My 42" ML handles everything from big perch to big Kokanee to big 6+ pound trout. I've got a 38" M Frabill ice hunter that I love as well. But it also depends on if you fish in a shelter much. If you fish inside or do much sight fishing, shorter rods are much more comfortable to use. In that case, I like my 26" L Frabill ice hunter. Never tried the inline reel, although I can see the advantage of having one for shallow water. Wouldn't do much good in deep water though.