It seems to be personal preference. Been doing as well as anyone on my lakes using mainly a #10 Diamond Jig in glow red and a glow brite nuggie, friend likes a Jiggin Rap and waxie on a dropper, other friend only uses live pinhead minnows. End up with about the same catch every trip though on some nights they will show a definite preference for one over the others. Not opposed to changing one bit when it's obvious.