have another setup if needed. This baby will hold some fish
(http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii213/coach04222/Hunting005_zps800cacb7.jpg)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Dec 15, 2013, 10:30 PM
did you get that from beans coach? when i worked in the warehouse, i was always eyeing those and thought they'd make a great tank.

if so, how'd you get one from em?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lunkahville on Dec 15, 2013, 11:07 PM
There was probably a post about this somewhere along the way. What does everyone use to catch suckers? We use a homemade barrel trap, similar to what you use for shiners just bigger. It works but numbers are low. Anyway to pickup more?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 16, 2013, 11:06 AM
There was probably a post about this somewhere along the way. What does everyone use to catch suckers? We use a homemade barrel trap, similar to what you use for shiners just bigger. It works but numbers are low. Anyway to pickup more?
I made this homemade trap its 48 '' x 20''  square. I made two and they work really well for suckers.
(http://i1236.photobucket.com/albums/ff452/sadchandler/trapping%20bait/IMG_0739.jpg)
(http://i1236.photobucket.com/albums/ff452/sadchandler/trapping%20bait/IMG_0740.jpg)
(http://i1236.photobucket.com/albums/ff452/sadchandler/trapping%20bait/Suckerhaultrapping003.jpg)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lunkahville on Dec 16, 2013, 11:17 AM
Thanks Eric. We haven't even started trapping yet. But will have to try building one of these and see if there is a difference
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 16, 2013, 12:49 PM
Thanks Eric. We haven't even started trapping yet. But will have to try building one of these and see if there is a difference
Yup  1/2 inch conduit and a vice and about 12 ft of hardware cloth 3 ' ..  improved my catch to about 80%.. ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lunkahville on Dec 16, 2013, 01:41 PM
Thats good, I would go from 2-3 fish a week to one week will give us all we need. Gonna shy away from the big tackle and suckers and keep running the big shiners.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Dec 16, 2013, 04:10 PM
did you get that from beans coach? when i worked in the warehouse, i was always eyeing those and thought they'd make a great tank.

if so, how'd you get one from em?
Yes, they purchased some new ones and these have some damage to them (holes mostly). I will see if I can get another that is in descent shape.

What area did you work. I do the catalog distribution for the company.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Dec 16, 2013, 04:32 PM
The same pond I was pulling 100 per trap each day has shut off 4 traps 3 day soak and 4 shiners. Anyone know why?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Brookieslayer20 on Dec 16, 2013, 04:37 PM
Around where I live as soon as there's solid white ice, and it's been real cold for over a week or so I have the same issue, some guys say when the water gets really really cold they go down into the mud, or maybe they just don't feed nearly as much, just what other people have told me and my experience.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: pimplejigger84 on Dec 16, 2013, 04:42 PM
Good haul right there. I've always had trouble keeping chubs though.

You know there is a pill that you can take for that...
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: pimplejigger84 on Dec 16, 2013, 04:48 PM
I wish we could trap our own bait and use it later on in New York. It seems pretty fun and you guys seem to have made quite the hobby out of it!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Epkomd on Dec 16, 2013, 04:51 PM
Yes, they purchased some new ones and these have some damage to them (holes mostly). I will see if I can get another that is in descent shape.

What area did you work. I do the catalog distribution for the company.

I worked low bay stock the past 2 years there. couldnt get back in time from my summer job to pick it up again this peak season. gave a good little boost in income during the holiday season. oh well. maybe ill go back next year. Ive got a couple friends working over there right now.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: dgilliam on Dec 16, 2013, 07:25 PM
I worked low bay stocking this season for awhile I got done and went back lobstering I didn't like stocking it was so boring
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 21, 2013, 05:46 PM
Anyone on here trap bait in the South Portland/Greater Portland area? I am fairly new to the world of baiting but I am desperate for some advice and bait. I'm eager to go fish but it's tough with the bait shops not having any and my inability to trap some. I have been setting traps in different small ponds around South Portland and Scarborough at different water levels. I have used bread, dog food, and styrofoam all with no luck. I usually let them sit for 24 hrs. and then move spots. Can anyone try to point me in the right direction? Will trade tips for tips! Good luck to all.

Thanks, DJ
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lunkahville on Dec 21, 2013, 06:05 PM
Let them soak for a little while longer, and try keeping them on bottom. If you can see where a tree has fallen in the water set up next to it..... gravy train dog food is what we use and have good luck. just my .02
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 21, 2013, 06:50 PM
Let them soak for a little while longer, and try keeping them on bottom. If you can see where a tree has fallen in the water set up next to it..... gravy train dog food is what we use and have good luck. just my .02

Thanks for the info. Right now the trap is in about 3-4 feet of water right on the bottom. The pond doesn't get much deeper and surrounded by cattails. I'll keep it in there for a few days maybe move it around the pond a little. I'm just getting too antsy!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lunkahville on Dec 21, 2013, 09:26 PM
Yeah we normally let ours soak for 2-3 days before we go pull it for the first time. If you are around cattails maybe try one next to them and one out in the middle right on bottom....  We caught bait in a beaver bog that wasn't much bigger than 20x20 last year
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Coach on Dec 21, 2013, 09:59 PM
...and if you are using a black trap throw it away, the silver ones work BEST.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: lunkahville on Dec 21, 2013, 10:13 PM
...and if you are using a black trap throw it away, the silver ones work BEST.

How this is an opinion there is no scientific evidence to state this as a fact but it may be plausible, Black traps will still work
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 21, 2013, 10:19 PM
...and if you are using a black trap throw it away, the silver ones work BEST.

I'm using silver ones. I haven't heard too much good stuff about the black ones. I'm going to try a bunch of different locations on this pond. Unfortunately I never tried trapping it before so I'm not sure if there is anything in it but it looks good
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 21, 2013, 10:39 PM
I pulled all my bait with black traps and got over 30 dozen some days.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 22, 2013, 10:01 AM
Well, I am now an official bait trapper! I went and checked my trap today and after a lot of trial and error I finally caught a batch! I believe they are dace, most of them are pretty small but I am sure there has to be some bigger ones. I reset the trap and will check it again. Thanks for all the info guys, your info definitely steered me in the right direction.

(http://i1295.photobucket.com/albums/b639/conley1993/24bd1c24-c6fd-419e-b57c-da84be9b2de1_zps1fd0dea6.jpg) (http://s1295.photobucket.com/user/conley1993/media/24bd1c24-c6fd-419e-b57c-da84be9b2de1_zps1fd0dea6.jpg.html)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: COLD-AS-ICE on Dec 22, 2013, 10:23 AM
All it takes is a little determination. Took me a while to find an area that produced. Trial and error will teach you a lot. Good luck
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Dec 22, 2013, 04:05 PM
Well, I am now an official bait trapper! I went and checked my trap today and after a lot of trial and error I finally caught a batch! I believe they are dace, most of them are pretty small but I am sure there has to be some bigger ones. I reset the trap and will check it again. Thanks for all the info guys, your info definitely steered me in the right direction.

(http://i1295.photobucket.com/albums/b639/conley1993/24bd1c24-c6fd-419e-b57c-da84be9b2de1_zps1fd0dea6.jpg) (http://s1295.photobucket.com/user/conley1993/media/24bd1c24-c6fd-419e-b57c-da84be9b2de1_zps1fd0dea6.jpg.html)
Nice work!  Wait till you get 10 dozen a pull  than you will be jumping for joy.. ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 22, 2013, 04:29 PM
The excitement got the best of me today. After I caught my bait I ran out to a nearby class "D" pond and tried my luck. Needless to say the bait worked well for me! I ended up catching 4 brookies in about 2-3 hours. They were all tank scrubbers but still a fun afternoon on the slushy hardwater. Goodluck everyone and be safe with these warmer conditions!

(http://i1295.photobucket.com/albums/b639/conley1993/0aeef94d-e641-4068-bc47-52491b547cd8_zpsa13cef5e.jpg) (http://s1295.photobucket.com/user/conley1993/media/0aeef94d-e641-4068-bc47-52491b547cd8_zpsa13cef5e.jpg.html)
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: mainejohn on Dec 23, 2013, 07:02 AM
I am thinking about trapping my own bait this year.  Is there anything I should do besides cut a hole in the ice and drop a baited trap down?  this particular pond is closed to ice fishing, but has a ton of shinners!  thanks for any help.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Dec 26, 2013, 04:38 PM
Has anyone ever run into this problem, and if not, what would you do? I have been trapping a pond for about a week now and haven't caught a ton of bait but I have caught more than enough to allow me to go fishing whenever I want without having to buy bait. I am catching a few Mummichog each time I check my traps and about 3-4 dozen sticklefish (which I throw back after each haul) every time I check my traps. Is there any way to better target the Mummichog and avoid the sticklefish? I have had one haul where I got about 2 dozen Mummichog but the rest of them usually have 1-5. There is a small inlet on one side of the pond, should I go there?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: The Rusty Crab on Dec 26, 2013, 04:46 PM
Has anyone ever run into this problem, and if not, what would you do? I have been trapping a pond for about a week now and haven't caught a ton of bait but I have caught more than enough to allow me to go fishing whenever I want without having to buy bait. I am catching a few Mummichog each time I check my traps and about 3-4 dozen sticklefish (which I throw back after each haul) every time I check my traps. Is there any way to better target the Mummichog and avoid the sticklefish? I have had one haul where I got about 2 dozen Mummichog but the rest of them usually have 1-5. There is a small inlet on one side of the pond, should I go there?

I think Mummies like more less turbulent water so I would go further away.  I would trap about 3-5 feet from a good weed bed
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Gfish69 on Dec 26, 2013, 07:59 PM
Mummies like the sun, especially this time of year. Tidal creeks with pools tend to concentrate them at lower tides. Bait with crushed mussels or oily fish like herring . Hope this helps
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: cmstearns on Dec 30, 2013, 01:47 PM
hey im catching small and med shinners and 1-2 large. is there a way to catch more large and less small or is it just a crap shoot. boy It sound's dumb but have to ask. anyone in the Waterboro area would like to share a spot with large bait PM me ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Derik on Dec 30, 2013, 01:52 PM
hey im catching small and med shinners and 1-2 large. is there a way to catch more large and less small or is it just a crap shoot. boy It sound's dumb but have to ask. anyone in the Waterboro area would like to share a spot with large bait PM me ;D

Try a bigger trap, we had those store bought ones and did ok, threw in a homemade one right beside it to up our catch and went from maybe a dozen in the small trap to 3-4 dozen in the big one with a greater number of large and jumbo shiners.  Got a lot of junk stuff too, but it was also a pretty small pond. 
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: cmstearns on Dec 30, 2013, 02:20 PM
Try a bigger trap, we had those store bought ones and did ok, threw in a homemade one right beside it to up our catch and went from maybe a dozen in the small trap to 3-4 dozen in the big one with a greater number of large and jumbo shiners.  Got a lot of junk stuff too, but it was also a pretty small pond.
I built a 18x8x8 trap
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Derik on Dec 30, 2013, 03:58 PM
Ours at the time was three feet long and we used 14" wreath rings on the ends.  It's still kicking around somewhere, haven't trapped bait in a while, but you've probably tried various depths, maybe change up the bait or add something to it to draw in more fish and let the numbers stack up and hope for the best.  Maybe someone out there would trade you a bunch of big shiners for a pile of mediums or something.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: cmstearns on Dec 30, 2013, 04:30 PM
true a trade would be good ;D
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: matthewt on Jan 04, 2014, 08:06 AM
Been trapping bait for several years now and always trap the same flows. Weird thing happened this year. 1 not a lot of bait coming to the traps which has not previosuly been the case. Not sure why, but same honey holes producing maybe 1-2 dozen. I have not hit it too hard they were there all summer. Lastly and the most odd is 3 times I have gone to pull traps and every one of them is dead. This is after 48 hours maximum in 2-3 feet of water. Any thoughts
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: tcfish on Jan 04, 2014, 08:30 AM
Been trapping bait for several years now and always trap the same flows. Weird thing happened this year. 1 not a lot of bait coming to the traps which has not previosuly been the case. Not sure why, but same honey holes producing maybe 1-2 dozen. I have not hit it too hard they were there all summer. Lastly and the most odd is 3 times I have gone to pull traps and every one of them is dead. This is after 48 hours maximum in 2-3 feet of water. Any thoughts

                    I have had the same issue here !!! Couldn't figure it out as the small hornpout would still be kickin ans all the shiners dead .Pulled my traps as not worth my time and effort pulling up dead bait !!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: maineute on Jan 04, 2014, 07:14 PM
Was wondering if this has happened to anyone. Went to check my trap after fishing today, hadn't checked it since Thursday. There wasn't much ice on the hole. chiseled it out went to pull it and only had half come out? I went and got a hook and found it ended up taking off all of my clothes and getting it shoulder deep.
So do you think that I just did not latch it good(been trapping for 2 years now) or is someone sending me a message? I am not real sure, with the fresh snow there were no tracks??? I reset the trap and tried again.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Derik on Jan 04, 2014, 07:41 PM
Was wondering if this has happened to anyone. Went to check my trap after fishing today, hadn't checked it since Thursday. There wasn't much ice on the hole. chiseled it out went to pull it and only had half come out? I went and got a hook and found it ended up taking off all of my clothes and getting it shoulder deep.

If you haven't checked it since thursday and there wasn't much ice I'd be wary that sounds like someone chipped out the hole before you got there.  Some places they are more likely to squish your trap or just take it rather than take the bait and drop half of it down.  You may want to mark the hole and put a big ring on the trap so you can use a pole with a hook on it to pull it up instead of tying it off. 
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: matthewt on Jan 05, 2014, 12:55 PM
That was my feeling to so I pulled them to another place. Been a tough year for bait. I guess I got lazy and did not scout around as much as I should have
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Wolley on Jan 05, 2014, 02:23 PM
the black ones can come apart if the tabs aren't bent enough.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: APJ on Jan 05, 2014, 05:40 PM
Been trapping bait for several years now and always trap the same flows. Weird thing happened this year. 1 not a lot of bait coming to the traps which has not previosuly been the case. Not sure why, but same honey holes producing maybe 1-2 dozen. I have not hit it too hard they were there all summer. Lastly and the most odd is 3 times I have gone to pull traps and every one of them is dead. This is after 48 hours maximum in 2-3 feet of water. Any thoughts
Its fairly common this time of year for all the bait to die in the traps  I had to pull mine a couple of weeks ago due to all the bait dying not enough oxygen in the water. Try checking them daily might help   even the suckers were dying in my traps.. :' :(
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: maineute on Jan 05, 2014, 06:16 PM
Its fairly common this time of year for all the bait to die in the traps  I had to pull mine a couple of weeks ago due to all the bait dying not enough oxygen in the water. Try checking them daily might help   even the suckers were dying in my traps.. :' :(
Thanks for the replies, Air plane - I have never had a problem with them dying in the traps, the beaver bog I am in has moving water. It is also 20 miles away so I cant check it daily. When I lived 2 miles away it wasn't such a big deal. I moved last year and haven't been able to get permission closer to home.
Anyone know where I can trap in Eliot that would be great ;D
For now I am going with, I did not have it together very well. If I show up and it is apart again I will just pull it.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Jan 07, 2014, 04:48 PM
Catching bait has not been good for me lately. The last couple weeks I have been managing to trap 2-3 Mummichog for every 1-2 day soak. A few days ago I finally pulled my traps and threw them in the basement. Today I decided to go set them again at a different location at different depths and locations on the pond. I was so eager to go check them so I checked them after a 4 hour soak and I finally trapped my first batch of Shiners! Needless to say I am super excited to have finally found a pond that produces nice Shiners in abundance! The traps are still soaking and I will be checking them after a day of ice fishing tomorrow. Hopefully I will have more than a dozen this time!


(http://i1295.photobucket.com/albums/b639/conley1993/6cea020c-c34f-4ebd-afe3-a9d077aee448_zpsfd5406a6.jpg) (http://s1295.photobucket.com/user/conley1993/media/6cea020c-c34f-4ebd-afe3-a9d077aee448_zpsfd5406a6.jpg.html)
Title: trapping bait
Post by: adrenaline94 on Jan 13, 2014, 02:57 PM
never trapped bait before, me and my buddy have a couple small shiner traps and wanna give it a whirl for fun, looking for any advice of places to try around durham pownal area, trap depths and what to put in the trap for bait??or any info anyone has would be appreciated. thank you
Title: Re: trapping bait
Post by: WaynefromMaine on Jan 13, 2014, 03:05 PM
  Can't help with your post,  Just wanted to welcome you to the site
Title: Re: trapping bait
Post by: NorthernFishFinder on Jan 13, 2014, 03:07 PM
First off, welcome to the site!  Second, there have been MANY posts about trapping bait that will take hours to read if you use the search box and type "bait trapping" or something of the like...

BUT, to answer your questions directly with my experience, right on the bottom in water a couple of feet deep has always done well for me.  Dog/Cat food in the trap seems to work just fine, but there are many things that can be thrown in to get the bait fish attracted.  Best of luck!
Title: Re: trapping bait
Post by: adrenaline94 on Jan 13, 2014, 03:16 PM
Thanks very much for the welcoming.. and I found a ton of trapping info but so much I was a little confused on where to read first lol
theres a couple of decent brooks and a few small ponds I was thinking of trying to see what happens
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: TinyTim on Jan 13, 2014, 03:29 PM
Welcome to Iceshanty

I merged your topic with the ongoing topic, a lot of info here...

It will be tough to find someone to give up there spots for trapping bait, but if you do some reading, you'll see HOW others do it and then you'll have to do some trial and error in places by you.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: adrenaline94 on Jan 13, 2014, 04:17 PM
thanks alot, ill do some reading and get an idea where to start
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: maineute on Feb 04, 2014, 06:14 PM
Is anyone still trapping? I am done but I have a friend who is still trapping and he hasn't trapped anything for a couple of weeks. When I was still trapping there I was getting 5 or 6 dozen every couple days. I doubt that we have trapped it out. Right now he has 4 traps and isn't getting any bait at all. I am guessing that it is the time of the year. Any ideas would be great. Thanks
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Feb 04, 2014, 06:40 PM
Ive been doing better than ever hauled 150 in a 6 hour soak put the traps back in and pulled over 500 the next afternoon, should hold me over until March.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Feb 04, 2014, 06:58 PM
Ive been doing better than ever hauled 150 in a 6 hour soak put the traps back in and pulled over 500 the next afternoon, should hold me over until March.

That's crazy! Time to buy a bait dealers license and start making some money on the side. What do you have for a setup to keep them all alive?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Feb 04, 2014, 07:40 PM
A bunch of 35 gallon rubbermaid totes with a bubbler and a filter in each one, Ive got a few dozen suckers and smelts on hand as well.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: woodchip on Feb 04, 2014, 08:33 PM
Lot of our small ponds slow up when the snowice covers everything  Cold weather also slows up the flow tru small ponds ,This condition drops the oxygen content in the ponds and fish get very sluggish . probably a stream or flowage with more current would have better oxygen count. And more active bait.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: rockhound57 on Feb 04, 2014, 10:14 PM
Is anyone still trapping? I am done but I have a friend who is still trapping and he hasn't trapped anything for a couple of weeks. When I was still trapping there I was getting 5 or 6 dozen every couple days. I doubt that we have trapped it out. Right now he has 4 traps and isn't getting any bait at all. I am guessing that it is the time of the year. Any ideas would be great. Thanks
I agree with woodchip, 'my' pond goes anaerobic (lo O2) once there is a good snow cover, the water even smells dead (like swamp gas). I have to find areas nearer the inlet, but not too close. I suppose it's due to the relationship of fresh, oxygenated water  vs. bacteria/food levels. My late season catches are very sporadic and counts are much lower (3-5 dozen early season, to 1/2 - 1 dozen late). Try moving around, look for green weed edges closer to fresh incoming water
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: maineute on Feb 05, 2014, 05:44 AM
I agree with woodchip, 'my' pond goes anaerobic (lo O2) once there is a good snow cover, the water even smells dead (like swamp gas). I have to find areas nearer the inlet, but not too close. I suppose it's due to the relationship of fresh, oxygenated water  vs. bacteria/food levels. My late season catches are very sporadic and counts are much lower (3-5 dozen early season, to 1/2 - 1 dozen late). Try moving around, look for green weed edges closer to fresh incoming water
Thanks for the info, We are far from the inlet, makes sense.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Feb 19, 2014, 10:12 AM
I've run into a problem and can't seem to figure out the answer so I'm hoping someone on here can steer me in the right direction. I came home to Southern Maine from college during Christmas break and I found an awesome small pond to trap a ton of shiners. I was catching them daily from the time I found the pond until the time I left to go back to college. Now it is February break and I came back to trap the same pond (1 month later) and I can't catch even one shiner. I have tried a few different spots on the pond and different depths and can't catch any. I'm using silver traps with bread and styrofoam, the same thing I was catching them with before. Has this happened to anyone else and is there something I am doing wrong for this time of the year?
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Feb 19, 2014, 02:49 PM
I've run into a problem and can't seem to figure out the answer so I'm hoping someone on here can steer me in the right direction. I came home to Southern Maine from college during Christmas break and I found an awesome small pond to trap a ton of shiners. I was catching them daily from the time I found the pond until the time I left to go back to college. Now it is February break and I came back to trap the same pond (1 month later) and I can't catch even one shiner. I have tried a few different spots on the pond and different depths and can't catch any. I'm using silver traps with bread and styrofoam, the same thing I was catching them with before. Has this happened to anyone else and is there something I am doing wrong for this time of the year?
Try suspending your traps and putting some right under the ice, I bet saturday you will catch a ton I always do best during warm STORM FREE weather.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: Conley1993 on Feb 19, 2014, 03:50 PM
Heading to Moosehead tomorrow, I will give that a try next time.
Title: Re: 13/14 Bait Trapping Thread
Post by: BrownTroutBoy on Feb 19, 2014, 04:11 PM
Thats a big 10-4. goodluck.