i got in late, as the original plan was a lake that didnt have good enough ice. we got there around 8 fished till 11 or so, got no flags. my buddy pulled in two perch jigging with half minnows. we were seeing ice on the fish finder, and we could get them to come up off bottom to check out our bait, but couldnt get any bites. we were in 8-10 feet of water. ice was 5 inches and change.