Adirondack Lake in the town of Indian Lake would provide all the flags you could ask for in terms of keeping your buddies interested. Not a lot of big fish, okay maybe thats an understatement, but there are pike in there that are hungry. I don't really fish South of LG so I dont know any lakes in your area that might help you, but i might suggest looking around your area for ponds that you could get permission to fish. If youre looking to get guys interested in ice fishing you gotta get them onto some fish, pond fishing can be productive and fun for anyone