IceShanty.com's Ice Fishing Community

Ice Fishing Tips -Check your local regulations! => Dressing for ice fishing => Topic started by: otiscohillbilly on Jan 13, 2010, 04:42 PM

Title: advice on gloves?
Post by: otiscohillbilly on Jan 13, 2010, 04:42 PM
Does anyone have the perfect glove out there. I am looking for warmth and functionality! I usually use the fingerless, but this year my hands have really taken a beating from the cold.

Thanks,
Hillbilly
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Drifter_016 on Jan 13, 2010, 04:55 PM
I wear my claw snowmobiling mitts to get to the fishing area and then just put on a cheap pair of insulated work gloves.

The Claw

(http://www.daltonmountain.com/catalogs/choko/pg35.jpg)

And cheapo work gloves.
Buy a couple of pairs and your good to go.

http://www.amazon.com/Black-Stallion-5LWP-WATERPROOF-Insulated/dp/B000UHCC3Q (http://www.amazon.com/Black-Stallion-5LWP-WATERPROOF-Insulated/dp/B000UHCC3Q)
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: 9huskies on Jan 13, 2010, 05:03 PM
My choice in gloves is Gore Windstopper fleece.  It is thin and allows excellent dexterity. It keeps my hands warm in all temperatures even when they are wet.  I have tried a few brands and the best I found is the Mountain Hardware Gravity Glove.  They are my every day winter glove. I get about 2 years from a pair.  They are a bit pricy at about $50 a pair. 
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: iceman260 on Jan 13, 2010, 05:05 PM
icearmor gloves warm waterproof and a pouch for Hot Hands pack toasty warm.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: swillerjig on Jan 13, 2010, 05:09 PM
I use frosty grip gloves they have rubberized palm and they are 5$ warm and excellent grip for taking fish off- and when your done for the day put a little snow or ice on them rub together and it gets rid of the fish smell.  They are very comfotable too.  I will try to post a pic later
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: UFCreel on Jan 13, 2010, 05:09 PM
Brown work gloves. You know the cheap ones. I also have ice armor gloves but they are to hot for me.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: wshnIwsfshn on Jan 13, 2010, 05:10 PM
icearmor gloves warm waterproof and a pouch for Hot Hands pack toasty warm.

I second that icearmor mittens hands done the warmest
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: jsbz on Jan 13, 2010, 05:17 PM
Thats odd because I think my ice armor gloves suck.  My fingers get cold after 15mins which makes me really mad cause I paid a good amount for them. >:(
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: elcapitanmas on Jan 13, 2010, 05:23 PM
original ice armor gloves SUCK!

that being said.  I have a ton of gloves and mittens but the following combo has worked the best for me no matter what the conditions are.  Granted I rarely wear the gloves,  But I used the blue frostee gloves mentioned above, and a pair of HEAVY duty lined mittens that are similar to welding gloves or fireplace mitts, the two pairs cost me about 10 dollars.  The mittens are nice because they are quick on and off, and double as knee pads when kneeling next to a hole during setup, cleanup or fighting a fish.

you can also put heat packs inside of them for REALLY cold days.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: rgfixit on Jan 13, 2010, 05:28 PM
My Eskimo mittens are the best I've found for when I have to wear gloves ice fishing.
(http://base1.googlehosted.com/base_media?q=http://www.fishusa.com/tackleshop/assets/product_images/94053261rb.jpg&size=17&dhm=93195294&hl=en)
RG
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: db1561 on Jan 13, 2010, 05:55 PM
What ever you do do NOT get the Arctic Armor gloves!!  They suck!!
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: fiesty on Jan 13, 2010, 06:02 PM
I like cabelas elk skin chopper mitts...can throw em off fast....last forever...warm...
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: mealworm on Jan 13, 2010, 06:44 PM
ice armor mitts...AWESOME!!
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Scotty D on Jan 13, 2010, 08:14 PM
anything with gortex or thinsulate.   I got a a pair of ice armor gloves for christmas and the palm tore the first time out. needless to say im not happy with them.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: james on Jan 13, 2010, 08:17 PM
Plain ol leather chopper mitts.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: FishinJenn on Jan 13, 2010, 08:46 PM
I wear mechanics gloves w/ wool cut off gloves over them. i spend most of the day bare handed. I keep a pair of fleece gloves in the shanty in case my hands get real cold.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Red Suited Iceman on Jan 13, 2010, 09:37 PM
 On the ice i wear a pair of the plain Mechanix Gloves.  they are easy and fast to get on and off.  i wear them for everything, i must own at least 5 pairs.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Trooper Bri on Jan 13, 2010, 09:49 PM
The original Ice Armor gloves didn't impress me entirely. They were fine unless it got below 20 degrees, then my hands would get cold at times, or not warm up after a fish.
The Ice Armor gloves with the zipper pockets are the Extreme version. They are a gauntlet style glove. I own a pair, but have never used them yet. They seem overkill for most general ice uses. They're probably perfect for the quad ride out.

This year I bought a pair of SnoSuit gloves (a smaller gauntlet style than the IA Extreme), and they got their first ice trials this past weekend. It was 3 degrees and quite windy (about as bad as it gets in CT) when we started, and my hands stayed warm all morning.

Other than that, I use some cheapie poly fleece fingerless gloves when it isn't too cold.

I did used to wear Mechanix gloves too. Wore out the ones I had though. They handle fish well, and when wet, I'd swap them out for a fresh pair while the other ones dried out.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: UpNorth -21 on Jan 13, 2010, 09:56 PM
I agree with the some of the other posts original ice armors BLOW they arent worth the garbage there made of mine lasted about two weeks and had holes all over not worth $30. Im tough on gloves when im fishing but my favorite for setting up is a pair of hodgman neoprenes waterproof and warm and very durable.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: kchamp on Jan 13, 2010, 10:05 PM
icearmor gloves warm waterproof and a pouch for Hot Hands pack toasty warm.
love them
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: troutaddict33 on Jan 13, 2010, 10:09 PM
i like the wool mittes with cut off fingers. the ones where the mitten top flips back. These are the only loves i can actually jig with. Hands get cold, put the lap over my fingers. Best part is, even when wool is wet it will keep you warm
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: cccc on Jan 13, 2010, 10:48 PM
I got a pair of work gloves that are waterproof and insulated. They work well for the in terms of dexterity even with gloves on, and keep me pretty warm.

Only problem is that if it's too cold outside and my gloves are wet, they freeze solid!
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: slipperybob on Jan 14, 2010, 12:47 AM
get some gortex insulated shooting/hunting gloves...they have the maximum dexterity.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: timbobber on Jan 14, 2010, 07:57 AM
rag wool fingerless gloves covered by leather, fleece lined chopper mitts
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: jkoegel on Jan 14, 2010, 08:05 AM
Bought a pair of fleece gloves at Walmart that have a flip open thumbs and a mitten cover on the other 4 fingers. Never have to take them off and they are super warm.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Lost Kangaroo on Jan 14, 2010, 09:54 AM
Flop top hunting mittens..about $8 at Gander...fingers are free for jigging and set up....when it's cold, flop the top back on.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: CJW on Jan 16, 2010, 10:13 AM
Unless I'm jigging, I say F*** gloves.  Even then, my jigging hand has a gortex and thinsulate glove, the other has a light weight cotton glove inside the muff I wear around my waist.  When I'm not jigging, the same cotton gloves, inside my muff, with a hot hands if I feel like it. 

If you're dead set on getting something, get some good mittens.  10x warmer than gloves.

FWIW
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: joejamiejop on Jan 16, 2010, 11:29 AM
Just to set the record straight! Ice Armor Gloves are awesome, I have the regular glove, have used them for a few years now. They are 100% waterproof, warm as any glove that I have ever owned. Easy on off. The only somewhat questionable thing is the durability. If taken care of you can get at least one good season out of them, maybe two at the most. Mine last one season before the crease by my thumb ripped open. I resolved this issue by buying one size bigger. That allows maximum movement. I have used these gloves for fishing, snowmobiling, shoveling, snowblowing, and general use during the winter. Never going to buy another kind!
Joe
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Iceman421 on Jan 16, 2010, 01:51 PM
love them

Ditto. A little bulky for jigging but great for walking out and just for a quick warm up when you get cold.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: CHICKENFOOT on Jan 16, 2010, 01:58 PM
I use Flop top hunting mittens with a Magnet.I found them at Wal-mart and on the top side I put toe warmers with stickum the toe warmers I got at Costco, and warmers don't fall out and I put them in folding top they stay warm and when I want to reel, I just flick my wrist back and the magnet holds them open they work out great.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: HT Redneck on Jan 18, 2010, 09:38 AM
I have found a well worn in pair of thinsulate insulated leather gloves to be about the most versatile hand wear going.  When fairly new treat with snow seal and then break in until soft.  Once broken in they offer a great deal of wind protection and water shedding while still allow for quite a bit of feel and warmth.  Maybe not the best in any one category but all around a top contender.   
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: BillB on Feb 20, 2010, 02:42 PM
There are two generations of the Ice Armor gloves.  The first generation used a micro fleece type material. The second uses a ballistic nylon type material. I have no experience with the nylon type. However, I have owed two pairs of the fleece type. Both have ripped out at the base of the thumb. I returned the first pair (got a couple of dozen trips outta that pair) for the second pair.  Wore those for six trips out and they ripped at the same spot (base of thumb) on both hands. The store I bought them from said I had to contact Clam. I sent two emails (no reply) and made a phone call to Clam (put on hold....no answer).  I expected better out of a Clam product and service.  I'd like to hear how the nylon type are holding up.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: JIGGIN- on Aug 17, 2010, 05:44 PM
I use regular insulated work gloves (the cheap ones) and use fingerless goretex / wind stopper glove for jigging outside if needed. Otherwise I go bare paw.

I suggest looking at OR (Outdoor Research) gloves. They are pricey but they are built for the outdoors mainly for  mountain climbers with removable liners. They have all different kinds of styles.

JIGGIN.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: tippin2back on Aug 17, 2010, 06:25 PM
i go cheap with the gloves.....but i keep extras handy.....
if my hands get cold and wet, there is a extra dry pair to keep em' warm
2-pair of the walmart "mitten fold up thing-a-mah-jobbies", and a pair of insulated work gloves
i wouldnt depend on one pair of gloves..
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Sven936 on Aug 18, 2010, 12:24 AM
I have the Ice Armour extreme gloves and mittens.  Love them. They are durable, warm, and water proof.  I have had them for two seasons.

I also had the regular ice armour gloves. They lasted 3 seasons of heavy use and finally wore out when I was changing a garage door and cable. (Wife back into the door and kept going with the Jeep while it was half way down.) The cable just tore them apart, they were not really built construction work.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: surflizard on Aug 18, 2010, 06:36 AM
Due to making my living working outside for over 29 years and my fair share of work related injuries to the paws, I really have a tough time keeping them warm. Last year a buddy suggested trying the heavy duty latex rubber examination gloves, What a God send, YIPEE, NO MORE COLD PAWS !! I wear them under my Choko Claws for the ride out and set up, then I'm good for the day with the exam gloves. I have enough dexterity with them on to tie knots with 4lb leader line.
The thicker exam gloves cost 7 bucks for a box of  200 pairs, the box lasted the whole ice season and through Spring Salmon season with a bunch left over.  ;D
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: JIGGIN- on Aug 18, 2010, 11:27 AM
Ah that explains it. I thought you didn't want to get the fish smell / slime on your hands or had dermatitis and that's why you wore latex gloves.

Neat idea.

JIGGIN.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: duck doctor on Aug 18, 2010, 11:36 AM
Ah that explains it. I thought you didn't want to get the fish smell / slime on your hands or had dermatitis and that's why you wore latex gloves.

Neat idea.

JIGGIN.

Ya I thought something was up too!
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: michianafisherman on Aug 18, 2010, 11:41 AM
I don't have problems with my hands. I stick them in the water to remove ice and fish. The extreme days I will wear some fingered gore-tex with the gauntlets. I also will wear them for the ride out on the four wheeler. But if you want extreme gloves look to drifters. He would not have a glove that wasn't warm where he fishes.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: tippin2back on Aug 18, 2010, 05:05 PM
Due to making my living working outside for over 29 years and my fair share of work related injuries to the paws, I really have a tough time keeping them warm. Last year a buddy suggested trying the heavy duty latex rubber examination gloves, What a God send, YIPEE, NO MORE COLD PAWS !! I wear them under my Choko Claws for the ride out and set up, then I'm good for the day with the exam gloves. I have enough dexterity with them on to tie knots with 4lb leader line.
The thicker exam gloves cost 7 bucks for a box of  200 pairs, the box lasted the whole ice season and through Spring Salmon season with a bunch left over.  ;D

i was wondering the same as jiggin' "why the doc's gloves" in lizards pics??
we use the same gloves at work. ill have to give em' a try this year, cuz when i cut up the sucker,
 i do it outside, and sometimes when im done, it feels like my fingers arent there...
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: surflizard on Aug 18, 2010, 06:28 PM
Hey Jiggin, another side benefit to the exam gloves,is that I don't get any of my nasty smellin human oil on my bait or jigs ! I've seen enough times that when the Lakers come into the chum pile, they don't pick it up and spit it back out now ! They don't hesitate at any human odor anymore, they gobble it down like the odd uncle and the Turkey that everyone has that shows up for the holidays !  ;D  EXCEPT WHEN THEY GRAB THE ONE WITH THE SHARP POINTY THINGAMAJIG IN IT !   :icefish: :roflmao: :roflmao: :roflmao:
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: surflizard on Aug 18, 2010, 06:49 PM
Your right Michiana, Last year Drifter mentioned the Choko Claws on one of his posts. I found them at the work clothes store just off of the Waterville Valley exit on 93. I think I paid $ 49.00 for them, I'd even pay more for em if I had too ! ;D THEY WORK !! I really like the fact that I can pull out the polypropylene liners to dry em, They have zippered pockets for heat packs and last but not least, The have a nice fuzzy removable and washable snot rocket wiper !! ;D  :roflmao: I really gave those Choko Claws a beating last winter and all they did was get softer !! :thumbsup: :roflmao:
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: northernnyice on Aug 31, 2010, 09:34 PM
love my ice armor gloves. i must have newer ones? i hear guys saying they suck. ive never been able to wear gloves. on ice or in woods. my fingers get cold. ive always needed mitts. this is honestly the first pair of GLOVES that keep my fingers warm. plus i can set up and pick up with them on
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: beerbellybob106 on Aug 31, 2010, 10:43 PM
ice armor gloves are deffinitely the way to go i can stick my hands down the with them on and they stay bone dry on the inside
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: mushroom_capd_1 on Sep 01, 2010, 01:04 AM
I've went with a pair of leather thinsulates last year. I own a pair of the first gen. Ice armour X', and while they are TOASTY warm and they were waterproof, they were not very good "chore" gloves. They were very, VERY warm though!!! I found a tough old pair of snowboarding gloves I'll use again until I buy a snowmobile or I am impressed enough to buy a new pair of icefishing gloves...I'll stick with the leather thinsulates as my "tipup" gloves. You almost need two pairs of icefishing gloves (Or one really WARM DURABLE pair) and thats what I think the manufacturers are gearing towards nowadays. I wont buy if they are not quality gloves anymore. The only way I see fit though to determine if they are really waterproof or not is to take the "watertest"...but I'm babbling and waiting for ICE!!! :icefish:
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Russ-T on Sep 02, 2010, 10:59 PM
I'm going to try the latex gloves out! Thanks Surflizard. For jigging i use the wool fingerless gloves because i can't stand the loss of dexterity from fingered gloves. For the rest of the time I buy all my winter gear in "tall" sizes. That way i can wear no gloves or my wool fingerless and have toasty warm hands and fingers. I simply pull my sleeves down over my hands. Very quick and easy to do and super fast to get my hands out of. Surprisingly warm too.  I can guarantee this will not work for everyone but it's what i preffer. But it does suck when you have to carry a 5lb wet flopping pike 100yards and it's -20 and windy!!!! You wind up with a dry, frozen pike and burning hands since your fingers have to be exposed to hold the critter!  I purchased a pair of duck decoy gloves to try for those conditions this season.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: bart on Sep 03, 2010, 06:00 AM
I rarely wear gloves, if I do, I wear the military wool insert gloves.(see my avatar)
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: slabspanker on Sep 03, 2010, 06:28 AM
I'm not a glove wearer but got a pair for Christmas one year...original ice armor gloves SUCK! mine were never waterproof first steel head i pulled through the hole, the gloves soaked thru. so when cold. i went to the old standby white cotton inserts my dad gets from the electric company. they travel well in a pocket and do not take up much space.
Title: Re: advice on gloves?
Post by: Raquettedacker on Sep 03, 2010, 06:42 AM
Fingerless wool gloves with the pull over mitten part...