if you ask me id say that the red hook works. a buddy and i were at houghton lake and we got 32 pike in 2 days on tipups with red hooks...only one was a keeper though..all little hammer handles
Can you attribute the good day to the hook color or was it location and bait of choice ?
I have used both a plain hook color and red but not at the same time to see if the hook color really makes a difference .
Hook color may play a small role < very small > in catch ratio but my belief is once again location , scent , sight that will make or break the day .
It would be interesting to see a study done and what the results would be .