45" Musky at Greenwood lake, NY side

[TheDL]

whoops...I didn't want to open this can of worms again ("throw back those pike").  He can do whatever he wants with his *legal* fish.  Muskies are few and far between in my neck of the woods, the regs are crazy strict about keeping musky, and it is frowned upon here as they are extremely uncommon to find in all but a few spots.  Also, it takes years to grow one that big - but hey, if they're swimming healthy in your neck of the woods, that's different.

Probly shouldn't have brought that up I guess...but if you can't bust someone's b@11s on the 'net, where can you

Regardless, a VERY, VERY nice catch!

[benny4117]

Nice Fish!

[LingFling]

What a beautiful fish. You'll be happy when you get that mount back and hang it on the wall. Your memories of the catch will flood back every time you look at it. Well done.

[semperfi]

GREAT FISH,,AND FOR WHAT WE PAY FOR NY FEES,,,,IF HE WANTS TO MOUNT IT,,THATS HIS CHOICE,,SOUNDS TO ME THAT SOME PEOPLE MIGHT BE JELOUS,,,NICE JOB,,FISH ON

[jedhead]

Nice fish,  definitley a catch of a lifetime thru the ice. I am 100% release with muskies, but if the fish was legally caught you have every right to keep it if you want it. Guys should realize that , as well as the fact the state of NJ does put alot of muskies in the lake every year. . Tight lines

[mayfield]

congrads it will look good in 8 mounths on your wall 

[MrPike]

DEC site:
Muskellunge, Tiger Muskellunge   All year   Min 36"   Daily limit 1

I stand corrected.  Used to seasons along the St. Lawrence River

[Neversink Jimmy]

Awesome fish...

Glad you weren't slummin' it over on the New Jersey side!

[Powow]

Cograds!!! Great Job!!!

[hamrhandle]

What a beautiful fish. You'll be happy when you get that mount back and hang it on the wall. Your memories of the catch will flood back every time you look at it. Well done.

ill 2nd that!! imo  replicas look like shiny plastic toys.  congrats on a beautiful fish!!