IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

IceShanty Main => General Ice Fishing Chit Chat => Topic started by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 03, 2020, 05:11 PM

Title: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 03, 2020, 05:11 PM
Good to see you guys again!

Living in Michigan these days. Can't wait to put out some tip-ups for some pike.

Anybody remember me?
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: PIKE FISHERMAN on Dec 03, 2020, 05:13 PM
Don't remember you, but welcome back!!!!
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: DR.SPECKLER on Dec 03, 2020, 05:37 PM
Nope don’t remember the name but im in Michigan also.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: JohnnyO19 on Dec 03, 2020, 05:42 PM
Good to see you guys again!

Living in Michigan these days. Can't wait to put out some tip-ups for some pike.

Anybody remember me?
Welcome back, I remember your "good old" days from Colorado  ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: 4eyeman on Dec 03, 2020, 06:03 PM
Welcome back Bear.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 03, 2020, 08:45 PM
Welcome back, I remember your "good old" days from Colorado  ;D

I was always a subject of debate, but for a good reason. I would crush those browns, cutts, bows,huge pike...would post pics of all sorts of lunkers caught...had the state record catch and release bluegill, used to post pics of 12-13" gills from 1 special fishery which drew a ton of debate, I think mostly cuz I was a kid outfishing the grown men on here! However I see now why im in Michigan why people thought I was lying about all the trout I caught in Colorado, I used to catch more there in 1 trip  than a whole season in MI, EASILY. A whole year was more trout than Ive ever caught in MI.  Never would I believe someone here in MI if they said they caught 50 trout on the river in the day, ranging from 8-24", lol. Biggest gill I've ever caught in MI was only 9.5", and that was 12 yrs ago. Will say I still do really well on the pike and SMB, did as good on browns as anyone in SE mi this year as well especially considering the trout desert it is, have gotten some really nice walleyes, catfish, etc., very nice fishing in MI if you know where to go for a myriad of species.


I am a professional scientist now at age 32, 10+ patents, multiple articles in scientific journals. Used to draw a lot of ire/debate about my scientific capability on here when I was 16 trying to disseminate the literature and fisheries management, showing how wrong Colorado was to kill their monster pike, smallmouth, rainbows, etc. I can also state now I was right then. BUT I also have much thicker skin and dont give a darn what people think. You think my 32" pike pic is a 30"? Don't care. I also think fishing forums and forums in general are a lot more chill now, so hoping this one has evolved similarly.


I love fishing here in MI and have been at it pretty hard the last 13 years, so I know a thing or two but still learning. I am a bit behind the curve on icefishing though, had to sell a lot of gear including my fl-18, tipups, etc., to get through college and then of course had to pay student loans for years...still paying those but am finally in good enough fiduciary position to start ice fishing again -- it is an expensive hobby after all. But of course the weather has to cooperate, and it is much too warm...

Looking forward to POSITIVE discussions with everyone.

Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Fry Flier on Dec 03, 2020, 08:55 PM
I have only been here a few years myself, enough said other than, Welcome Back.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: trundog on Dec 04, 2020, 05:54 AM
Welcome back!
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 04, 2020, 05:59 AM
BUT I also have much thicker skin and dont give a darn what people think. You think my 32" pike pic is a 30"? Don't care. I also think fishing forums and forums in general are a lot more chill now, so hoping this one has evolved similarly.

My guess is that everybody just got 12 years older (or more) in the 11 years you have been gone.

Probably we are all more grumpy but simply don't feel it is worthwhile to spend our limited energy disputing on a blog.

Just my own observations... ;D ;D ;D

Welcome back.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 04, 2020, 06:52 AM
Well this will be interesting...
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: DR.SPECKLER on Dec 04, 2020, 07:26 AM
Lol.sounds like a perfect candidate to take esox fisherman under his wing...
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: P Meyette on Dec 04, 2020, 09:51 AM
welcome back
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: jimhaney08 on Dec 04, 2020, 11:01 AM
Lol.sounds like a perfect candidate to take esox fisherman under his wing...

 ;D :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: missoulafish on Dec 04, 2020, 11:29 AM
Lol.... I'm just gonna stand over here and watch....
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Iceassin on Dec 04, 2020, 11:50 AM
Lol.sounds like a perfect candidate to take esox fisherman under his wing...

Lol...His kinder, gentler resolution will be tested for sure.  ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: cwavs1982 on Dec 04, 2020, 12:06 PM
Lol.sounds like a perfect candidate to take esox fisherman under his wing...

 ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: POk3s on Dec 04, 2020, 03:35 PM
You sound humble too....

Welcome back!
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 04, 2020, 04:53 PM
You sound humble too....

Welcome back!

Hadda poke the bear...  :P
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: hawg on Dec 04, 2020, 05:05 PM
You sound humble too....

Welcome back!
my thoughts exactly. Likes to type too.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: fishinator on Dec 04, 2020, 05:09 PM
Careful you don't throw your elbow out while patting yourself on the back. Wont be able to fish that way.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 06:04 PM
You sound humble too....

Welcome back!

If you want to hear humble, I've steelhead fished 7 times in 2020, 56 hrs on the water, only bite was an 11" brown trout. To top it off, I sprained my ankle on black friday while hopelessly flailing away (please no Joe Namath comparison). This knowledge that trout fishing is like this in a lot of the country has certainly humbled me back from my 30-50 trout days without much effort on the Colorado River. I've caught 20 trout THIS YEAR.

Unfortunately our ice just isn't here yet in MI, very warm still. So I can't give up steelie fishing...My buddy is taking me out next week though on his boat, since he has caught a handful this year he will let me take first bite (trolling). Course, a bite isn't a guarantee.

I see that iceshanty has a culture that is just as positive as always.  ::)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Roccus on Dec 04, 2020, 06:35 PM
Lol.... I'm just gonna stand over here and watch....
As will I.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Iceassin on Dec 04, 2020, 06:56 PM
For those special occasions


(https://i.postimg.cc/N5hFBhMV/125853712-2959394161013764-856997558745239092-n.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/N5hFBhMV)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 07:02 PM
My sole intention is for positive interaction.

Last year, Iceassin, you were lucky...you guys in SW MI actually had ice better than a lot of mid MI, and of course SE MI where I have been for about 8 years always struggles with ice...Knew a guy in Saginaw who said he never would've dreamed he had to drive 2+hrs north, OR south, to icefish.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 04, 2020, 07:05 PM
For those special occasions


(https://i.postimg.cc/N5hFBhMV/125853712-2959394161013764-856997558745239092-n.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/N5hFBhMV)

I thought we said "No Politics!"   ;D ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: stuckinohio on Dec 04, 2020, 07:11 PM
Welcome back
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 07:39 PM
Welcome back

Thanks! What part of ohio are you stuck in? LOL. Love the name.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 04, 2020, 07:47 PM

I see that iceshanty has a culture that is just as positive as always.  ::)

On second thought... NM.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 08:05 PM
Galatians, 6:7  :)

Not necessarily a bad point. One most certainly creates their own reality, in a way...or at least frames/shapes it, however others do also contribute greatly. I am part of another forum for fishing and have been since basically I left these ones, I have only ever had a negative interaction with 1 member in all those years. I will say I've already got negative interactions from many on this site, just in this post, without any sort of reason for it? Truly a shame. However, I'm going to keep at it though, hopefully I will be able to adhere to the wisdom of Galatians, 6:7.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 08:07 PM
Hey esox, I see you are in SW WI. How far from Menominee, MI? I've never been there, but I've seen at least a decent job in my field there a few times....I keep hearing about the much better fishing (esp for salmon, steelies, lake run browns) on the lake michigan side of wisconsin, as compared to MI...and it has me thinking, since Menominee, MI, basically borders WI...
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 04, 2020, 08:34 PM
Actually it's SE WI. About halfway between Madison and MKE.

Marinette/Menominee is about halfway up the state from me. Plenty of opportunities there. Green Bay to the south on the WI side and LBDN to the north. LBDN has a terrific walleye and perch fishery with some decent pike to be had and GB has really everything that swims in Lake Michigan. Not any kind of trout or salmon guy so can't help with that. I do know that there are plenty of seasonal opportunities from GB all the way south to Milwaukee (and beyond) for spawning trout and salmonids. Spectacular ice fishing for browns and bonus bows right in the harbor @ Milwaukee.

So quid pro quo Mr. Bear. What is your particular arena of scientific expertise? No reason really, just a curious guy...
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Evinrude58 on Dec 04, 2020, 08:40 PM
From what the op has posted so far I think I see what the problem was the first time he left and have the feeling he probably will leave for the same reason again,
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 04, 2020, 08:51 PM
I think that there is room here for all of us. :)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: JohnnyO19 on Dec 04, 2020, 08:55 PM
. Spectacular ice fishing for browns and bonus bows right in the harbor @ Milwaukee.

Saw a video on the ice fishing from some show (last year) with Milwaukee literally in the back ground. I actually think one of the guys took a taxi right to the shore, as he had a late night ;-) They caught some great fish!, I'll try to find it.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 10:12 PM
Actually it's SE WI. About halfway between Madison and MKE.


So quid pro quo Mr. Bear. What is your particular arena of scientific expertise? No reason really, just a curious guy...


Sorry about that, yeah SE WI. Really am impressed with what I've heard of fisheries along that coast, you are lucky to have such a resource. If I get pm back I will talk with you about my career if you are interested, I will say it is related to environmental chemistry...people here used to argue I wasn't a scientist.... well, now I am, and have been for years....really anybody can be a scientist though and we all are to some degree. I want our resources to be here for the next generation, including my own children. :)

Obviously I have big time common ground with everyone here and hope we can have a better time than >11 years ago...I'm only 32, I've been a member here more than half my life!!! Also, we all enjoy our natural resources, and we are all fishing freaks...I mean, come on, we are posting on an ice fishing website!

Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 04, 2020, 10:20 PM
Saw a video on the ice fishing from some show (last year) with Milwaukee literally in the back ground. I actually think one of the guys took a taxi right to the shore, as he had a late night ;-) They caught some great fish!, I'll try to find it.
Urban fishing can offer surprisingly overlooked opportunities, and shouldn't be counted out!
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Iceassin on Dec 05, 2020, 03:36 AM

Sorry about that, yeah SE WI. Really am impressed with what I've heard of fisheries along that coast, you are lucky to have such a resource. If I get pm back I will talk with you about my career if you are interested, I will say it is related to environmental chemistry...people here used to argue I wasn't a scientist.... well, now I am, and have been for years....really anybody can be a scientist though and we all are to some degree. I want our resources to be here for the next generation, including my own children. :)

Obviously I have big time common ground with everyone here and hope we can have a better time than >11 years ago...I'm only 32, I've been a member here more than half my life!!! Also, we all enjoy our natural resources, and we are all fishing freaks...I mean, come on, we are posting on an ice fishing website!

As an older fella here I don't process math quite as well as I used to...and my abacus is on the fritz. But your 32, became a member here 11 years ago, which would put you at 21. Then you say you've been a member here for half your life...which would be 16. Wait...I think I got it. C = pi*r*2, carry the 1, Johnny had 5 apples and...never mind. My head is starting to hurt. I need a nap.  :blink:
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Bucket Rump on Dec 05, 2020, 04:17 AM
He's been a member since 2003, Ice.  Just hasn't been active for the past 11....

Welcome back TFB
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Iceassin on Dec 05, 2020, 05:06 AM
He's been a member since 2003, Ice.  Just hasn't been active for the past 11....

Welcome back TFB

Just going by what he said BR. Sometimes stories just don't add up.  ;)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 05, 2020, 06:19 AM
Just going by what he said BR. Sometimes stories just don't add up.  ;)

Seems to me that both the math skills and reading/observation skills highlighted above point to my old observation that:

"Some of us old farts have aged 12 years or more in the 11 years he’s been gone." Just sayin... ;D ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Iceassin on Dec 05, 2020, 07:20 AM
Seems to me that both the math skills and reading/observation skills highlighted above point to my old observation that:

"Some of us old farts have aged 12 years or more in the 11 years he’s been gone." Just sayin... ;D ;D

> than. Ok, guess I could go with that. But still... ::)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 05, 2020, 08:22 AM
ok we got some fellow goofballs in here now, let's set up the shanty, the card table and crack some beers. Now all we have to wait for is  :tipup:
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 05, 2020, 08:44 AM
ok we got some fellow goofballs in here now, let's set up the shanty, the card table and crack some beers. Now all we have to wait for is  :tipup:

I recommend being kind to the fellow "goofballs" and I plead "guilty" on that account!

Your time is coming, it may still be 30 years down the road, but it is still coming.... ::)

MAYBE you will remember this then, but just maybe - its one of those things... :-\
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 05, 2020, 08:53 AM
I recommend being kind to the fellow "goofballs" and I plead "guilty" on that account!

Your time is coming, it may still be 30 years down the road, but it is still coming.... ::)

MAYBE you will remember this then, but just maybe - its one of those things... :-\

Unfortunately I already act like a crotchety old man. I shudder to think in 30 years... :o

And when I see Mn, I always instantly think of Grump Old Men, the best ice fishing movie of all time! Any ice up there yet Gunflint?
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 05, 2020, 09:10 AM
Unfortunately I already act like a crotchety old man. I shudder to think in 30 years... :o

And when I see Mn, I always instantly think of Grump Old Men, the best ice fishing movie of all time! Any ice up there yet Gunflint?

Minnesota gives authentic meaning to the phrase "Grumpy Old Men"- all other states, including the ones with cheese, are simply wannna bees.

There just started to be fishable ice on the Gunflint Trail. But, I fish Lake Trout and the season won't open for another month so this ice is simply cosmetic.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 05, 2020, 09:16 AM
Minnesota gives authentic meaning to the phrase "Grumpy Old Men"- all other states, including the ones with cheese, are simply wannna bees.

There just started to be fishable ice on the Gunflint Trail. But, I fish Lake Trout and the season won't open for another month so this ice is simply cosmetic.

You just can't resist, can ya?  >:D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Rebelss on Dec 05, 2020, 10:14 AM
Minnesota gives authentic meaning to the phrase "Grumpy Old Men"- all other states, including the ones with cheese, are simply wannna bees.

There just started to be fishable ice on the Gunflint Trail. But, I fish Lake Trout and the season won't open for another month so this ice is simply cosmetic.

Wanna "bees"?  Is this a new declining species? Like the rusty-patched bumblebee?  Enquiring minds want to know.....

One more thing buzzing 'round my head, is an "environmental scientist" a landfill garbage man?  ???


(https://i.postimg.cc/NLBHLRb6/grandpa.jpg) (https://postimg.cc/NLBHLRb6)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 05, 2020, 10:29 AM
You just can't resist, can ya?  >:D

I think that at least part of the reason we Minnesotans so wonderfully excel at being grumpy can be laid at the feet of our local Football team and decades of performance or lack thereof.

Another reason may be, as Rebelss has so kindly pointed out, is simply that we are more honest than anybody else including those from states with "         " (fill in the blank but it begins with "Ch").

 ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Rebelss on Dec 05, 2020, 10:34 AM
We have a football team?!?!??!? Alright!!!!  When did we finally get one?!  :woot: 
Whoops, better get back to the original welcome thread, wherever it was going. I have waffles to make.   :P
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Gunflint on Dec 05, 2020, 10:39 AM
We have a football team?!?!??!? Alright!!!!  When did we finally get one?!  :woot: 
Whoops, better get back to the original welcome thread, wherever it was going. I have waffles to make.   :P

Exactly, it is actually insurmountable for old men in a state with a Football team to truly be grumpy to the level found in Minnesota.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: SLAYERFISH on Dec 05, 2020, 06:20 PM
Lol.sounds like a perfect candidate to take esox fisherman under his wing...

Bwahahaha-
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 05, 2020, 06:28 PM
Everyday presents the opportunity for change...
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: wyogator on Dec 05, 2020, 08:15 PM
Yes, I remember you from the good old days.  I lived in Cheyenne at the time, just north of you.  I fished some of the northern Co lakes, so I read the Co posts.  Welcome back!
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 05, 2020, 10:04 PM
Yes, I remember you from the good old days.  I lived in Cheyenne at the time, just north of you.  I fished some of the northern Co lakes, so I read the Co posts.  Welcome back!

I remember you Wyogator, good to see you again!

And slayerfish, good to see you as well, you still fish elevenmile, antero, cheeseman, etc.?

And Rebelss, no, I'm not a garbage man or landfill management. Creative thinking/razzing wins you a few points though.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: TroutFishingBear on Dec 05, 2020, 10:17 PM
I think that at least part of the reason we Minnesotans so wonderfully excel at being grumpy can be laid at the feet of our local Football team and decades of performance or lack thereof.
 ;D

I mean, you guys lost to University of Michigan this year, had to be awful to do that!!!!...btw I lived in Ann Arbor area most of the last 8 years, about 1 mi away from the stadium for some of it in fact, and take joy in Michigan defeat (sorry 'iceassin') ha!
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Icer for life on Dec 05, 2020, 10:32 PM
Started from the beginning......PRICELE SS.  All I got.
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: SLAYERFISH on Dec 06, 2020, 10:55 AM
I remember you Wyogator, good to see you again!

And slayerfish, good to see you as well, you still fish elevenmile, antero, cheeseman, etc.?

And Rebelss, no, I'm not a garbage man or landfill management. Creative thinking/razzing wins you a few points though.

Fish more in Wyoming now. Too freekin crowded in CO. ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: Rebelss on Dec 06, 2020, 04:04 PM
You never did say if ya got yer hiatus fixed or not.... ;)
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: esox_xtm on Dec 06, 2020, 04:14 PM
I think that at least part of the reason we Minnesotans so wonderfully excel at being grumpy can be laid at the feet of our local Football team and decades of performance or lack thereof.

Agreed. Ain't been the same since Bud Grant  ;)2

Another reason may be, as Rebelss has so kindly pointed out, is simply that we are more honest than anybody else including those from states with "         " (fill in the blank but it begins with "Ch").

Oh, you wanted "honest"? I was trying to be kind...  :roflmao: That can change.  ;D

 ;D
Title: Re: Old School Member is BACK after 11 year hiatius
Post by: primepin65 on Dec 06, 2020, 07:14 PM
Lol.sounds like a perfect candidate to take esox fisherman under his wing...

Dear God in heaven.... don't say dirty things like that on here, speckler!