What reel to get for new ice rod ??

[Cold front]

I just got my first Dh custom rod al dente noodle 25 inch, was thinking putting a spinning Pflueger Trion size 20, but was thinking on going with a straight line reel or fly rod reel set up? any suggestions on what reel I would want to look at . And not sure how to attach them on the cork handle, Tape or with the bands?

[matzilla]

tape, cold snap bands, rubber O-rings - they all work
The Trions are very nice (I have 3 size 30's, 1 25 and a 20) and cost effective - you might want to clean up the factory grease and use a light precision machine oil or Quantum Hot Sauce

If you choose inline - do not buy one without giving it a test drive in the store. The common CGI, Eagle Claw, etc inlines have some bad quality control issues but the good reels work well and last quite a while.

[slipperybob]

Cgrtz on the new rod.

Reel...lots to choose from.  And also don't limit yourself to just one type of reel.  Try various ones that let's your hands feel at its most comfort.

Although there is a learning curve and some challenges with a fly reel, it can be equally rewarding and fun as well. 

I personally prefer a baitcasting reel, but that's me.

[Cold front]

OK thanks !! cant wait to get out this winter !!

[jwetovick]

You really don't need to spend more than $30 on a reel if you generally after panfish. I'm mainly talking about spinning reels. The trion is fine, sienna is good, president and Sedona are a bit more but very good. Don't overlook the Tica Cetus reels. The GV500 is about $30 and after cleaning out the grease and lubing with Hot Sauce it is very nice. Good luck with the noodle rod. DH noodle blank is best on the market in my opinion. I build many rods for guys using that blank.

[IceGunner]

I picked up the eagle claw inline (pink) at cabelas, late season, marked down to $19.  Originally got it for my daughter but I used it and love it.  Have only used it 3 trips but it certainly was more reel than I expected.   I will be buying a couple more for sure.  Unless someone recommends an inline at comparable cost that is better.  I use it only when targeting pan fish.

[Cold front]

Ok thanks sounds good

[bigstorm]

I got a DH Custom Al Dente last year and put a Sienna on it, it works great so I replaced a few other reels with Siennas too

[after-4]

Phlueger president.

[Agronomist_at_IA]

I just got my first Dh custom rod al dente noodle 25 inch, was thinking putting a spinning Pflueger Trion size 20, but was thinking on going with a straight line reel or fly rod reel set up? any suggestions on what reel I would want to look at . And not sure how to attach them on the cork handle, Tape or with the bands?

The cold snap bands(castration rings picked up at a farm supply store where you get 100 rings for $1) Are ok, but can be to tight and dig into a cork handle. it happens more so on the cheaper cork handles. Also they loose strength over time and become brittle.  I personally like tommy tape that only tapes to itself and feel it works the best.

What kind of fishing are you doing with the noodle? If your fishing panfish in 10 foot and under, just a simple straight line Black Betty, code blue, or fly reel works well and keeps the line twist off the panfish lures. For finessing panfish With little bumps and jiggles its hard to beat.

If your deeper water I'd look at the geared in line reels, and would look more towards the higher end ones with a good drag system. I found they work great for getting lures up and down, and keeping line twist to a min. I tried one of the high end eagle claws and liked it, but had to return it because the drag was really poor.

[Cold front]

Ya mostly panfish in the 10 depth range

[Cold front]

Ya the tommy tape, is cool might have to try it

[RapidsJigger24]

For spinning reels, the Shimano Sienna is tough to beat for the price as others have mentioned.

If you are looking at geared inline reels, check out the Ice Hopper Extreme line for Sportsmens Direct.  The newest model has a free-spool option, but I personally like the older model better.  They have a great drag system and are a steal when they go on sale!

[3300]

Pflueger® Trion® Spinning Reel good stuff! no problems ever from any of them. i run 5 of them. no need to clean/oil/tear down or replace oils/grease. two of use them about 6 days a week for at least 4 hours a day.

i tried eagle claw in-line junk and sold asap.
i don't want to pull line to get my jig where i want it.

open face only, but might try one of my spare fly reels for kicks this season in one of my shanty's where the line won't freeze like they do on in-lines.

If you are looking at geared inline reels, check out the Ice Hopper Extreme line for Sportsmens Direct.  The newest model has a free-spool option, but I personally like the older model better.  They have a great drag system and are a steal when they go on sale!

they were just on sale @31$ from 39$ probably still on sale.

[stpaulslouch]

In your case I would buy 2.  A cheap inline(Frabill or other)  and a cheap spinning (Shimano Sienna).  This way you'll be prepared if you do take it for deeper water fishing.  I use bands on rods I swap reels out on and good electrical tape on those I don't.  I found that Tommy Tapenis a bit bulky when wrapped on and actually left indents from the reel seat.

[frogmaster]

I just did a bunch of online research and ordered 2 of these:  http://www.cabelas.com/product/fishing/ice-fishing/rods-reels-tip-ups%7C/pc/104793480/c/104735880/sc/104543280/no-8-tackle-co-cold-gear-in-line-ice-reel/1866437.uts?destination=%2Fcatalog%2Fbrowse%2Frods-reels-tip-ups%2F_%2FN-1100502%2FNs-CATEGORY_SEQ_104543280

The overall number of features for the Buck is hard too beat.  Sorry Frabill and Eagle Claw.... you need to UP your game!!!  Lastly the Mr. Gentz Inlines are no better then the E.C. or Frabill either.

Bless

[Agronomist_at_IA]

Ya mostly panfish in the 10 depth range

Then my suggestion would be the straight line fly wheels. My preference was the Black Betty or Code blue from no8 tackle. If you get one get the fender for when you palm grip it.

[Agronomist_at_IA]

I just did a bunch of online research and ordered 2 of these:  http://www.cabelas.com/product/fishing/ice-fishing/rods-reels-tip-ups%7C/pc/104793480/c/104735880/sc/104543280/no-8-tackle-co-cold-gear-in-line-ice-reel/1866437.uts?destination=%2Fcatalog%2Fbrowse%2Frods-reels-tip-ups%2F_%2FN-1100502%2FNs-CATEGORY_SEQ_104543280

The overall number of features for the Buck is hard too beat.  Sorry Frabill and Eagle Claw.... you need to UP your game!!!  Lastly the Mr. Gentz Inlines are no better then the E.C. or Frabill either.

Bless

I found the drag on those to be jumpy no different then the wright and McGill eagle claw version.

[frogmaster]

I found the drag on those to be jumpy no different then the wright and McGill eagle claw version.

Thanks for the Heads Up... I will test it throughly... and if Jumpy Drag I can either RETURN or MODIFY.  I prefer the latter and have several ticks up my sleeve based on the internals.

Bless

[Muskyrush]

From my experience plfuegers really don't hold up well in the cold, the drags get really sticky and and gears start to stick. I have had really good luckwith my shimano sedonas 3 seasons and they still work like the day I bought them and I fish 4-5 day a week.

[Bumski]

From my experience plfuegers really don't hold up well in the cold, the drags get really sticky and and gears start to stick.

 Yep Plfuegers use a grease that is too thick but I always re-lube my reels with Hot Sauce and no troubles......that and I never have drag issues with any reel...I don't use it...I prefer back-reeling if necessary...or my rod does the work..
Smoothness is the key for me...  

Tommy (silicone) tape for me...with 1 wrap of Electrical tape for me...

[Cold front]

Thanks for the info !!

[matzilla]

If the oiled felt drag on a pflueger or shimano reel is bad in the cold weather just open it up and separate the felts and steels, clean the steels off and reoil the felts. I've heard stories of them freezing up due to moisture being trapped inside but I've never had a problem with mine

[Agronomist_at_IA]

If the oiled felt drag on a pflueger or shimano reel is bad in the cold weather just open it up and separate the felts and steels, clean the steels off and reoil the felts. I've heard stories of them freezing up due to moisture being trapped inside but I've never had a problem with mine

last winter I took a few different reels apart and cleaned up re oiled them........wow smooth was an understatement

[Cold front]

Thanks for the tip

[TheMainah]

Pflueger President all day