Thanks for the input guys! Well, I haven't figured out the cats yet, but we have been constantly catching them! The next week(from original post), we hit the same place and I pulled out three cats in under 10 minutes and then the school left. The next week at the lake, we were searching for crappie and my buddy landed a cat. I quickly came over and in the next couple of hours, we landed 10 cats and lost probably 5. Everytime we know fish this new area and end up catching between 8 and 10 cats. At this spot, they aren't nearly as aggressive...talking #8 jigs with a waxie, and taking very lightly. And they aren't coming through in huge schools; a single or pair cruise through every so often.
We have talked to about a dozen locals, and none have caught a cat through the ice. I found this strange since we are catching them exactly the same as we catch bluegills and perch out of this same lake; so I thought everyone was catching 'em. One thing I have learned...the color pink outfishes any other color at least 2 to 1.
Jim