I have recently started trying this too due to the new VHS rules figuring sooner or latter we won't be able to fish with live bait anymore. I have done both salted and garlic to see what works best. I have only been out twice and have set up one salted, one garlic, and one live, but to inconclusive results due to not even getting a flag ( fished with three friends on each occasion who only used live bait they didn't get any flags either) but on both occasions the tippup with one of my garlic minnows came up with a bare hook. I don't know if it fell off or got taken by a fish. I do know i didn't loose it like you do sometimes by hooking the bottom of the hole.